Red Presents: Through the Years (done)

[Red]

#46 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 16
Low: 50
Highest Point: 35
Lowest Point: 46

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 0
Top Tens: 0
Top Halves: 3
Bottom Tens: 3
Bottom Fives: 3
#50s: 1

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 35
aerodynamite - 39
American Idiot - 36
wrip - 44
wheatsquares33 - 44
rowellfarm490- 42
zippy - 38
BB🌕 - 43
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 42
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 43
samo🦕 - 45
willapted33 - 44
MoD - 46

[zippy]

Dang, so close to my bottom 4 songs going out first. I don't expect this closeness to continue moving forward.

[Red]

That chorus is a fucking earworm, I had it in my head for weeks after listening to it for the first time.

also, ngl, I laughed the first time the "Helter Skelter" sample popped in, and now, I look forward to it every time I listen to it

---

#46
Skinny Puppy
Worlock

Points: 236
Standard Deviation: 10.92
Where I'd Rank It: #50
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #47

Rankings
zippy - 16
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 18
American Idiot - 22
singingrulebritannia - 29
wheatsquares33 - 31
aerodynamite - 32
rowellfarm490 - 32
willapted33 - 33
@trilogy - 37
HamedM1 💔 - 38
MoD - 43
BB🌕 - 48
wrip - 49
samo🦕 - 50

Movements
35 39 36 44 44 42 38 43 42 43 45 44 46

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Quantum Leap
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
L'Via L'viaquez
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
The Man Comes Around
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Slow Emotion Replay
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Hole in the Sky
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[Red]

#45 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 21
Low: 49
Highest Point: 42
Lowest Point: 47

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 0
Top Tens: 0
Top Halves: 5
Bottom Tens: 4
Bottom Fives: 2
#50s: 0

5th Lowest SD

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 47
aerodynamite - 45
American Idiot - 45
wrip - 42
wheatsquares33 - 46
rowellfarm490- 45
zippy - 44
BB🌕 - 42
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 43
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 44
samo🦕 - 44
willapted33 - 45
MoD - 45

[wheatsquares33]

Boooo at the ATD song in the bottom 5
Worlock was a v cool discovery though. Didn't love the Jesus Lizard song, but I am interested in listening to the full album

[singingrulebritannia]

It's been pretty sad watching At The Drive-In go from loved to not that well-liked on Pulse. I fear that if we re-did 2001 Alternative today, One-Armed Scissor would finish far lower than #21, which was already a robbery.

Edit: Ok maybe I was being hyperbolic; even though several of the boosters from the first time are gone, I assume a handful of the people who tanked OAS in Alt either wouldn't send or would rank the song higher today to sort of offset that. and like....we're talking about 2001 Alt. How many songs could really pass it up lmao

[Red]

I've heard approximately two John Maus songs that I've liked, but I love both, so that has to account for something, right?

---

#45
John Maus
Quantum Leap

Points: 251
Standard Deviation: 9.42 (5th lowest)
Where I'd Rank It: #24
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #45

Rankings
samo🦕 - 21
BB🌕 - 24
American Idiot - 25
wrip - 25
MoD - 25
zippy - 28
rowellfarm490 - 29
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 33
@trilogy - 35
aerodynamite - 35
willapted33 - 41
singingrulebritannia - 45
wheatsquares33 - 48
HamedM1 💔 - 49

Movements
47 45 45 42 46 45 44 42 43 44 44 45 45

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
L'Via L'viaquez
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
The Man Comes Around
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Slow Emotion Replay
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Hole in the Sky
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[zippy]

It's cool to discover a song from the year 2011 that sounds nothing like the other songs that first come into my mind from that year.

[Red]

#44 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 6
Low: 48
Highest Point: 43
Lowest Point: 48

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 0
Top Tens: 2
Top Halves: 3
Bottom Tens: 5
Bottom Fives: 3
#50s: 0

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 48
aerodynamite - 48
American Idiot - 48
wrip - 48
wheatsquares33 - 45
rowellfarm490- 43
zippy - 45
BB🌕 - 46
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 45
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 45
samo🦕 - 46
willapted33 - 46
MoD - 44

[CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker]

Dec 6, 2022 20:54:13 GMT -5 HamedM1 💔 said:

Not me and samo🦕 being the only ones to rank Hannah Hunt top 10

Hey I tried....I at least deserve a cookie

[Red]

I was this close to losing two of my top five in the first five reveals. MOD saved me from that embarassment...by two spots.

Fitting that the other top five loss for me involves Cedric and Omar from ATDI.

---

#44
The Mars Volta
L'Via L'Viaquez

Points: 256
Standard Deviation: 14.21
Where I'd Rank It: #4
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #41

Rankings
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 6
MoD - 8
wrip - 12
wheatsquares33 - 28
rowellfarm490 - 33
samo🦕 - 35
willapted33 - 36
aerodynamite - 37
American Idiot - 38
zippy - 41
singingrulebritannia - 43
@trilogy - 46
BB🌕 - 47
HamedM1 💔 - 48

Movements
48 48 48 48 45 43 45 46 45 45 46 46 44

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
The Man Comes Around
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Slow Emotion Replay
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Hole in the Sky
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[HamedM1 💔]

I didn't mind this but I'd be a liar if I said I didn't progressively get bored as it went on.

[Red]

#43 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 12
Low: 45
Highest Point: 15
Lowest Point: 43

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 0
Top Tens: 0
Top Halves: 4
Bottom Tens: 3
Bottom Fives: 0
#50s: 0

4th Lowest SD

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 15
aerodynamite - 21
American Idiot - 29
wrip - 35
wheatsquares33 - 36
rowellfarm490- 34
zippy - 36
BB🌕 - 36
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 40
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 41
samo🦕 - 39
willapted33 - 40
MoD - 43

[Red]

lol, what on earth is this doing so low

---

#43
The The
Slow Emotion Replay

Points: 256
Standard Deviation: 9.38 (4th lowest)
Where I'd Rank It: #34
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #44

Rankings
singingrulebritannia - 12
samo🦕 - 22
@trilogy - 24
rowellfarm490 - 25
wheatsquares33 - 29
zippy - 31
BB🌕 - 33
aerodynamite - 34
HamedM1 💔 - 34
wrip - 38
willapted33 - 40
American Idiot - 42
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 44
MoD - 45

Movements
15 21 29 34 36 34 36 36 40 41 39 40 43

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
The Man Comes Around
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Hole in the Sky
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker]

Im getting perfect rankings

What is this madness

[Red]

#42 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 10
Low: 49
Highest Point: 21
Lowest Point: 43

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 0
Top Tens: 1
Top Halves: 5
Bottom Tens: 5
Bottom Fives: 1
#50s: 0

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 21
aerodynamite - 31
American Idiot - 34
wrip - 40
wheatsquares33 - 38
rowellfarm490- 40
zippy - 43
BB🌕 - 38
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 39
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 38
samo🦕 - 42
willapted33 - 43
MoD - 42

[Red]

I've been meaning to feature a song from one of the non-top tier Black Sabbath albums in a RD, and I can't say I'm surprised it's low, but this still rules.

---

#42
Black Sabbath
Hole in the Sky

Points: 275
Standard Deviation: 12.62
Where I'd Rank It: #41
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #43

Rankings
@trilogy - 10
BB🌕 - 15
MoD - 15
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 20
wheatsquares33 - 24
American Idiot - 30
singingrulebritannia - 33
HamedM1 💔 - 35
zippy - 36
wrip - 42
willapted33 - 42
aerodynamite - 44
rowellfarm490 - 44
samo🦕 - 49

Movements
21 31 34 40 38 40 43 38 39 38 42 43 42

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
The Man Comes Around
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[Red]

#41 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 3
Low: 50
Highest Point: 36
Lowest Point: 47

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 1
Top Tens: 2
Top Halves: 3
Bottom Tens: 5
Bottom Fives: 4
#50s: 1

---

Movements

singingrulebritannia and @trilogy - 41
aerodynamite - 47
American Idiot - 40
wrip - 36
wheatsquares33 - 43
rowellfarm490- 46
zippy - 47
BB🌕 - 45
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 47
HamedM1 💔 and @trilogy edit - 46
samo🦕 - 43
willapted33 - 42
MoD - 41

[Red]

I love the American series so much. Not every recording works, but what does work *works*, and this is one of the prime examples.

---

#41
Johnny Cash
The Man Comes Around

Points: 276
Standard Deviation: 15.17 (10th highest)
Where I'd Rank It: #33
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #42

Rankings
American Idiot - 3
samo🦕 - 7
MoD - 21
@trilogy - 26
HamedM1 💔 - 26
wrip - 27
BB🌕 - 29
willapted33 - 29
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 30
wheatsquares33 - 45
singingrulebritannia - 48
rowellfarm490 - 48
zippy - 49
aerodynamite - 50

Movements
41 47 40 36 43 46 47 45 47 46 43 42 41

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Monster
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[zippy]

I don't deny Johnny Cash was a talented musician, but the Biblical subject of this song really irks me. I didn't rank it last because it is well presented and also since I didn't feel anything when listening to "The Cold Song".

Now with my bottom four revealed, I consider every single song moving forward to be good at worst.

[Red]

#40 PREVIEW

Stats
High: 4
Low: 50 (x2)
Highest Point: 33
Lowest Point: 44

#1s: 0
Top Fives: 1
Top Tens: 2
Top Halves: 6
Bottom Tens: 6
Bottom Fives: 5
#50s: 2

---

Highest SD

[CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker]

I'm revisiting the American series myself...one of my favorite discoveries recently came from American VI

[Red]

If I had revealed this rankdown when I originally planned on doing so, I feel like this song and reveal would be far less awkward.

I have not been able to listen to a single song of Kanye's since...well, all of this shit that has been going on, and that includes this. Shame, too, because Nicki's verse on this song is still unbelievable.

---

#40
Kanye West f/ Jay-Z, Rick Ross, Nicki Minaj, and Bon Iver
Monster

Points: 290
Standard Deviation: 17.46 (highest)
Where I'd Rank It: #26
Where It Would Have Finished: w/ My Rank: #38

Rankings
willapted33 - 4
wrip - 7
BB🌕 - 12
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 15
zippy - 19
aerodynamite - 21
HamedM1 💔 - 27
samo🦕 - 30
rowellfarm490 - 45
singingrulebritannia - 47
MoD - 48
wheatsquares33 - 49
@trilogy - 50
American Idiot - 50

Movements
34 34 44 33 41 44 41 37 35 40 40 36 40

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}June
Alfonsina y el mar
Modern Business Hymns
All Mirrors
Pyramid of Bones
The Moth
Really Doe
Loner
Two Weeks
Krokodil
Anthonio
Hearts a Mess
XR2
Daydreamin'
Overnight Celebrity
The Argus
What If
I Surrender
Rabbit in Your Headlights
Shangri-La
8 Steps to Perfection
Down by the Water
Confide in Me
Unsung
Missing the Moon
Athol-brose
The Rhythm Divine
Tears
Communication
Since Yesterday
Blind Vision
Hilly Fields (1892)
Missiles
Planet Claire
Holy Ghost
Tokai
Get Up Offa That Thing
Lady Fantasy
Moonshake

[Deleted]

this is what i moved in my edit lol

[zippy]

f**k Kanye West, but I am not tanking the two songs he's a part of in this rankdown just because of what he's doing nowadays. I can still enjoy listening to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and his other older albums.

Also yeah, Nicki Minaj's portion of "Monster" is worth coming back to.

[HamedM1 💔]

I still really only use this for Nicki, everyone else is serviceable.

[Red]

Okay, I'm sorry, everyone, but I think I'm just gonna call reveals off until tomorrow. This has been a disaster of a first set for me. As it turns out, trying to rush into reveals when I haven't double-checked everything to make sure that all of the movements and stats were accurate was a poor decision, especially with the movements, because they are messed up right now, and it's going to take a decent amount of work to fix them.

I'm sorry, everyone, this is all on me. I'll make sure that everything is up to par tomorrow.

[singingrulebritannia]

I can separate art from artist in a lot of cases, but when you write a song saying "I know you think I'm a bad guy but it doesn't matter to me since you bump all my music and give me money anyway"...yea, that's going to age horribly when your actions become far worse than standard tabloid drama.

[Red]

Almost forgot to do stats!

SPOILER: Click to show

{CLOSENESS}aerodynamite - 8.09
zippy - 9.09
rowellfarm490 - 9.18
HamedM1 💔 - 10.09
@trilogy - 10.81
willapted33 - 11
BB🌕 - 11.63
wrip - 11.81
wheatsquares33 - 11.81
singingrulebritannia - 13.27
American Idiot - 13.72
samo🦕 - 14.27
MoD - 15.63
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 17.18

SPOILER: Click to show

{TOP TENS REMAINING}aerodynamite - 10
wheatsquares33 - 10
rowellfarm490 - 10
zippy - 10
BB🌕 - 10
singingrulebritannia - 9
@trilogy - 9
American Idiot - 9
wrip - 9
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 9
HamedM1 💔 - 9
willapted33 - 9
MoD - 9
samo🦕 - 8

SPOILER: Click to show

{TOP HALVES REMAINING}aerodynamite - 24
rowellfarm490 - 24
HamedM1 💔 - 24
singingrulebritannia - 23
@trilogy - 23
wheatsquares33 - 23
zippy - 23
willapted33 - 23
American Idiot - 22
wrip - 22
BB🌕 - 22
samo🦕 - 21
MoD - 21
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 20

SPOILER: Click to show

{BOTTOM TENS REMAINING}singingrulebritannia - 4
rowellfarm490 - 4
zippy - 4
@trilogy - 5
aerodynamite - 5
wrip - 5
wheatsquares33 - 5
BB🌕 - 5
samo🦕 - 5
HamedM1 💔 - 6
willapted33 - 6
American Idiot - 7
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 7
MoD - 7

SPOILER: Click to show

{HIGHEST RANK LOST}singingrulebritannia - 3
American Idiot - 3
willapted33 - 4
samo🦕 - 5
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 6
wrip - 7
MoD - 8
@trilogy - 10
HamedM1 💔 - 10
BB🌕 - 12
wheatsquares33 - 13
zippy - 16
aerodynamite - 21
rowellfarm490 - 25

SPOILER: Click to show

{LOWEST RANK REMAINING}zippy - 45
samo🦕 - 45
aerodynamite - 47
HamedM1 💔 - 47
@trilogy - 48
American Idiot - 48
wrip - 48
singingrulebritannia - 49
rowellfarm490 - 49
BB🌕 - 49
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 49
wheatsquares33 - 50
willapted33 - 50
MoD - 50

SPOILER: Click to show

{PERFECT RANKINGS}zippy - 2
singingrulebritannia - 1
aerodynamite - 1
wrip - 1
CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker - 1
HamedM1 💔 - 1
samo🦕 - 1
willapted33 - 1

[CagedJuggalo The Third Tanker]

I lost a perfect ranking 😭

Leave the Memories Alone 🤣