Same Trailer Different Park vs. Pageant Material

[.indulgecountry]

Pitting the tracks of Kacey's two albums against each other; vote for your favorite song in each set and then pick your favorite of the two albums! Unfortunately "Fine"/the hidden track gets left off because her first album only has 12 songs. That aside, I thought this would be a fun poll to do.



Template to use for your convenience:

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v.Cup of Tea
Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material

[zjames]

01 Silver Lining v. High Time
02 My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
03 Merry Go 'Round v. Late To The Party
04 Dandelion v. Pageant Material
05 Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
06 I Miss You v. Biscuits
07 Step Off v. Somebody To Love
08 Back On The Map v. Miserable
09 Keep It To Yourself v. Die Fun
10 Stupid v. Family Is Family
11 Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12 It Is What It Is v. Cup Of Tea

It's a tie 6-6. But Pageant Material has the fantastic "Fine" and great hidden Willie Nelson track, so I'll give Pageant Material the tiebreaker.

[Deleted]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v. Cup of Tea

8-4 for Same Trailer Different Park.

[.indulgecountry]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v. Cup of Tea
Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material

6-6, but I give the slight edge to Pageant Material overall because I feel it's a bit more consistent. Even though some of the highs on Same Trailer Different Park are incredible, there's also a few songs I don't care for quite so much ("Stupid" in particular).

[Deleted]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v.Cup of Tea

Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material



Two stellar albums, but I do enjoy Kacey's debut a bit more.

Both albums have incredible highs, but there are a few songs on "Pageant" I don't care for based on the first few listens (Fine, Cup Of Tea and Family Is Family)

[14887fan]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party (difficult)
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin'' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club (difficult)
12. It Is What It Is v.Cup of Tea
Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material

8-4, but "Are You Sure?" is in her top ten best songs, and "Fine" practically pulls double-duty in votes over everything else she's ever put on record (barring "Keep It to Yourself"). Both albums are magic.

[zaclord 🌈]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v.Cup of Tea
Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material

Pretty much all of "Same Trailer Different Park" is better in my opinion, but "Pageant Material" has been growing on my tremendously - once I listen to it more, it may be a closer race. But STDP is my all-time favorite album so its big shoes for PM to fill.

[Joe1240]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v. Cup of Tea
Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material,Maybe it's the fact the album is very new but I like Pageant Material more at the moment.Both great albums althrough.

[fearlessarrow]

For me...

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v. Cup of Tea

Album: Same Trailer Different Park v. Pageant Material

7-5 for me. Pageant Material will definitely grow on me more with time ("This Town" and "Family Is Family" haven't done too much for me yet), but as of now, I feel like I would give the edge to "Same Trailer Different Park". But as some of you have been saying, Pageant Material has "Fine" and "Are You Sure", which are both really good. Both albums are so great that it was really difficult to pick one over the other on some of the sets...

[ant]

1. Silver Lining v. High Time
2. My House v. Dime Store Cowgirl
3. Merry Go 'Round v. Late to the Party
4. Dandelion v. Pageant Material
5. Blowin' Smoke v. This Town
6. I Miss You v. Biscuits
7. Step Off v. Somebody to Love *tie*
8. Back on the Map v. Miserable *tie*
9. Keep It to Yourself v. Die Fun
10. Stupid v. Family Is Family
11. Follow Your Arrow v. Good Ol' Boys Club
12. It Is What It Is v. Cup of Tea

Same Trailer Different Park: 5
Pageant Material: 5
(2 ties)

It's hard for me to pick a clear winner.  I really love the hidden track "Are You Sure" with Willie Nelson on Pageant Material and "Fine" is great too.  The only thing missing from Pageant Material for me personally is a rock-ish song like "Blowin' Smoke".  I feel like it would've broken the album up more, since a lot of the songs sound kind of similar.