I've been doing quite a bit of research on pre-Billboard alternative charts from a trade magazine called "The Hard Report" which ranked the Top20 alternative tracks & Top 50 played alternative albums each week. Below is a result of my research. I have "completed" the list of top 1988 alternative songs by starting with the Billboard list (9/10/1988 thru 12/31/1988) and then adding the songs from the Hard Report (1/1/1988 thru 6/24/1988). I have indicated the source of each song by placing a "B" or "H" (EDIT: or "C" for CMJ) next to the song. As some of the issues of the Hard Report are missing, it is possible that the peak on the Hard Report songs was actually higher than indicated. And of course it is possible that some songs were missed altogether due to the missing issues. I have ranked these songs by "known" peak, then source (giving advantage to songs that charted on Billboard), then alphabetically by Artist and Song.
Interestingly, I could only find 2 songs that overlapped between June on the Hard Report & September on Billboard. Those are: "Chains Of Love" - Erasure, and "So Excited" - Ranking Roger. Here is the complete list for 1988
EDIT: Thanks to
Verisimilitude & his research into R&R/CMJ charts i was able to add an additional 17 songs to this list...i also upgraded the peak position for many songs. So now, I am ranking the songs thusly:
a) by "known" peak
b) by weeks at #1
c) by source (giving advantage to songs that charted on Billboard, then Hard Report, then CMJ)
d) then alphabetically by artist & song...here are the results using this new updated criteria:
YERank-Peak-Source-Song-Artist-weeks@#101 - 1 B - Orange Crush - REM 8
02 - 1 B - Desire - U2 5
03 - 1 B - Peek-A-Boo - Siouxsie & Banshees 5
04 - 1 H - (Nothing But) Flowers - Talking Heads 5
05 - 1 C - Birthday - Sugarcubes 4
06 - 1 B - All That Money Wants - Psychedelic Furs 3
07 - 1 H - Under The Millky Way - Church 3
08 - 1 H - All Night Long - Peter Murphy 3
09 - 1 H - No New Tale To Tell - Love & Rockets 2
10 - 1 H - Beds Are Burning - Midnight Oil 2
11 - 1 H - Tomorrow People - Ziggy Marley 2
12 - 1 C - Eye Of Fatima - Camper Van Beethoven 2
13 - 1 C - Birth School Work Death - Godfathers 2
14 - 1 C - Fast Car - Tracy Chapman 2
15 - 1 B - Just Play Music - Big Audio Dynamite 1
16 - 1 H - I Need A Man - Eurythmics 1
17 - 1 H - Get Started, Start A Fire - Graham Parker 1
18 - 1 H - Suedehead - Morrissey 1
19 - 1 H - Balloon Man - Robyn Hitchcock 1
20 - 1 H - Mandinka - Sinead O'Connor 1
21 - 2 B - Carolyn's Fingers - Cocteau Twins
22 - 2 B - Killing Jar - Siouxsie & Banshees
23 - 2 H - Hazy Shade Of Winter - Bangles
24 - 2 C - Sidewalking - Jesus & Mary Chain
25 - 2 C - Only A Memory - Smithereens
26 - 2 C - Love Will Tear Us Apart - Swans
27 - 2 C - Airhead - Thomas Dolby
28 - 3 B - Great Commandment - Camouflage
29 - 3 B - Wild Wild West - Escape Club
30 - 3 B - Put This Love To The Test - Jon Astley
31 - 3 B - Crash - Primitives
32 - 3 B - Angel Of Harlem - U2
33 - 3 H - Postcards From Paradise - Flesh For Lulu
34 - 3 C - Christine - House Of Love
35 - 3 C - Inside Out - Mighty Lemon Drops
36 - 3 C - People Have The Power - Patti Smith
37 - 4 B - What I Am - Edie Brickell
38 - 4 B - Breakfast In Bed - UB40
39 - 4 H - Rev It Up - Jerry Harrison
40 - 5 B - In Your Room - Bangles
41 - 5 B - Tumblin Down - Ziggy Marley
42 - 5 H - She's Having A Baby - Dave Wakeling
43 - 5 H - Bed Bugs & Ballyhou - Echo & Bunnymen
44 - 5 H - Tower Of Strength - Mission UK
45 - 5 H - This Corrosion - Sisters Of Mercy
46 - 5 H - Peace In Our Time - Sun & The Moon
47 - 5 H - Killer Moon - T-Bone Burnett
48 - 5 C - Chains Of Love - Erasure
49 - 5 C - Mirror People - Love & Rockets
50 - 5 C - Sometime To Return - Soul Asylum
51 - 5 C - Talkin Bout A Revolution - Tracy Chapman
52 - 6 B - Away - Feelies
53 - 6 B - Back On The Breadline - Hunters & Collectors
54 - 6 B - Jane Says - Jane's Addiction
55 - 6 B - Up There Down There - Patti Smith
56 - 6 B - Intoxication - Shriekback
57 - 6 H - Wheels Turning - Woodentops
58 - 6 C - Sometimes - Firehose
59 - 6 C - Don't Go - Hothouse Flowers
60 - 6 C - Devil Inside - INXS
61 - 6 C - Kidney Bingos - Wire
62 - 7 B - I've Got A Feeling - Screaming Tribesmen
63 - 7 H - Breakaway - Big Pig
64 - 7 C - For The Singer Of REM - Firehose
65 - 7 C - Cold Metal - Iggy Pop
66 - 8 B - Way Behind Me - Primitives
67 - 8 H - Aches & Pains - Bears
68 - 8 H - Dominion - Sisters Of Mercy
69 - 8 H - Rev Jack & His Roamin Cadillac Church - Timbuk 3
70 - 8 C - Jump In The River - Sinead O'Connor
71 - 9 B - What's The Matter Here? - 10,000 Maniacs
72 - 9 B - Tell That Girl To Shut Up - Transvision Vamp
73 - 9 B - Jesus Christ - U2
74 - 9 H - Kiss And Tell - Bryan Ferry
75 - 9 H - Forgotten Town - Christians
76 - 9 C - Just Too Bloody Stupid - Close Lobsters
77 - 9 C - Trash City - Joe Strummer
78 - 9 C - Soviet Snow - Shona Laing
79 - 9 C - Silk Skin Paws - Wire
80 - 10 B - What's On Your Mind (Pure Energy) - Information Society
81 - 10 B - Motorcrash - Sugarcubes
82 - 10 B - When Love Comes To Town - U2
83 - 10 H - Reptile - Church
84 - 10 H - Route 66 - Depeche Mode
85 - 10 H - Golden Calf - Prefab Sprout
86 - 10 H - Sweet Fire Of Love - Robbie Robertson
87 - 10 H - Be Still My Beating Heart - Sting
88 - 10 H - Maybe It Won't Last - Woodentops
89 - 10 C - Crystal Palace - Bible
90 - 10 C - Other 99 - Big Audio Dynamite
91 - 10 C - Victoria - Fall
92 - 10 C - Paradise - Meat Puppets
93 - 10 C - Where Is My Mind? - Pixies
94 - 10 C - When The End Comes Before - Rave-Ups
95 - 10 C - Heaven Knows - Robert Plant
96 - 11 B - King Of Emotion - Big Country
97 - 11 B - Another Kind Of Love - Hugh Cornwell
98 - 11 B - Ana Ng - They Might Be Giants
99 - 11 B - I Say Nothing - Voice Of The Beehive
100 - 11 C - Help Save The Youth Of America - Billy Bragg
101 - 11 C - Pleasure - Railway Children
102 - 11 C - Go Bang - Shriekback
103 - 11 C - I Want Your Hands (On Me) - Sinead O'Connor
104 - 11 C - Don't Let's Start - They Might Be Giants
105 - 12 B - I'm Sorry - Hothouse Flowers
106 - 12 H - So Excited - Ranking Roger
107 - 12 C - Globe Of Frogs - Robyn Hitchcock
108 - 12 C - Coldsweat - Sugarcubes
109 - 13 B - I Don't Want Your Love - Duran Duran
110 - 13 B - High Time - Icicle Works
111 - 13 B - My Bag - Lloyd Cole
112 - 13 H - Hot Hot Hot - Cure
113 - 13 H - New Sensation - INXS
114 - 13 H - Touched By The Hand Of God - New Order
115 - 13 H - Dreaming - OMD
116 - 13 H - Indigo Eyes - Peter Murphy
117 - 13 H - King Of Rock N Roll - Prefab Sprout
118 - 13 H - House We Used To Live In - Smithereens
119 - 13 H - Underneath The Radar - Underworld
120 - 13 C - Blind - Talking Heads
121 - 13 C - Stop This Car - Woodentops
122 - 14 B - Kiss - Art Of Noise
123 - 14 B - Liar, Liar - Debbie Harry
124 - 14 B - Winning Side - Oingo Boingo
125 - 14 B - (Glad I'm) Not A Kennedy - Shona Laing
126 - 14 H - Baby's Got Rockets - Dancing Hoods
127 - 14 H - Hey Cecelie - E*I*E*I*O
128 - 14 H - 40 Years - House Of Freaks
129 - 14 H - Fall Down (Like The Rain) - Mighty Lemon Drops
130 - 14 H - Lovers Jamboree - Nick Lowe
131 - 14 H - I Think She Likes Me - Treat Her Right
132 - 14 H - Young Manhood - Wild Swans
133 - 14 C - Better Be Home Soon - Crowded House
134 - 14 C - Simply Irresistible - Robert Palmer
135 - 14 C - Beat On The Brat - Sonic Youth
136 - 15 B - Walking Away - Information Society
137 - 15 H - Talk About Love - O Positive
138 - 15 H - Flesh Number One (Beatle Dennis) - Robyn Hitchcock
139 - 15 C - Dumb Things - Paul Kelly
140 - 15 C - Troy - Sinead O'Connor
141 - 16 B - She's Got A New Spell - Billy Bragg
142 - 16 B - Anchorage - Michelle Shocked
143 - 16 B - Dream World - Midnight Oil
144 - 16 B - Pop Song 89 - REM
145 - 16 H - I Love The Things You Do To Me - Balaam & The Angel
146 - 16 H - All Day & All Of The Night - Stranglers
147 - 17 B - All I Wanted - In Tua Nua
148 - 17 B - Every Dog Has Its Day - Let's Active
149 - 17 B - Doctorin The Tardis - Timelords
150 - 17 B - Don't Walk Away - Toni Childs
151 - 17 H - Judas Kiss - Del Lords
152 - 17 C - Just Like Paradise - David Lee Roth
153 - 17 C - Dead Heart - Midnight Oil
154 - 17 C - Blind Hearts - Xymox
155 - 18 B - Be With You - Jack Rubies
156 - 18 B - Im Nin Alu - Ofra Haza
157 - 18 H - Lie Detector - Screaming Blue Messiahs
158 - 18 H - Everything's Gonna Turn Out Great - Young Fresh Fellows
159 - 18 C - Disco Dancer - Devo
160 - 19 B - Shark Walk - Shriekback
161 - 19 H - Down In The Trenches - Broadcasters
162 - 19 C - What Is There To Smile About? - Close Lobsters
163 - 19 C - Soldier's Requiem - Naked Raygun
164 - 20 B - Waiting For The Great Leap Forwards - Billy Bragg
165 - 20 B - If Love Was A Train - Michelle Shocked
166 - 20 H - Thousands Are Sailing - Pogues
167 - 20 H - River - Throwing Muses
168 - 20 C - Love Will Tear Us Apart - Joy Division
169 - 21 B - 1969 - Pretenders
170 - 22 B - Slow Turning - John Hiatt
171 - 22 B - Domino Dancing - Pet Shop Boys
172 - 23 B - Perfect - Fairground Attraction
173 - 27 B - Don't Let It Break You Down - Graham Parker
174 - 28 B - Never Tear Us Apart - INXS
175 - 30 B - Living For You - Joan Armatrading
176 - 30 B - Def Con One - Pop Will Eat Itself
177 - 30 B - Turning Of The Tide - Richard Thompson
178 - 30 B - (Believed You Were) Lucky - Til Tuesday
179 - 30 B - Walk The Dinosaur - Was (Not Was)