Kelly Clarkson Album Gems

[ificanthaveyou]

Which is your favorite album gem? I chose "Honestly" for Stronger because it has absolutely no single potential, but is a highlight of the album.

This is a tough choice for me, because I ADORE all of these, but if I had to chose one it would be Maybe. I have heard Kelly live plenty of times, but hearing Maybe performed in Irvine was one of the best Kelly moments I've ever had.

[Hook]

Addicted. I love that song so much. <3

Maybe and Honestly are great too, of course. The other two are meh for me. (love the Smoakstack version of IICHY though)

[Focus]

Maybe- My December by far, then Addicted

[dbhmr]

Maybe is her best song so that wins easily. I'd rank the rest:

Honestly
Addicted
Just Missed the Train
If I Can't Have You

[Deleted]

From these choices? "Just Missed The Train".

I don't consider the others gems at all.

[Jay]

"Maybe" and "Addicted" are two of her best songs ever. I'd rank the other three in this order:

Just Missed the Train
Honestly
If I Can't Have You

[Deleted]

1. Maybe
2. Honestly
3. Addicted
4. Just Missed The Train
5. If I Can't Have You

[Illusions]

Maybe
Just Missed the Train
Addicted
Honestly
Ready If I Can't Have You

[think pink.]

"Just Missed The Train"

[franklin]

Maybe is incredible, easily gets my vote.

o2. Addicted
o3. Honestly
o4. Just Missed the Train
o5. If I Can't Have You

[Au$tin]

"Addicted" hands down.

2. Honestly
3. If I Can't Have You
4. Maybe
5. Just Missed the Train

I love the entire top 4, though. 3 and 4 change depending on my mood.

[strikeleo]

I loved Just Missed The Train, so f**king much. It was probably my favorite from Thankful.

Addicted was great, I remember being sort of sad it didn't get the single treatment, but it hasn't aged well with me. I almost never go back on it, it's sort of too dramatic for me.

Maybe is flawless! I hate using this word but I can't use any other when talking about it, really. "I don't want to be tough, and I don't want to be proud, I don't need to be fixed and I certainly don't need to be found, I'm not (it always sound like she is saying never, which to me is 100x better) lost".

I wasn't big on If I Can't Have You when it was released, and it took me the the new EP to finally see the light. It's a gorgeous track, I prefer it as a ballad but the original track is great, as well.

I ended up voting for Honestly because it's more recent for me, but I do know that Maybe is better. Honestly is gorgeous, as well, and I like that it's something different from what we usually get from Kelly. From music, as a whole. I don't think anyone ever approached that subject, and I can relate so much to it. Sometimes I just need people to be honest, wether they are judging me, hating me, or loving me.

[esoteric76]

Feb 10, 2012 17:19:24 GMT -5 strikeleo said:

I loved Just Missed The Train, so f**king much. It was probably my favorite from Thankful.

Same with me, and I really enjoy Carly Smithson's (aka Hennessy's) version as well. Kelly's is much more compact and polished though, and that voice. Sigh.

[Love Plastic Love]

My favorites from every cd lol. Cannot vote.

[Deleted]

I feel like we've done this poll a million times. But, I'll still participate.

01. Addicted
02. Honestly
03. Maybe
04. If I Can't Have You
05. Just Missed the Train

All are amazing.

[Deleted]

1. Addicted
2. If I Can't Have You
3. Honestly
4. Maybe

5. Just Missed The Train

I like all of them.

[ificanthaveyou]

Feb 10, 2012 18:40:37 GMT -5 Love Plastic Love said:

My favorites from every cd lol. Cannot vote.

Really?!?!?! We are totally soul mates :'(

[Deleted]

Honestly.

Should be a single.