Weekly Alternative/Rock Personal Charts

[jvandyck87]

1. Alter Bridge - "Isolation"
2. Karnivool - "All I Know"
3. Deftones - "You've Seen The Butcher"
4. A Silent Film - "You Will Leave A Mark"
5. In This Moment - "The Promise"

[lockebox]

Does "All I Know" count? Don't think it's officially gone for adds.

[Devin]

Nov 29, 2010 18:04:20 GMT -5 lockebox said:

Does "All I Know" count? Don't think it's officially gone for adds.

Well it is on some stations (I think) and is getting played currently, and if it is actually released as a single in the U.S., I'll count it for now. But I'm not sure.

[Nicholas2.0]

1. Avenged Sevenfold "Welcome to the Family"
2. Jimmy Eat World "My Best Theory"
3. Arcade Fire "Ready to Start"
4. My Chemical Romance "Na Na Na"
5. Jimmy Eat World "Coffee and Cigarettes"

[jvandyck87]

Nov 29, 2010 19:11:28 GMT -5 Devin said:

Nov 29, 2010 18:04:20 GMT -5 lockebox said:

Does "All I Know" count? Don't think it's officially gone for adds.

Well it is on some stations (I think) and is getting played currently, and if it is actually released as a single in the U.S., I'll count it for now. But I'm not sure.

Music Choice pretty much plays every single that goes for adds. It does play some album tracks, but doesn't put them into rotation. While this was never listed with FMQB, nearly was "Set Fire To The Hive", but given at one point it was being tested on about 20 active rock stations, it was clearly pushed as the lead single. I don't really love that song, so it would never make this countdown for me.

Now, watching Music Choice, it seems like "All I know" gets played on their active rock channel 4 or 5 times a day. I see it as much as any other song that they have in rotation. "Set Fire To The Hive" was also played a similar amount on Music Choice Rock before Sirius Octane added it a couple of months later in addition to a handful of other stations. I think it is the next (ie current) single in the US, but getting additional adds to Music Choice will happen gradually and infrequently. It's kind of a similar case with Silversun Pickups - "Growing Old Is Getting Old" which is played on Music Choice Alternative, and is technically their current single, only it never went for adds and is getting very little airplay on other stations. Granted Silversun Pickups is a radio band on a 4th single, so the comparison only holds between the two singles, not the bands' situations.

[Devin]

2 more hours to vote! Although I don't think there are many other people left to vote this week. Artie never, but that's understandable.

Anyone else?

[Devin]

I am introducing the carryover rule this week, much like Az's countdown on the CHR section.
[/li][li]If a voter does not vote for the current week, but voted last week, his/her vote will be "carried over" to the current week.
[/li][li]If a voter voted 2 weeks ago, and hasn't voted for two weeks, his/her will still be "carried over."
[/li][li]If a voter voter 3+ weeks ago, and hasn't voted in 3+ weeks, his/her vote will not be counted for.

LW TW WKS Song
01 01 005 ALTER BRIDGE Isolation
12 02 005 30 SECONDS TO MARS Closer to the Edge
04 03 005 MUSE Undisclosed Desires
07 04 005 JIMMY EAT WORLD My Best Theory
02 05 005 TEMPER TRAP Fader
03 06 003 HAIL THE VILLAIN Runaway
09 07 002 MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE Sing
-- 08 001 DISTURBED The Animal
05 09 005 AVENGED SEVENFOLD Welcome to the Family
-- 10 002 MUMFORD & SONS Little Lion Man

-- 11 001 MUMFORD & SONS The Cave
08 12 002 FLORENCE + THE MACHINE Dog Days Are Over
-- 13 002 MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE Na Na Na ...
-- 14 001 FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH Far From Home
11 15 003 CEE-LO GREEN F**k You (Forget You)


DROPPERS:
"New Low" - Middle Class Rut (3 weeks, from #6)
"All I Want" - A Day to Remember (1 week, from #10)
"You've Seen the Butcher" - Deftones (4 weeks, from #13)
"World So Cold" - Three Days Grace (2 weeks, from #14)
"Life Won't Wait" - Ozzy Osbourne (1 week, from #15)

PURGED/RECURRENT ON SUNDAY (No Longer Eligable):
"Kick In the Teeth" - Papa Roach
"Na Na Na" - My Chemical Romance
(If there are any other purges/recurrents I missed you can pm me so I can post it under here. It would be also helpful if someone could pm me the recurrents/purges. Thanks!)


CHART NOTES:
12 voters and 4 carry-overs this week. Alter Bridge stay isolated at #1 for another week, while "Closer to the Edge" makes a triumphant comeback to #2 from #10. Muse climb back up, as well as Jimmy Eat World, and My Chemical Romance. "The Animal" finally debuts after hoving below the Top 15 for while, at #8. Mumford & Sons enter the chart this week with two songs; "Little Lion Man" re-enters at #10, while "The Cave" makes a debut at #11. :) "Na Na Na" won't go down without a fight, as it also re-enters for it's last week on the chart, at #13. 5FDP also debut at #14, with "Far From Home." The #1 song has 21 points, the Top 5 have 12+ points, the Top 10 have 9+ points, and the Top 15 have 6+ points.


#1's of 2010

11/03/10 MUSE Undisclosed Desires
11/10/10 MUSE Undisclosed Desires
11/17/10 ALTER BRIDGE Isolation
11/24/10 ALTER BRIDGE Isolation
12/01/10 ALTER BRIDGE Isolation

[Devin]

Voting's now open

1) Mumford & Sons - "Little Lion Man"
2) Mumford & Sons - "The Cave"
3) Hail the Villain - "Runaway"
4) Alter Bridge - "Isolation"
5) A Day to Remember - "All I Want"

[pen]

Sweet, (doesn't vote for two weeks).

[Devin]

I hope everyone is happy with that new rule. But I do encourage you to vote every week, for in case you decide to change a song but you are too lazy to do so!

[rockmaniac]

Nov 24, 2010 15:55:25 GMT -5 rockmaniac said:

1. Three Days Grace - World So Cold
2. Alter Bridge - Isolation
3. Disturbed - The Animal
4. Drowning Pool - Turn So Cold
5. Avenged Sevenfold - Welcome To The Family

[Deleted]

1) My Chemical Romance - Sing
2) Cee Lo Green - F**k You
3) Florence + the Machine - Dog Days Are Over
4) Linkin Park - Waiting For The End
5) Three Days Grace - World So Cold

[Nicholas2.0]

Why is "Ready to Start" on the recurrent/purged list? It was #31 last week on the Alternative chart. And "Na Na Na" was purged on Sunday.

[Devin]

Dec 2, 2010 1:45:29 GMT -5 Nicholas2.0 said:

Why is "Ready to Start" on the recurrent/purged list? It was #31 last week on the Alternative chart. And "Na Na Na" was purged on Sunday.

My bad. I was told that it purged.

[lockebox]

You mean my bad haha. I thought it had been.

[jvandyck87]

^ Is that a Neon Trees - Animal or a Disturbed - The Animal vote?

[lockebox]

1. Alter Bridge - "Isolation"
2. Five Finger Death Punch - "Far from Home"
3. Deftones - "You've Seen the Butcher"
4. The Black Keys - "Tighten Up"
5. Paper Tongues - "Get Higher"

[jvandyck87]

I guess I'll vote now:

1. Karnivool - All I Know
2. Deftones - You've Seen The Butcher
3. Middle Class Rut - New Low
4. Mumford & Sons - Little Lion Man
5. Jimmy Eat World - My Best Theory

I'm still rooting for "Isolation", but I think I need a break from them after spinning their album a few too many times on my Northeast road trip last week.

[Nicholas2.0]

The numbers on my actual chart shifted, but these are still the Top 5 singles on it.

1. Avenged Sevenfold "Welcome to the Family"
2. Jimmy Eat World "My Best Theory"
3. Arcade Fire "Ready to Start"
4. My Chemical Romance "Na Na Na"
5. Jimmy Eat World "Coffee and Cigarettes"

[Devin]

Dec 3, 2010 22:55:48 GMT -5 Nicholas2.0 said:

The numbers on my actual chart shifted, but these are still the Top 5 singles on it.

1. Avenged Sevenfold "Welcome to the Family"
2. Jimmy Eat World "My Best Theory"
3. Arcade Fire "Ready to Start"
4. My Chemical Romance "Na Na Na"
5. Jimmy Eat World "Coffee and Cigarettes"

"Na Na Na" is purged. Pick another please. :)

[Gravity.]

1. Dog Days Are Over
2. Undisclosed Desires
3. My Best Theory
4. Waiting for The End
5. SING

[Deleted]

MUMFORD & SONS The Cave
FLORENCE + THE MACHINE Dog Days Are Over
MUMFORD & SONS Little Lion Man
30 SECONDS TO MARS Closer To The Edge
PHOENIX Lasso

[Pipa]

1. A Day to Remember - All I Want
2. Alter Bridge - Isolation
3. Avenged Sevenfold - Welcome to the Family
4. Hail the Villain - Runaway
5. Broken Bells - The Ghost Inside

[Nicholas2.0]

Dec 3, 2010 23:10:54 GMT -5 Devin said:

"Na Na Na" is purged. Pick another please. :)

So it is. Force of habit. Let's try this again:

1. Avenged Sevenfold "Welcome to the Family"
2. Jimmy Eat World "My Best Theory"
3. Arcade Fire "Ready to Start"
4. Jimmy Eat World "Coffee and Cigarettes"
5. 30 Seconds to Mars "Closer to the Edge"

[iceman]

1. Phoenix Burn-Alpha Rev
2. Only the Young-Brandon Flowers (not sure about this one)??
3. The Cave-Mumford & Sons
4. Beg Steal or Borrow-Ray LaMontagne
5. Fader-The Temper Trap

[Devin]

Dec 4, 2010 16:05:12 GMT -5 iceman said:

1. Phoenix Burn-Alpha Rev
2. Only the Young-Brandon Flowers (not sure about this one)??
3. The Cave-Mumford & Sons
4. Beg Steal or Borrow-Ray LaMontagne
5. Fader-The Temper Trap

I'm actually pretty sure Ray LaMontage and Alpha Rev don't count (no add dates, not a lot of significant airplay). Will someone prove me wrong?

[iceman]

Maybe not Alpha Rev but "Beg Steal or Borrow" hit #1 on AAA.

[Devin]

Dec 4, 2010 16:21:35 GMT -5 iceman said:

Maybe not Alpha Rev but "Beg Steal or Borrow" hit #1 on AAA.

Oh, well I'm sorry, I don't follow the Triple A chart, though I should since I include it on this chart, shouldn't I? Oh well pick another one besides Alpha Rev.

[halo19]

In spite me missing one week, it seems as though my entries all have suffered from the fact.

I'll contribute when I hear more current songs this week.

[iceman]

Dec 4, 2010 16:30:37 GMT -5 Devin said:

Dec 4, 2010 16:21:35 GMT -5 iceman said:

Maybe not Alpha Rev but "Beg Steal or Borrow" hit #1 on AAA.

Oh, well I'm sorry, I don't follow the Triple A chart, though I should since I include it on this chart, shouldn't I? Oh well pick another one besides Alpha Rev.

Here it is!

1. Only the Young-Brandon Flowers
2. The Cave-Mumford & Sons
3. Beg Steal or Borrow-Ray LaMontagne
4. Fader-The Temper Trap
5. Maybe-Sick Puppies