Post by Albie on Jan 11, 2018 15:44:37 GMT -5
Sam and Green too, thank you for answering one of my questions.
I was also looking to have your opinions on the rest of the players and not just whom you found most suspicious. I suppose one can assume that you don't find the rest of the players suspicious because you didn't mention them but better not to put words in your mouths. If you're still able to answer that part of the question, it'd be great to hear.
Regarding Surf and I as a mafia team, well I'll say that at least you're throwing things out there and I can't blame you for grasping as straws as that's what we've got to work with. I will say that when I mentioned Surf in my player analysis post, I didn't make it out to look like he's posted anything of meaning. Really he hasn't. I was acknowledging the fact that he has indeed been regularly active in the game, even if the only thing he'd done was ask questions of players (mainly you). But it at least it came off as some sort of attempt to spur discussion which the thread had severely been lacking up until last night/this morning.
Also, nothing wrong with making wrong conclusions because, again, at least you're throwing ideas out there and that is the sort of gameplay that we need. Now if you can just back up your ideas a little better you'll be off to a better start.
Its way to draw conclusions and i dont want to make assumptions because i think it would deter people being open and playing the way they are playing i was just curious that post happened after a couple of votes and sometimes that could be a distancing thing or it could be harmless. Just threw it out here so we can talk about it that is all.
I thinking we are rushing to conclusions alot which is natural this early in the game. I dont like the reasons for green or the reasons for Sam who has contributed as little as a lot of people and i think his english isnt greatest? What has green said that is so scummy? short one liners? i tagged Barbie cause up to the last post she hasnt said much, is that scummy? where is Cynthia?
im having a hard time deciding because its not always the one who say the least that are scum, sometimes and often its the ones who say the most. So im at the point of reading through the thread but its hard to digest it, when im working so much so tonight and friday will be dedicated to the game.
however my usual M.O is to throw out things, created discussion and read what is said. If anyone expects flimsy dissertations based on nothing from me hun youll be waiting a long ass time. I go off whats infront of me and so far nothing, but its improving today!
I know what you mean about deterring people from being open. People tend to close up or not want to put forth their ideas when they start to feel cornered or in danger, especially this early on in the game. I don't think we are rushing to conclusions, per se, but any conclusions that have been drawn so far are flimsy at best. Which is why I didn't even try to do my player analysis based on scummy to least scummy. Do I think Greentoo and Sam are scummy. No. I worked on who was even playing in any manner that would be beneficial to town at the moment. Not playing or contributing is not helpful and while that is in no way a guarantee that we're going to get the lynch right, given what we've got, there is something to be said for trimming the fat, if you will. Unless of course, players like Sam, Greentoo and Cynthia step up their game in the next 24 hours.
Also, Surfboardt I'll be looking for you to continue your thoughts on the rest of the players later on.