Flashback Top 40 Rankdown #2: Hot 100 9/10/05 (Winner!)

[aerodynamite]

Back by popular demand!

Many of you were up for another mid-00’s flashback. You even did your homework and found a specific chart week :-p! Thankfully, I don’t object to including any of these songs in my own rankdown; otherwise, I’d have to veto it . So here it is: the second Flashback Top 40 Rankdown!



www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100/2005-09-10



Song List

We Belong Together – Mariah Carey
Shake It Off – Mariah Carey
Don’t Cha – The Pussycat Dolls f/ Busta Rhymes
Lose Control – Missy Elliott f/ Ciara & Fatman Scoop
Let Me Hold You – Bow Wow f/ Omarion
Pon de Replay - Rihanna
Like You – Bow Wow f/ Ciara
You and Me - Lifehouse
Behind These Hazel Eyes – Kelly Clarkson
Listen to Your Heart - DHT
Just the Girl – The Click Five
Sugar, We’re Goin’ Down – Fall Out Boy
Beverly Hills - Weezer
Don’t Lie – The Black Eyed Peas
Wake Me Up When September Ends – Green Day
Play – David Banner
Pimpin’ All Over the World – Ludacris f/ Bobby Valentino
Feel Good Inc - Gorillaz
Gold Digger – Kanye West f/ Jamie Foxx
Cater 2 U – Destiny’s Child
Cool – Gwen Stefani
Hollaback Girl – Gwen Stefani
Get It Poppin’ – Fat Joe f/ Nelly
These Words – Natasha Bedingfield
My Humps – The Black Eyed Peas
Don’t Phunk with My Heart – The Black Eyed Peas
Scars – Papa Roach
Holiday – Green Day
Alcohol – Brad Paisley
Wake Up – Hilary Duff
Outta Control (Remix) – 50 Cent f/ Mobb Deep
Badd – Ying Yang Twins f/ Mike Jones & Mr. ColliPark
Since U Been Gone – Kelly Clarkson
La Tortura – Shakira f/ Alejandro Sanz
Mr. Brightside – The Killers
Your Body – Pretty Ricky
Grind with Me – Pretty Ricky
Lonely No More – Rob Thomas
Best of You – Foo Fighters
As Good as I Once Was – Toby Keith





Rules

1. Rank the above songs from 1 to 40, 1 being your favorite and 40 being your least favorite.
2. PM your list to me ( aerodynamite )
3. Scores will be determined using inverse points (i.e. a #1 rank is worth 40 points, #2 worth 39, …, #40 worth 1).
4. Deadline is August 21 at 11:59:59 PM Central Daylight Time (UTC -5).



Tags

Albie alexcuse @antigonerising austin awesomecharts Az Paynter bat1990 Daryl the Beryl Beno beyoncelover Linnethia Monique castleoblivion26 CF15 chicken077 Choco Blurry LBTrocks Willow Rinadoobee Breakfast crazyb DistrictTwelve dm2081 nick64 when the pawn... ★Disco★ fearlessarrow Exclusive rainie frenchfry ry4n Ginger Spice Sambalada .indulgecountry james518 @jamesflame Leo ✔ Zeebz born matteeeb Kanenrá:ke Juanca Mr. Thonk Eyes jtd Thee Stallion Juan Carlos peacebone kmbgs Ky Leaf GOD'S PLAN Rocky Codex lyhom #LisaRinna Libra The Bode Blend (Moose) MilesW1998 @mirza MTSChart21 Caviar Raccoon Harx Golden Bluebird Red rgreen0625 Fat Ass Kelly Price someguy zaclord 🌈 Daniel Collins Au$tin †ealsünset Rose Wintur Web Pale Shelter toomuchboy trustypepper BackwoodsBarbie woods vann @walker9 wheatsquares33 willapted33 YotamTS

-Participation is open to everyone.
-If you wish not to be tagged, let me know.
-Feel free to tag anyone else you think would be interested.

[aerodynamite]

Playlist




Note: "Holiday" ends at roughly 3:50 of the "Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams" track.





Participants
Billy
aerodynamite
alexcuse
Az Paynter
Beno
castleoblivion26
CF15
Choco
Willow Rinadoobee Breakfast
crazyb
DistrictTwelve
fearlessarrow
frenchfry
Green Baron
Sambalada
.indulgecountry
@jamesflame
Leo ✔
matteeeb
Mr. Thonk Eyes
jtd Thee Stallion
Juan Carlos
peacebone
kmbgs
Ky
lyhom
MilesW1998
@mirza
Red
rgreen0625
Au$tin
Pale Shelter
@walker9
willapted33
YotamTS

[aerodynamite]

Results
#40 #39 #38 #37 #36 #35 #34 #33 #32 #31
#30 #29 #28 #27 #26 #25 #24 #23 #22 #21
#20 #19 #18 #17 #16 #15 #14 #13 #12 #11
#10 #9 #8 #7 #6

Top 5:
#5-#3
Winner

SPOILER: Click to show

{Final Results}

Rank	Song	Points
1	Behind These Hazel Eyes	1139
2	Mr. Brightside	1103
3	Since U Been Gone	1068
4	Wake Me Up When September Ends	1047
5	Feel Good Inc	1016
6	Lonely No More	997
7	We Belong Together	985
8	Gold Digger	969
9	Hollaback Girl	938
10	Pon de Replay	933
11	Sugar, We're Goin' Down	923
12	Holiday	912
13	Lose Control	898
14	Cool	896
15	La Tortura	876
16	You and Me	835
17	Don't Phunk with My Heart	826
18	Don't Cha	782
19	Beverly Hills	761
20	Shake It Off	760
21	Best of You	759
22	Listen to Your Heart	754
23	These Words	744
24	Don't Lie	657
25	Like You	573
26	Wake Up	553
27	My Humps	534
28	Cater 2 U	531
29	Pimpin' All Over the World	528
30	Let Me Hold You	527
31	Outta Control (Remix)	500
32	Scars	457
33	Alcohol	454
34	Just the Girl	449
35	Get It Poppin'	384
36	As Good As I Once Was	380
37	Grind with Me	356
38	Your Body	320
39	Badd	304
40	Play	272

Recaps
Recap 1
Recap 2
Recap 3
Recap 4
Final Recap

Rankdown & User Closeness

[Willow Rinadoobee Breakfast]

Sweet, another great year.

[Leo ✔]

Yes!! Bookmarking

[Willow Rinadoobee Breakfast]

I absolutely love my top 5. I at least hope Cool makes it to the top 10.

There is one song I'm nostalgic about, even if it's cheesy as hell.

But calling it, Play is #40.

[kmbgs]

Yaaaaas!!

[Deleted]

Play better not be 40.

[Deleted]

Jul 30, 2017 18:53:58 GMT -5 @walker9 said:

Play better not be 40.

For a second I thought you mean Pon De Replay until I noticed the other song
Speaking of PDR, I'm expecting it to be a potential winner

[Au$tin]

HILARY DUFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We Belong Together – Mariah Carey
Shake It Off – Mariah Carey
Don’t Cha – The Pussycat Dolls f/ Busta Rhymes
Lose Control – Missy Elliott f/ Ciara & Fatman Scoop
Pon de Replay - Rihanna
Like You – Bow Wow f/ Ciara
Behind These Hazel Eyes – Kelly Clarkson
Listen to Your Heart - DHT
Sugar, We’re Goin’ Down – Fall Out Boy
Beverly Hills - Weezer
Don’t Lie – The Black Eyed Peas
Wake Me Up When September Ends – Green Day
Gold Digger – Kanye West f/ Jamie Foxx
Cool – Gwen Stefani
Hollaback Girl – Gwen Stefani
These Words – Natasha Bedingfield
My Humps – The Black Eyed Peas
Don’t Phunk with My Heart – The Black Eyed Peas
Wake Up – Hilary Duff
Since U Been Gone – Kelly Clarkson
Lonely No More – Rob Thomas

Holy f**k, what a week!

[Rose Wintur]

I might play this one. Maybe

[Deleted]

For once I can confidently say that this time, my number 1 is going top 5 for sure.

[Red]

Honestly, I like this top 40 better than the 2007 one, but...good grief, there's still some awful songs here. Maybe not as downright terrible as the worst of the 2007 top 40, but close.

[CF15]

I'll do this one as well. I see a lot of songs here that I like.

[Blurry]

I'll definitely do this one after accidentally missing the last one.

I have a couple #1 contenders here.

[fearlessarrow]

Good week! Mariah, Gwen, and Kelly have two songs each and there are more great songs too!

Now it's time to watch Brad Paisley get eliminated real quick (especially with a song like "Alcohol" lol)   It's not like I was going to rank "Alcohol" that high anyways but I love Brad so... 

[willapted33]

Even better than 07

[Deleted]

Sent. I think that I will do much better here than in 07, but could still lose some high songs early and some low songs could stay a while. My 7 will be out especially early and I hope that my 2 will end up escaping bottom 10 but I doubt it. I expect my number 1 in top 5 but we will see.

[peacebone]

Would've rather done the other '05 week that was posted in the other thread on the basis of it having "Speed of Sound" (a guaranteed top 5 for me), which isn't present on this one.

Still, some pretty solid stuff on here.

[Leaf]

Jul 30, 2017 23:39:07 GMT -5 peacebone said:

Would've rather done the other '05 week that was posted in the other thread on the basis of it having "Speed of Sound" (a guaranteed top 5 for me), which isn't present on this one.

Still, some pretty solid stuff on here.

MTE, it would have been my #1. Ah well.

[Deleted]

Didnt the week after this, Gold Digger jump to 1 and WBT fell to 3 which caused SIO to be stuck at 5 more weeks at number 2 behind GD?

[Deleted]

Also wish that we included the week before this so Just A Lil Bit could have been on it. but oh well.

[willapted33]

Jul 30, 2017 23:39:07 GMT -5 peacebone said:

Would've rather done the other '05 week that was posted in the other thread on the basis of it having "Speed of Sound" (a guaranteed top 5 for me), which isn't present on this one.

Still, some pretty solid stuff on here.

Same

[musicfan134]

Behind These Hazel Eyes goes at least top 5, and I could easily see it winning. Since U Been Gone will go top 10, maybe even top 5. Calling it now.

May participate in this; we will see as it gets closer.

[Beno]

100% doing this

[Az Paynter]

IDK yet what my #1 will be but all I can say is, 'Lonely No More' and 'La Tortura' F**k. YES. I mean, I wanted to do a week with 'La Tortura' but still

[Leo ✔]

"La Tortura" better be top 10 or I'll kill someone.

[Green Baron]

Tag me in reminders, aero.

[crazyb]

Submitted, not as good as the week in the 2007 one IMO, but still good.

[Deleted]

Just submitted, a lotta good songs songs on here.
Only a few I dislike like Play & then songs like Best Of You, Just The Girl, and Scars(basic vocals x the cliche 2000s rock sound, sorry not sorry about these ones)

Also my guess for the #1 is that Behind These Hazel Eyes is gonna win it all