Interesting that they played "On The Way Down" as an optional extra the week after it falls off the countdown. :o
Looks like that was a "local" extra. From what I can tell, different songs were used as the "national" optional extras.
Here's the full chart (now that I finally have). Note, there are two double-plays this week.
AMERICAN TOP 40 - APRIL 23, 2005
LW TW Artist - TitleLast Week's Number One: Kelly Clarkson - Since U Been Gone-- 40 Backstreet Boys - Incomplete
32 39 Lil' Jon and The East Side Boyz featuring Usher and Ludacris - Lovers And Friends
-- 38 Destiny's Child - Girl
36 37 Gavin DeGraw - Chariot
-- 36 Gwen Stefani - Hollaback Girl
18 35 Mariah Carey featuring Fat Man Scoop and Jermaine Dupri - It's Like That
38 34 Papa Roach - Scars
28 33 Jay-Z and Linkin Park - Numb/Encore
29 32 Nelly featuring Tim McGraw - Over And Over
31 31 Maroon5 - She Will Be Loved
Optional Extra: Sir Mix-A-Lot - Baby Got Back33 30 Jennifer Lopez featuring Fat Joe - Hold You Down
Double-Play: Jennifer Lopez featuring Ja Rule - I'm Real24 29 Ryan Cabrera - True
23 28 Kelly Clarkson - Breakaway
35 27 Howie Day - Collide
26 26 Jet - Look What You've Done
34 25 The Game featuring 50 Cent - Hate It Or Love It
27 24 Omarion - O
30 23 Will Smith - Switch
22 22 Bowling For Soup - Almost
20 21 Destiny's Child featuring T.I. and Lil' Wayne - Soldier
Optional Extra: Jagged Edge featuring Nelly - Where The Party At?23 20 Trick Daddy featuring Ludacris, Lil' Kim, and Cee-Lo - Sugar (Gimme Some)
16 19 Gavin DeGraw - I Don't Want To Be
13 18 The Game featuring 50 Cent - How We Do
21 17 The Killers - Mr. Brightside
15 16 Rob Thomas - Lonely No More
19 15 3 Doors Down - Let Me Go
14 14 Jesse McCartney - Beautiful Soul
11 13 Mario - Let Me Love You
17 12 Akon - Lonely
09 11 Eminem - Mockingbird
Double-Play: Eminem - Lose YourselfOptional Extra: Avril Lavigne - Don't Tell Me10 10 Natalie - Goin' Crazy
12 09 Alicia Keys - Karma
07 08 Ciara featuring Missy Elliott - 1, 2 Step
08 07 50 Cent - Disco Inferno
04 06 Gwen Stefani featuring Eve - Rich Girl
Out Of The Box: Black Eyed Peas - Don't Phunk With My Heart06 05 50 Cent featuring Olivia - Candy Shop
05 04 Frankie J. featuring Baby Bash - Obsession (No Es Amor)
02 03 Green Day - Boulevard Of Broken Dreams
Optional Extra: Ludacris featuring Shawnna - Stand Up03 02 Usher featuring Fabolous - Caught Up
01 01 Kelly Clarkson - Since U Been Gone
** 4 weeks @ no. 1 **DROPPERS:John Mayer - Daughters (from 40)
Switchfoot - Dare You To Move (from 39)
Ryan Cabrera - On The Way Down (from 37)