Sambalada
8x Platinum Member
Founder of Rankdown ca. 2016
Mmmmmmmm....
Joined: June 2016
Posts: 8,686
|
Post by Sambalada on Jan 15, 2018 19:00:05 GMT -5
So just a quick day 1 recap because im at work - greento0 and barbie most suspicion, came down to wire. We chose to lynch barbie - Albie night killed. Most of us had a town vibe, nothing stood out as scummy. Question is why him? - Milo im torn on, seems to say a couple of things that sound scummy per post (ie if i die tonight vote this way, the general tone of maybe doing too much sound town. yet im still on the fence. Overall useful enough poster. - Sam and Surf- surf has provided more analysis, not consistent but enough and more than most, Sam has been more one line here and one line there. Neither have struck me as anything other than minor FOS but im watching. Albie, Libra and Cynthia were my bigger town leans on DAY 1, i have to not have tunnel vision into thinking because one turned up town the other two gut instincts are correct. - I have to hear way from greentoo becasue he has been way tooooooo quiet and not helpful It seems way too quiet in here. I guess im looking to find out why some of us were so quick to move away from green to barbie especially those who felt strongly on him. and maybe hear from everyone their thoughts? Errmm.. me too. I have no idea what Barbi said on D1 to make everyone vote for him instead of the long-suspected greentoo.
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 19:01:22 GMT -5
GUYS GUYS I'M BACK WOO!
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 19:15:11 GMT -5
So just a quick day 1 recap because im at work - greento0 and barbie most suspicion, came down to wire. We chose to lynch barbie - Albie night killed. Most of us had a town vibe, nothing stood out as scummy. Question is why him? - Milo im torn on, seems to say a couple of things that sound scummy per post (ie if i die tonight vote this way, the general tone of maybe doing too much sound town. yet im still on the fence. Overall useful enough poster. - Sam and Surf- surf has provided more analysis, not consistent but enough and more than most, Sam has been more one line here and one line there. Neither have struck me as anything other than minor FOS but im watching. Albie, Libra and Cynthia were my bigger town leans on DAY 1, i have to not have tunnel vision into thinking because one turned up town the other two gut instincts are correct. - I have to hear way from greentoo becasue he has been way tooooooo quiet and not helpful It seems way too quiet in here. I guess im looking to find out why some of us were so quick to move away from green to barbie especially those who felt strongly on him. and maybe hear from everyone their thoughts? Errmm.. me too. I have no idea what Barbi said on D1 to make everyone vote for him instead of the long-suspected greentoo. There is a few things Barbie said though. I literally posted them a few pages back. While I wasn't certain on her I just felt greento was maybe having language or trouble expressing himself. I thought the strong suspicion was a tad odd on green. But I don't like to rush to judgement or get swayed to lynch someone just cause they quiet
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 19:20:31 GMT -5
What bothered me most about Barbie is she came on way too defensive and that def raised flags.
Milo what are your thoughts? Where iz Libra surf and Cynthia
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 19:26:24 GMT -5
Cynthia to me seemed a bit scummy in Day 1. The way she was silent for ages and then said βOh I forgot I was playingβ just seemed like a cover up, and she had to back it up by saying how she βforgot she was playing last gameβ as well. And then she barely said anything from then on. She might have been being genuine and actually forgot or sheβs talking a lot on the mafia chat and just needs a way to cover it up. In all fairness Cynthia is very forgetful. Literally. However she like everyone else is fos material but that in itself isnt reason enough. If anything if she was scum she would be less inclined to say that? But it could be a tactic. Who knows .
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 21:31:04 GMT -5
So Backwoods was town. Huh. So, people who voted for her: BackwoodsBarbie [5]: greentoo, Libra, Coco, Cynthia, Milo greentoo [3]: BackwoodsBarbie, Sam, Albie Sam [1]: Surf Greentoo voted for her, which doesn't really change any of my thinking of him. Libra voted for her, which kind of puts a dent in my thoughts for him. However, it was just one vote, and he is now my highest town lean. Coco voted for her, and his reasoning felt justified, but read lower to see my updated thoughts on Coco. Cynthia voted for her, and meh? She doesn't really evoke much of a reaction in her posts anymore. I voted for her, but pretty much only to cause a lynch. I discuss this further down. Backwoods AND Albie, two confirmed town players, both voted greentoo. This is either a bad case of Tunnel Vision and confusion, or they were both onto something. Sam voted for him too, which kind of gives me a bit higher opinion of him, but I do think it could just be "I'm directing attention away from me with this." and then there's Surf lol. He voted Sam, which is kind of weird, especially after he went for greentoo so hard. But he wasn't around near the lynch, and he probably thought Sam had a chance of lynch. There really isn't much to say about Albie's NK, pretty predictable I'd say, but I'm holding hope that the watcher or tracker got a reading. A mislynch here wouldn't be the end of the game, but it makes it 2 mafia vs. 3 town. Unfortunately, almost no-one felt anything other than "town lean" on Albie, which makes his game harder to look at. Now, time to look at some quotes! Hehehe zero activities... To start off: One of the reasons I was okay with voting Backwoods was that she never really seemed like a power role, which at the very least made it 2/7 chance that she'd be mafia. Not to mention, I think Libra and Albie are both town, so it made it 2/5. Can you elaborate more on this? What made you think Libra and Albie are 100β
town, and others are not? For starters, thinking is not the same as knowing. I thought that they were, mainly because they both played similar to their previous town , but I wouldn't completely throw them out. I'd certainly defend them though, and would feel confident in counting them town. I prefer a decision to a no decision. I think both are out only choices and I get useless town read of green dunno why. I'm sorry, but I really don't like this post. "I prefer a decision to a no decision". I mean, yeah? That's kinda obvious. From most previous games, the general consesus is lynch is better than no lynch. Is there really a reason to say this? And "I think both are ou tr only choices and I get useless town read of greentoo, dunno why." is just wrong. Yes, no-one else really had a large following aside from them, but people already knew that and mentioned it with more thought. And then "Dunno why". dunno why is basically "Just because" or "Why not?". It basically means nothing. I'm trying to make sense of all that has transpired. Whyyyy. I need to start trusting my first instinct and double back. Nope nope nope and nope. "Whyyyy?" Really? That just immediately screams "Desperate" to me. It's like something I would have done as mafia, and stooping to my level is something you really don't want to do. And on a technical level, trusting your instinct in mafia is not a good plan. Yes, in some circumstances you need to believe in your choices, but your first instinct? I thought normusic was a confused town on first glance in his first game, and look what happened. I thought willapted33 was roleblocker at first instinct in his first game. And I thought you were town at first instinct this game, but now: Vote: CocoSo just a quick day 1 recap because im at work - greento0 and barbie most suspicion, came down to wire. We chose to lynch barbie - Albie night killed. Most of us had a town vibe, nothing stood out as scummy. Question is why him?- Milo im torn on, seems to say a couple of things that sound scummy per post (ie if i die tonight vote this way, the general tone of maybe doing too much sound town. yet im still on the fence. Overall useful enough poster. - Sam and Surf- surf has provided more analysis, not consistent but enough and more than most, Sam has been more one line here and one line there. Neither have struck me as anything other than minor FOS but im watching. Albie, Libra and Cynthia were my bigger town leans on DAY 1, i have to not have tunnel vision into thinking because one turned up town the other two gut instincts are correct. - I have to hear way from greentoo becasue he has been way tooooooo quiet and not helpful It seems way too quiet in here. I guess im looking to find out why some of us were so quick to move away from green to barbie especially those who felt strongly on him. and maybe hear from everyone their thoughts?"Question is, why him?" I really don't know why this quote in particular rubs me the wrong way. I just think that it sounds a little... awkward? It sounds kind of forced, and really does seem like you decided that you needed to end that with a question. Your other reads seem completely fair, particularly mine. but then: "It seems way too quiet in here. I guess I'm looking to find out why some of us were so quick to move away from green to barbie especially those who felt strongly on him, and maybe hear from everyone their thoughts?" I mean, you hadn't provided any thoughts then aside from a recap and a "Townie gone RIP", so you could also provide some analysis too? However, I will answer your question: I found Barbie a town lean. I wrote it in one of my posts with leans, and I mentioned that I'd prefer Green/Sam/Coco/Cynthia to go out before her. BUT, the people voting Backwoods wouldn't back off, and I always doubt myself, particularly my beliefs, so I tried to get into the Backwoods wagon, and grasped at some straws to justify lynching her. And now that the dust has settled, I realise I let myself get played. Cynthia to me seemed a bit scummy in Day 1. The way she was silent for ages and then said βOh I forgot I was playingβ just seemed like a cover up, and she had to back it up by saying how she βforgot she was playing last gameβ as well. And then she barely said anything from then on. She might have been being genuine and actually forgot or sheβs talking a lot on the mafia chat and just needs a way to cover it up. Okay, fair. I kind of agree with your points there, although maybe it's a bit of a stretch with the mafia chat. However, what about talking about anyone else? Are you not going to acknowledge the lynch/NK? Are you going to disappear after a small post? Don't mistake my vote for Coco, I'm still very suspicious of you. In fact, if I had to guess right now, I'd guess a Greentoo/Coco mafia team, as Sam really only got into my suspicion for his relationship with greentoo. Yes please. Woah, that was a big post. Final thoughts: I think greentoo is my biggest suspicion still, but I want people to consider Coco more, especially after their behavior changed from jokey to calmly unhelpful. Surf and cynthia get town leans, Libra gets a strong town lean and Sam gets a very slight town lean. Have fun reading this y'all!
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 21:35:04 GMT -5
#mod: ...bruhPlayers:
1. greentoo 2. Mylo13 π 3. Libra 4. Sambalada 5. @antigonerising 6. Albie (Killed Night 1) 7. BackwoodsBarbie (Lynched Day 1)8. @pma2015 9. surfy I'm about to start issuing temp-bans from future games lol
|
|
Libra
Diamond Member
The One Who Knows Where All the Bodies Are Buried
:)
Joined: September 2003
Posts: 14,376
My Charts
|
Post by Libra on Jan 15, 2018 21:36:13 GMT -5
OK, I definitely need to turn my focus back on, but: One of the reasons I was okay with voting Backwoods was that she never really seemed like a power role, which at the very least made it 2/7 chance that she'd be mafia. Not to mention, I think Libra and Albie are both town, so it made it 2/5. I really don't like this post because I can't shake the feeling that it reads like being "okay" with lynching someone you might still think is Town. Like...you say it was "okay" to vote for Barbie because you didn't think she was a power role, but don't mention how that might have influenced your staying on greentoo. (Not that you should be openly speculating about who might/might not be a power role anyway!) At the very least, this warrants a FOS directed your way. Actually, I'm not sure your math adds up either. You say that you didn't think she was a power role (you were right, she wasn't, but that's not the point), and eliminating those from consideration of what she would be narrowed her odds of being Mafia to 2/7. That does check out. But then you say your belief in both Albie and me being town narrows it to 2/5. Here's the problem. What if Albie had in fact been a power role? Based on the math you supplied, that would make Barbie's odds of being Mafia 2/6, not 2/5, because Albie would fill one of the slots that you already eliminated when you narrowed it down to 2/7. (The fact that Albie wasn't a power role is, again, beside the point.) FOS: Myloninja because this is really making me think that you know too much to be a Townsperson. The only reason I don't just vote you yet is that, let me not totally tunnel in on you. Cynthia was completely right to clock me for that - look what it's made me do already! ;_; We have voting wagons from Day 1 that are worth looking over, and a fresh look at things that were said/did should also be in order. Oh yeah, as we start to gather back around we'll have totally new discussion to add to the pile as well!
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 21:42:04 GMT -5
OK, I definitely need to turn my focus back on, but: One of the reasons I was okay with voting Backwoods was that she never really seemed like a power role, which at the very least made it 2/7 chance that she'd be mafia. Not to mention, I think Libra and Albie are both town, so it made it 2/5. I really don't like this post because I can't shake the feeling that it reads like being "okay" with lynching someone you might still think is Town. Like...you say it was "okay" to vote for Barbie because you didn't think she was a power role, but don't mention how that might have influenced your staying on greentoo. (Not that you should be openly speculating about who might/might not be a power role anyway!) At the very least, this warrants a FOS directed your way. Actually, I'm not sure your math adds up either. You say that you didn't think she was a power role (you were right, she wasn't, but that's not the point), and eliminating those from consideration of what she would be narrowed her odds of being Mafia to 2/7. That does check out. But then you say your belief in both Albie and me being town narrows it to 2/5. Here's the problem. What if Albie had in fact been a power role? Based on the math you supplied, that would make Barbie's odds of being Mafia 2/6, not 2/5, because Albie would fill one of the slots that you already eliminated when you narrowed it down to 2/7. (The fact that Albie wasn't a power role is, again, beside the point.) FOS: Myloninja because this is really making me think that you know too much to be a Townsperson. The only reason I don't just vote you yet is that, let me not totally tunnel in on you. Cynthia was completely right to clock me for that - look what it's made me do already! ;_; We have voting wagons from Day 1 that are worth looking over, and a fresh look at things that were said/did should also be in order. Oh yeah, as we start to gather back around we'll have totally new discussion to add to the pile as well! That is completely fair. I really had no idea the point I was trying to make there, I was really grasping at straws to justify a Backwoods lynch. The math was supposed to be 2/7 (2 maf in 7 non-power roles) and 2/5 (2 mafia in 5 non-power roles/not Albie or Libra, incorrectly forgetting that they could be a power role).
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 21:50:46 GMT -5
Good evening! I'd like to thank mafia for not killing the black players on MLK weekend. That was very considerate of you. Cynthia to me seemed a bit scummy in Day 1. The way she was silent for ages and then said βOh I forgot I was playingβ just seemed like a cover up, and she had to back it up by saying how she βforgot she was playing last gameβ as well. And then she barely said anything from then on. She might have been being genuine and actually forgot or sheβs talking a lot on the mafia chat and just needs a way to cover it up. In all fairness Cynthia is very forgetful. Literally. However she like everyone else is fos material but that in itself isnt reason enough. If anything if she was scum she would be less inclined to say that? But it could be a tactic. Who knows . My mother used to tell me I'd forget on my own ass if it wasn't attached to me, smh. This game will be similar to the last though: I'm only here b/c I'm a replacement so I didn't really plan space in my schedule for this; therefore my time and attention span are both somewhat limited. I'll work on the attention span, but can't do too much about the time. Very quick (re)assessment as of now. - I got very quick town vibes from Coco on day one mainly due to little mistakes that I think a mafia player would try to avoid, and I feel much the same on D2. It's been quiet in here but she was the first person to really lead discussion instead of giving an empty 'oh noes' filler kind of post (not that those kind of posts in and of themselves are absolutely scum tells, but they do stand out to me as noncontributory). - So on that note, yesterday I had Surf penciled in as a town read based on what he had contributed so far. I'm not particularly fond of him coming in with an empty post and not having anything else to say. Same goes for Sam, minus the town vibe of course. It's not a lot to go on but it is enough for me to FOS them for the moment. - Libra has not posted yet so I have nothing other than my D1 hunches to look back on. I initially felt null about him but inched towards a town read at the end of the day...so for now I'll have to give an 'n/a' for my opinion on him. - Mylo, like Libra, he has not spoken on D2, so I need to hear more from him before deciding where my current opinion lands. - I agree with Coco that Barbie's quick defensiveness is ultimately what did her in. She was arguably even more absent than I was, and when she did appear it was to cave in just b/c she had two votes on her. Honestly it's just hard to distinguish sometimes between a scum tell and a 'new player who still hasn't quite gotten the hang of this' tell... - and that brings me to greentoo. Frankly his D1 play seems scummy because he was quite reticent to put his thoughts on screen, and the thoughts he did put out there had very little reasoning to back them up. His lone D2 post is a bit better - I'm not scum, but there is a decent attempt at reasoning/FOS'ing there which is what a town player should do. Now with that said I'd like to see him give an opinion on everyone in the game - or put another way, if I were scum, who else do you think could be scum with me? Who do you think is probably not scum? We have two players to find so we have to evaluate everybody.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 21:51:59 GMT -5
ah, that's what i get for not refreshing, will read mylos posts now
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:05:54 GMT -5
Melania you're doing a little too much. I can understand trying to piece together and provide commentary is important but so far you're either shading people lol or you're jumping and lumping people together rather quickly. This is the second time you have partnered greentoo with someone. This time it's me, yet you didn't vote greentoo. You voted Barbie. Which makes me wonder if your casual look at greentoo but don't forget about Coco remark is basically you trying to throw greentoo under the bus? Legitimately or not? I don't know but eyebrow raising.
You say I'm jokey and calmly unhelpful but yet you give surf a town lean. I think I've been equally as present if not more. I've tried to not zero in and provide some discussion without just blindly omgus everything something is said.
But to be honest I'm having a hard time pinpointing things to tie one person much less a duo but
" If I'm dead this night, and greentoo is the lynch and mafia, I'd suggest looking into Sam. If he's town, I wouldn't really have any specific person that you should go for (I mean, I'm probably the person who tackled him the hardest).
For Backwoods, I wouldn't know either way. The people who have gone for her the hardest seem like the more established players, which of course means it is more hard to read their play. "
If this isn't the most eyebrow raising thing yet. It seems I dunno, off? You have been shady all game but have come out super aggressive lol odd
I still would like to hear from others and I don't think I'm going to allow my general annoyance throw me off but there is something jarring about your gameplay and I don't know if it's how you are or if it's for show . Haven't made up my mind yet. I'm a woman I'm allowed to change my mind
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:09:19 GMT -5
I think what's rubbing me the wrong way is that you are on me for saying a lynch is better than no lynch which we all agree with actually the right philosophy on D1 not later in the game but day 1. Yet you said what I said in different words here " If none of the four players currently not voting greentoo (Not including greentoo) honestly don't feel like lynching greentoo, I will throw a vote towards BackwoodsBarbie, but I'd rather Green, Sam and maybe even Coco or Cynthia over them. Although, like I mentioned, all but Sam and green give me town leans. The only players I would genuinely defend against are Libra and Albie.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:11:52 GMT -5
Why change your mind just to vote like someone else if you feel strongly about
However I think it would be foolish on me to zero in on you because that is not smart .
I want to learn more about Surfboardt because I know he is busy and while I have nothing to base w read on him yet he has been super quiet and I want to hear his thoughts overall since D1 ended.
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 22:13:32 GMT -5
Melania you're doing a little too much. I can understand trying to piece together and provide commentary is important but so far you're either shading people lol or you're jumping and lumping people together rather quickly. This is the second time you have partnered greentoo with someone. This time it's me, yet you didn't vote greentoo. You voted Barbie. Which makes me wonder if your casual look at greentoo but don't forget about Coco remark is basically you trying to throw greentoo under the bus? Legitimately or not? I don't know but eyebrow raising. You say I'm jokey and calmly unhelpful but yet you give surf a town lean. I think I've been equally as present if not more. I've tried to not zero in and provide some discussion without just blindly omgus everything something is said. But to be honest I'm having a hard time pinpointing things to tie one person much less a duo but " If I'm dead this night, and greentoo is the lynch and mafia, I'd suggest looking into Sam. If he's town, I wouldn't really have any specific person that you should go for (I mean, I'm probably the person who tackled him the hardest). For Backwoods, I wouldn't know either way. The people who have gone for her the hardest seem like the more established players, which of course means it is more hard to read their play. " If this isn't the most eyebrow raising thing yet. It seems I dunno, off? You have been shady all game but have come out super aggressive lol odd I still would like to hear from others and I don't think I'm going to allow my general annoyance throw me off but there is something jarring about your gameplay and I don't know if it's how you are or if it's for show . Haven't made up my mind yet. I'm a woman I'm allowed to change my mind Okay then. Did you read my post? I explained why I voted you over greentoo. And why I called you jokey and calmly unhelpful. And why I gave Surf a town lean. And yes, that post I made is bad, but if I was killed, I wanted to leave my thoughts there. And you do remember how I called you out for using "Dunno why?". Dunno, off is virtually the same thing. But to be fair, these games always freak me out. I love them, but god it panics me.
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 22:15:07 GMT -5
I think what's rubbing me the wrong way is that you are on me for saying a lynch is better than no lynch which we all agree with actually the right philosophy on D1 not later in the game but day 1. Yet you said what I said in different words here " If none of the four players currently not voting greentoo (Not including greentoo) honestly don't feel like lynching greentoo, I will throw a vote towards BackwoodsBarbie, but I'd rather Green, Sam and maybe even Coco or Cynthia over them. Although, like I mentioned, all but Sam and green give me town leans. The only players I would genuinely defend against are Libra and Albie. My argument was that you shouldn't have needed to mention it. And if I'm correct, that post doesn't mention needing to lynch, because I implied it instead.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:15:15 GMT -5
Libra clocking people for maths is always a good sign I think?
re: myloninja's thoughts, your dislike of Coco's 'whyyyy' post is also the reason I side eyed Sam and Surf. Coco at least tried to return with something moderately substantive, which I don't feel that Surf or Sam did, really. So it seems a bit odd to me that you'd single her out for it and then give those two town leans.
I also don't think asking 'why [albie]' is that offputting. It's not something worth spending a ton of discussion over but it doesn't hurt to at least briefly wonder about it either. I don't want this to come off as letting her off the hook necessarily, but if Coco were going to be nailed for that question it should only be because the answer to the question is so obvious, not because it feels awkwardly placed there.
putting aside possible alignment I also get the sense that you generally are having a bit of a hard time adjusting to Coco's posting style (same as some of us might have problems with greentoo) so that's something to keep in mind.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:17:16 GMT -5
it would be really nice if proboards' thread search function wouldn't break every five fucking minutes
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 15, 2018 22:17:43 GMT -5
Why change your mind just to vote like someone else if you feel strongly about However I think it would be foolish on me to zero in on you because that is not smart . I want to learn more about Surfboardt because I know he is busy and while I have nothing to base w read on him yet he has been super quiet and I want to hear his thoughts overall since D1 ended. I didn't change my mind. I felt strongly against greentoo, but I knew a lynch was more important than my "gut feeling", so I voted Backwoods. And if you're talking about voting you, then I think I also explained that in my post. Continue.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:21:57 GMT -5
Why change your mind just to vote like someone else if you feel strongly about However I think it would be foolish on me to zero in on you because that is not smart . I want to learn more about Surfboardt because I know he is busy and while I have nothing to base w read on him yet he has been super quiet and I want to hear his thoughts overall since D1 ended. I didn't change my mind. I felt strongly against greentoo, but I knew a lynch was more important than my "gut feeling", so I voted Backwoods. And if you're talking about voting you, then I think I also explained that in my post. Continue. I'm not blaming you for that . I'm just saying you're side eyeing me for saying a lynch is better than a no decision when you basically said or implied the same thing. That's a tad hypocritical. At that point in the game we were going to lynch either green or Barbie. I felt Barbie was defensive and I thought the rush on Green was a reach . I still feel it's a reach. The only reason he would have been voted out was he was not providing any info and still isn't. That could be scum laying low or it really could be he is having a hard time with expressing his thoughts. I dunno.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 22:24:40 GMT -5
greentoo can you give a few thoughts per person so far even if it's one line we won't judge as long as you're putting something down that you mean.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 15, 2018 23:12:34 GMT -5
"Good evening! I'd like to thank mafia for not killing the black players on MLK weekend. That was very considerate of you."
I dunno why I chuckled but the least these white folk could do.
|
|
surfy
Diamond Member
Irreplaceable
learning and growing
Joined: September 2013
Posts: 18,064
Pronouns: (she/they)
|
Post by surfy on Jan 16, 2018 0:59:49 GMT -5
HAI everyone! I have info that will either blow this game wide open or destroy me and town in the process so I have to be careful!
So I am going to claim right now, I am the Town Tracker, and since thereβs only two mafia and the other is Tracker-immune. I either found the Town Watcher or Watcher-Immune Mafia last night visiting Albie - and that person was none other than Myloninja.
So for reasons that I shouldnβt have to justify with the above Vote: Myloninja if he is lynched and confirmed scum, my role is now considered useless so I have nothing to lose!
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 16, 2018 1:02:00 GMT -5
HAI everyone! I have info that will either blow this game wide open or destroy me and town in the process so I have to be careful! So I am going to claim right now, I am the Town Tracker, and since thereβs only two mafia and the other is Tracker-immune. I either found the Town Watcher or Watcher-Immune Mafia last night visiting Albie - and that person was none other than Myloninja. So for reasons that I shouldnβt have to justify with the above Vote: Myloninja if he is lynched and confirmed scum, my role is now considered useless so I have nothing to lose! Oh, damn, a double reveal. I AM THE TOWN WATCHER.
HOWEVER, ALL IS NOT LOST. I ACTUALLY WATCHED ALBIE LAST NIGHT, AND SAW THAT COCO VISITED HIM. COCO IS CONFIRMED MAFIA NOW.
|
|
surfy
Diamond Member
Irreplaceable
learning and growing
Joined: September 2013
Posts: 18,064
Pronouns: (she/they)
|
Post by surfy on Jan 16, 2018 1:07:57 GMT -5
HAI everyone! I have info that will either blow this game wide open or destroy me and town in the process so I have to be careful! So I am going to claim right now, I am the Town Tracker, and since thereβs only two mafia and the other is Tracker-immune. I either found the Town Watcher or Watcher-Immune Mafia last night visiting Albie - and that person was none other than Myloninja. So for reasons that I shouldnβt have to justify with the above Vote: Myloninja if he is lynched and confirmed scum, my role is now considered useless so I have nothing to lose! Oh, damn, a double reveal. I AM THE TOWN WATCHER.
HOWEVER, ALL IS NOT LOST. I ACTUALLY WATCHED ALBIE LAST NIGHT, AND SAW THAT COCO VISITED HIM. COCO IS CONFIRMED MAFIA NOW.well shit something is happening regardless they canβt kill all town at this point
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 16, 2018 1:14:23 GMT -5
If no counter-claims happen (Which I'm pretty certain won't), then I'd like to point out that all confirmed town players have been suspicious of greentoo as well.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2018 1:24:55 GMT -5
HAI everyone! I have info that will either blow this game wide open or destroy me and town in the process so I have to be careful! So I am going to claim right now, I am the Town Tracker, and since thereβs only two mafia and the other is Tracker-immune. I either found the Town Watcher or Watcher-Immune Mafia last night visiting Albie - and that person was none other than Myloninja. So for reasons that I shouldnβt have to justify with the above Vote: Myloninja if he is lynched and confirmed scum, my role is now considered useless so I have nothing to lose! Oh, damn, a double reveal. I AM THE TOWN WATCHER.
HOWEVER, ALL IS NOT LOST. I ACTUALLY WATCHED ALBIE LAST NIGHT, AND SAW THAT COCO VISITED HIM. COCO IS CONFIRMED MAFIA NOW.I know that is not possible and I knew you were being deceptive from the start. Very quick to out yourself as a town watcher to draw the town watcher to out themselves after Surfs report. Very convenient. Now things make sense. You could have easily defended yourself before that rather scummy claim. You're are not town watcher . If I was watching someone on the first night it would have been greentoo btw. Vote:myloninja13
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2018 1:32:57 GMT -5
I know y'all confused as to who but I just ask if Milo was watcher and he watched me and as he says knows Im scum. Why earlier today on d2 in greentoo still his biggest suspicion.
" I think greentoo is my biggest suspicion still, but I want people to consider Coco more, especially after their behavior changed from jokey to calmly unhelpful. Surf and cynthia get town leans, Libra gets a strong town lean and Sam gets a very slight town lean. Have fun reading this y'all!
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2018 1:33:12 GMT -5
#mod: forgot to mention, it takes 4/7 votes to lynch. The following is an unofficial vote count:
Coco [1]: Milo Milo [2]: Surf, Coco
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Jan 16, 2018 1:59:43 GMT -5
Oh, damn, a double reveal. I AM THE TOWN WATCHER.
HOWEVER, ALL IS NOT LOST. I ACTUALLY WATCHED ALBIE LAST NIGHT, AND SAW THAT COCO VISITED HIM. COCO IS CONFIRMED MAFIA NOW.I know that is not possible and I knew you were being deceptive from the start. Very quick to out yourself as a town watcher to draw the town watcher to out themselves after Surfs report. Very convenient. Now things make sense. You could have easily defended yourself before that rather scummy claim. You're are not town watcher . If I was watching someone on the first night it would have been greentoo btw. Vote:myloninja13Coco, please don't. If there isn't a counter-claim, and you obviously aren't, then I am the town watcher. Don't go down with this, say some post about how we're all just haters and how you'll rebound in the next life or something. This is not going to work. IF NO-ONE ELSE CLAIMS TOWN WATCHER, I AM CONFIRMED TOWN WATCHER. DOES ANYONE OBJECT?
|
|