lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Dec 13, 2010 15:19:55 GMT -5
Second single from "7th Symphony". Featuring Brent Smith, although allaccess has it done as Hoobastank's Doug Robb ???
I still would have gone for "Broken Pieces". This is Brent Smith overkill.
Goes for adds January 18th.
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Dec 13, 2010 16:27:42 GMT -5
it's "I Don't Care" all over again
|
|
jvandyck87
5x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2007
Posts: 5,213
|
Post by jvandyck87 on Dec 13, 2010 16:36:15 GMT -5
If AllAccess has it as Doug Robb, then my guess is that's who'll be on the radio version of the track. Maybe Shinedown's label is worried about the Brent Smith overkill at radio, or just wants to limit him to Shinedown and other Atlantic Records releases for radio. This is kinda like the Chris Daughtry record label issue with Sevendust "The Past" or Santana's "Why Don't You & I" which had a version with Chad Kroeger and a version with Alex Band that radio played.
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Dec 13, 2010 16:38:29 GMT -5
If AllAccess has it as Doug Robb, then my guess is that's who'll be on the radio version of the track. Maybe Shinedown's label is worried about the Brent Smith overkill at radio, or just wants to limit him to Shinedown and other Atlantic Records releases for radio. This is kinda like the Chris Daughtry record label issue with Sevendust "The Past" or Santana's "Why Don't You & I" which had a version with Chad Kroeger and a version with Alex Band that radio played. they may have put Doug Robb by mistake |
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Dec 13, 2010 16:56:39 GMT -5
If AllAccess has it as Doug Robb, then my guess is that's who'll be on the radio version of the track. Maybe Shinedown's label is worried about the Brent Smith overkill at radio, or just wants to limit him to Shinedown and other Atlantic Records releases for radio. This is kinda like the Chris Daughtry record label issue with Sevendust "The Past" or Santana's "Why Don't You & I" which had a version with Chad Kroeger and a version with Alex Band that radio played. I didn't actually think of that. I hope you are right. |
|
(Artie Ziff)
5x Platinum Member
Joined: June 2007
Posts: 5,993 
|
Post by (Artie Ziff) on Dec 13, 2010 17:18:52 GMT -5
Billboard.biz had this listed 3 weeks ago as "featuring Tipe Johnson." So maybe there are three versions. I didn't start it then because I've never heard the song and it was noted that Diane Warren wrote it.
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Dec 13, 2010 17:25:13 GMT -5
Billboard.biz had this listed 3 weeks ago as "featuring Tipe Johnson." So maybe there are three versions. I didn't start it then because I've never heard the song and it was noted that Diane Warren wrote it. again, by mistake. |
|
Devin
Diamond Member
Best Rock Poster 2011―2014
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 14,015
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by Devin on Dec 13, 2010 19:10:10 GMT -5
Either way, "Broken Pieces" shoulda been the second single. Then this third, obviously. And it might be possibe that this may have a different featured artist, because of both the Shinedown/Brent Smith overkill and possible record label troubles about releasing this which another singer from another label who doesn't want their artist to be released on another label, blah blah blah (like Santana's "Why Don't You & I" with Chad Kroeger, and got replaced by Alex Band I think).
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Dec 13, 2010 19:14:02 GMT -5
i don't like the idea of putting another version of a song featuring another guest vocalist. it's stupid.
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Dec 13, 2010 19:34:51 GMT -5
from Hoobastank's Twitter:
(shakes head)
|
|
Devin
Diamond Member
Best Rock Poster 2011―2014
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 14,015
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by Devin on Dec 13, 2010 19:37:01 GMT -5
Looks like my explanation appears to be true.  :( |
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Dec 13, 2010 19:56:50 GMT -5
i don't like the idea of putting another version of a song featuring another guest vocalist. it's stupid. Why is it stupid? I'm sick of hearing Brent Smith at the minute. Good to hear that Doug Robb will be taking up the mantelpiece. He hasn't a radio hit in a long time. |
|
pen
9x Platinum Member
A true gentleman leaves no puzzle unsolved.
Joined: July 2005
Posts: 9,408
|
Post by pen on Dec 13, 2010 20:57:42 GMT -5
Word up to that. I'm glad somebody remembers Hoobastank is still a band.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jorge_Str [Som3on3] on Dec 13, 2010 22:03:09 GMT -5
it's "I Don't Care" all over again oh yeah, but i like more this one |
|
|
|
Post by American Idiot on Dec 13, 2010 22:51:24 GMT -5
Word up to that. I'm glad somebody remembers Hoobastank is still a band. ...and a largely underrated and still awesome one at that! |
|
linicklo
Bubbling Under
Joined: November 2010
Posts: 12
|
Post by linicklo on Dec 13, 2010 23:08:30 GMT -5
Word up to that. I'm glad somebody remembers Hoobastank is still a band. well this is the band that kind of brought gavin rossdale back into the rock scene |
|
pen
9x Platinum Member
A true gentleman leaves no puzzle unsolved.
Joined: July 2005
Posts: 9,408
|
Post by pen on Dec 13, 2010 23:14:35 GMT -5
Word up to that. I'm glad somebody remembers Hoobastank is still a band. well this is the band that kind of brought gavin rossdale back into the rock scene Yeah, I was kind of hoping that band would be, y'know, Bush. |
|
jvandyck87
5x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2007
Posts: 5,213
|
Post by jvandyck87 on Dec 14, 2010 0:43:11 GMT -5
Looks like my explanation appears to be true. :( No offense bud, but you sorta plagiarized your explanation from mine. Read earlier in the thread. I beat you to the bunch I'm afraid. |
|
|
|
Post by slicknickshady on Dec 14, 2010 0:46:34 GMT -5
None of the tracks on this albums are as good as "I'm Not Jesus", "I Don't Care", or "SOS".
|
|
Devin
Diamond Member
Best Rock Poster 2011―2014
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 14,015
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by Devin on Dec 14, 2010 15:08:36 GMT -5
Looks like my explanation appears to be true. :( No offense bud, but you sorta plagiarized your explanation from mine. Read earlier in the thread. I beat you to the bunch I'm afraid. Actually my explanation said 3/4 of what you said, except I explain why the would release this with another artist as what happened with Chad Kroeger in "Why Don't You & I". But that's only if you were implying that. Sorry if it pissed you off,  |
|
jvandyck87
5x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2007
Posts: 5,213
|
Post by jvandyck87 on Dec 14, 2010 19:09:28 GMT -5
Nah, I just didn't want you stealing all my glory.
|
|
Devin
Diamond Member
Best Rock Poster 2011―2014
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 14,015
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by Devin on Dec 14, 2010 20:01:44 GMT -5
Nah, I just didn't want you stealing all my glory. How bout we share the glory, then? |
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Dec 14, 2010 20:07:02 GMT -5
Jamie mentioned it first I thought ??? ha.
|
|
(Artie Ziff)
5x Platinum Member
Joined: June 2007
Posts: 5,993
|
Post by (Artie Ziff) on Dec 24, 2010 20:59:09 GMT -5
XM now is playing the Doug Robb version. I'm guessing the Tipe Johnson and Brent Smith recordings have been scrapped.
|
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Dec 27, 2010 12:24:09 GMT -5
XM now is playing the Doug Robb version. I'm guessing the Tipe Johnson and Brent Smith recordings have been scrapped. Tipe Johnson is their touring vocalist, that's probably why there's a version with him. I doubt it's a studio one, though. |
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Jan 5, 2011 9:57:19 GMT -5
look at this
"a source told The Pulse Of Radio that APOCALYPTICA failed to secure the right to release the song to radio with Smith's voice on it from SHINEDOWN's label, Atlantic Records."
|
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Jan 5, 2011 14:43:25 GMT -5
^ I think that's what everyone assumed had happened. Atlantic didn't want the Brent Smith show on radio.
|
|
lockebox
5x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2009
Posts: 5,739
|
Post by lockebox on Jan 7, 2011 19:00:17 GMT -5
The version with Doug Robb. The quality isn't the best, but it's good enough to tell that the Brent Smith version is far better. There's no way they could have released that to radio, though.
|
|
rockmaniac
2x Platinum Member
Joined: July 2010
Posts: 2,355
|
Post by rockmaniac on Jan 7, 2011 19:10:31 GMT -5
Brent Smith version > Doug Robb version any day of the week
|
|
pen
9x Platinum Member
A true gentleman leaves no puzzle unsolved.
Joined: July 2005
Posts: 9,408
|
Post by pen on Jan 7, 2011 20:25:27 GMT -5
It's a shame because it's obvious the song was meant for Smith and hearing Robb having to basically be Smith on the song is unfair to both Smith and Robb.
|
|
![Jorge_Str [Som3on3] Avatar](http://storage.proboards.com/1258812/avatar/Ckf_SvW4JZTB5VouxIVv.jpg)
