Same title, different song to reach number 1

[prenatt1166]

"MISSING YOU"
1982 Dan Fogelberg
1985 Diana Ross

"HUMAN TOUCH"
1983 Rick Springfield
1992 Bruce Springsteen

"I'LL BE THERE FOR YOU"
1989 Bon Jovi
1995 Rembrandts

"EVERYTHING"
1990 Jody Watley
2004 Alanis Morissette

"HEAVEN KNOWS"
1979 Donna Summer (with Brooklyn Dreams)
2007 Taylor Hicks

"STAY"
2008 Sugarland
2008 Dot Dot Dot

"ANGEL"
1988 Aerosmith
2008 Chaka Khan

"THE TIME OF MY LIFE"
1987 Bill Medley & Jennifer Warnes
2008 David Cook

"UNBELIEVABLE"
2005 Kaci Brown
2008 Josh Gracin

"HOME"
2006 Daughtry
2008 Elliott Yamin

"COME BACK TO ME"
1990 Janet Jackson
2009 David Cook

"FREE"
2008 Elliott Yamin
2010 Zac Brown Band

:)

[popstop]

I Do
1998 - Lisa Loeb
1999 - 98 Degrees

Beautiful
2003 - Christina Aguilera
2003 - Pharrell featuring Snoop Dogg

Home
2007 - Daughtry
2010 - Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeroes

Demons
2001 - Fatboy SLim ft. Macy Gray
2013 - IMagine Dragons

And a couple close calls:

Time of the Season
1999 - Scott Wieland (hit #1)
2010 - Isobel Campbell and Mark Lanergan (hit #2)

F**k You
2008 - Lily Allen (hit #2)
2010 - Cee Lo Green (hit #1)

[Deleted]

Heart Attack
1982 - Olivia Newton-John
2013 - Demi Lovato

Cherish
1985 - Kool & The Gang
1989 - Madonna

I Can't Wait
1986 - Stevie Nicks
1986 - Nu Shooz (it actually dislogded Stevie's from #1)

Always
1987 - Atlantic Starr
1991 - Pebbles

Because Of You
1988 - The Cover Girls
1999 - 98º
2005 - Kelly Clarkson
2007 - Ne-Yo

The Way You Love Me
1988 - Karyn White
2000 - Faith Hill

Real Love
1989 - Jody Watley
1992 - Mary J. Blige

Love Is
1990 - Alannah Myles
1993 - Vanessa Williams & Brian McKnight

Someday
1991 - Mariah Carey
1999 - Sugar Ray

My Love
2001 - Westlife
2008 - Celine Dion

Fallen
2003 - Sarah McLachlan
2003 - Mya

With You
2004 - Jessica Simpson
2004 - Chris Brown

Note: I'm Real and its Murder Remix both went to number one, and though the latter is considered a remix, to me it's a different song.