|
Post by bubblepop15 on Feb 13, 2006 7:00:47 GMT -5
1. Beautiful 2. Because Of You 3. My Immortal Same. Well I can't stand "My Immortal." I hate her voice in it. I love "Beautiful" and "Because of You."
|
|
Purple Dreams
2x Platinum Member
Joined: November 2004
Posts: 2,030
|
Post by Purple Dreams on Feb 13, 2006 9:07:54 GMT -5
Very hard decision. I went with BOY. 1. BOY 2. My Immortal 3. Beautiful
|
|
[upsilon]™
5x Platinum Member
Whoooooooooo!
Joined: September 2004
Posts: 5,627
|
Post by [upsilon]™ on Feb 13, 2006 23:44:08 GMT -5
"Beautiful" > "Because Of You" >"Bring Me To Life"
All GREAT singles though.
|
|
Matt4319
Administrator
Joined: September 2003
Posts: 15,215
Staff
|
Post by Matt4319 on Feb 14, 2006 18:11:23 GMT -5
"Beautiful" > "Because Of You" >"Bring Me To Life" All GREAT singles though. "Bring Me to Life" wasn't part of the poll. Anyway, "MI" is the clear winner here.
|
|
|
Post by tico on Feb 16, 2006 21:08:12 GMT -5
I'm shocked Kelly isn't winning. I went for Christina.
|
|
Waffles
New Member
Joined: November 2005
Posts: 211
|
Post by Waffles on Feb 17, 2006 15:56:37 GMT -5
My Immortal. I loved it as soon as it came out and I never got sick of it. I like the other two, but I got sick of both of them after awhile.
|
|
hidizzyguy
8x Platinum Member
hello
Joined: January 2005
Posts: 8,800
|
Post by hidizzyguy on Feb 17, 2006 16:03:11 GMT -5
i would put My Immortal in a category on its own as being somewhat close to a masterpiece (even if it isn't).......... and then put Boy and Beautiful in a whole different, category, far away, with BOY being on top of Beautiful.........
|
|
JeffB
New Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 479
|
Post by JeffB on Feb 17, 2006 19:53:39 GMT -5
i would put My Immortal in a category on its own as being somewhat close to a masterpiece (even if it isn't).......... and then put Boy and Beautiful in a whole different, category, far away, with BOY being on top of Beautiful......... Exactly, i dont know where is the resemblence between those song, but My Immortal merit way more then that to be with Kelly and X-Tina. I vote for My Immortal of course.
|
|
|
Post by reception on Jan 13, 2007 16:11:20 GMT -5
1 Evanescence - My Immortal 2 Christina Aguilera - Beautiful 3 Kelly Clarkson - Because of You
|
|
vinyl
Diamond Member
Was Rachel Bilson In Another Life
Joined: July 2006
Posts: 12,157
|
Post by vinyl on Jan 13, 2007 16:30:50 GMT -5
My Immortal, easily.
|
|
|
Post by beaston on Jan 13, 2007 16:31:42 GMT -5
Kelly
|
|
|
Post by ruby1 on Jan 13, 2007 16:45:36 GMT -5
my immortal (the BEST evanescense song)
|
|
|
Post by dperkins on Jan 13, 2007 17:17:38 GMT -5
1. Evanescence - My Immortal 2. Kelly Clarkson - Because Of You 3. Christina Aguilera - Beautiful
|
|
|
Post by Positive Tension on Jan 13, 2007 23:00:51 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by joker on Jan 14, 2007 0:01:29 GMT -5
|
|
Felicia
9x Platinum Member
will you love me, even with my dark side?
Joined: March 2006
Posts: 9,875
|
Post by Felicia on Jan 14, 2007 3:25:21 GMT -5
My Immortal, excellent song and beautiful video!
|
|
oscillations.
Diamond Member
Opinion = Fact
I was faced with a choice at a difficult age.
Joined: February 2005
Posts: 10,130
|
Post by oscillations. on Jan 14, 2007 3:37:31 GMT -5
Because I'm in a mood to defend the sentimental, the maudlin, and the truly sincere, I'm going to allow "My Immortal" 's artistic shortcomings be overshadowed by the obvious well-intended nature of the song. I'm not supposed to know what the song is "about", but I do, and, well, that's a dangerous bit of knowledge to be privy to, as it completely throws any attempts at objectivity into abstraction. It would be like trying to grade an art student's drawing of their dead friend. You can't - you give them the A & realize why a critic loathes genuine sincerity & single-entendres (because criticizing in these cases would be pretty evil, and at the very least, something to rightfully feel guilty about). Irony-free expression & artless emotion disconcert reviewers because they can't make their favorite complaint of "disingenuousness" but can't quite bring themselves to admit that the piece is "stirring" without betraying personal reaction/emotional involvement (faux pas!). But in these cases, the artist's intentions preempt the actual musical output in importance. Christina's track, though, manages to balance the needs of both personal expression and artistry, so by proxy, hers wins. "Because of You" is like being subjected to Diane Warren's interpretation of a subliterate 13 year old's diary (yes, I'm aware she is not actually responsible for the track, but her influence pawprints are all over the songwriting). No thanks.
|
|
polly
New Member
Joined: January 2013
Posts: 0
|
Post by polly on Jan 14, 2007 5:57:03 GMT -5
All are great songs, but My Immortal is just SUPERB!
|
|
|
Post by jaxxalude on Jan 14, 2007 9:55:32 GMT -5
Christina's track, though, manages to balance the needs of both personal expression and artistry, so by proxy, hers wins. Exactly. (And tell me, what drugs do you use? I want some of them too! )
|
|
killzone
Gold Member
Joined: December 2006
Posts: 574
|
Post by killzone on Jan 14, 2007 16:06:45 GMT -5
My Immortal, Beautiful is beautiful but that's it, BOY as far as it's a real like story it just wasn't there
|
|
|
Post by when the pawn... on Jan 14, 2007 22:35:57 GMT -5
1. Beautiful 2. My Immortal 3. Because Of You
|
|