The Highest Debut (On Your Chart) W/O Hitting #1

[620 Soul Train]

I will start off with mine:

Good Charlotte - Girls & Boys

Chart Run:
2-2-2-3-4-4-4-6-10-16-16-17-19-20-31-33-35-37-37-40-39

The Foo Fighters - Times Like These kept them out of the number one spot!

[FreakyFlyBry]

Melanie C f/Lisa "Left-Eye" Lopes - Never Be The Same Again - debuted at #8, peaked at #3.

Robbie Williams - Angels - debuted at #13, but only peaked at #9!

This was most common in late 1999-2000 on my chart, since I expanded to top 100, it rarely happens anymore.

[jond7699]

Here are my top 5 highest debuts w/out hitting number one

5: Korn - "Did My Time"
9-8-6-4-5-15-30

4: City High - "What Would You Do"
7-7-18-40

3: New Edition - "Hit Em Off"
7-10-4-13-26-34-40

2: Mel B -"Tell Me"
4-2-2-2-2-2-3-3-3-5-6-7-8-7-6-9-4-4-8-10-14-16-19-20-20-20-19-20-23-27-29-33-35-39-38-36-36-35-35-33-36-36-39 (Note: This is one of those songs that you just can't get enough of. Atleast it was for me. It had an amazing 43 weeks on my chart. Unfortunately 3 Doors Down's "Loser" and Dream's "He Loves U Not" kept it from hitting number one)

1: Mariah Carey / Bonecrusher - "The One" (So So Def Remix)
2-4-5 (Note: I know this is still charting for me but it will not regain it's bullet so this will be the highest debut without hitting #1)

[af18c]

Although I don't have the exact chart run...on my chart last year "Hero" by Chad Kroeger & Josey Scott debut at #17 (out of 30) and only made it to around #5 i'm gonna say...although I'm not sure...i know it didnt hit #1

[Deleted]

That record would go to Kylie Minogue's "Love At First Sight" which debuted at #3 and peaked at #2.

[insect2]

The highest debut in the history of my chart, "Hands Clean" by Alanis Morissette, debuted at #16 only to peak at #3. In my opinion, there's no way that should have debuted so high, but I'll live with the #3 peak.

[Matt4319]

Staind's "For You" debuted at #4 in late 2001 but only peaked at #2, kept out by Puddle of Mudd's "Blurry" (which spent a then-record 6 weeks at #1).

[Devil Marlena Nylund]

Hmmm, good question. I think the Philosopher Kings entered at #41 on my Top 100 and peaked at #40 with 'Supersexworld'.

Eminem's 'Stan' went 68-4 and peaked at #4 for four weeks. So that's probably the Top 40 record.

[BlahBlahBlah]

Mister said:

Hmmm, good question. I think the Philosopher Kings entered at #41 on my Top 100 and peaked at #40 with 'Supersexworld'.

One Ton.

[Devil Marlena Nylund]

BlahBlahBlah said:

One Ton.

'Supersex69'

[JCMF3]

In 1999 & 2000, I allowed Christmas songs to chart on my personal chart (now I make a separate Holiday chart). Then, the record would be for Christina Aguilera's "The Christmas Song", which debuted at #12 and peaked at #2. (This was when I had a top 20 chart).

For non-holiday songs,this record is held by *N Sync's "Pop", which debuted at #17 or #18, but only peaked at #3. (This is when the chart was a top 30).

[chartfanatic]

Top 5 Debuts With On Chart w/o hitting #1

5) August 5, 2000
Eminem...The Way I Am
Debut: #3 | Peak: #3 (2wks)

4) August 4, 2001
Mandy Moore...Crush
Debut: #3 | Peak: #3 (10)

3) May 11, 2002
Korn...Here To Stay
Debut: #2 | Peak: #2 (1)

T1.) December 8, 2001
P.O.D....Youth Of The Nation
Debut: #2 | Peak: #2 (4)

T1.) September 14, 2001
Britney Spears...I'm A Slave 4 U
Debut: #2 | Peak: #2 (4)

[Control]

Family Affair, Mary J. Blige
2-2-2-2-2-3-7-11-11 (Top 15 chart at the time)
Debut: 2 / Peak: 2

Boy (I Need You), Mariah Carey featuring Cam'ron
3-3-3-2-2-2-5-5-7-12-14-17-17-19-20
Debut: 3 / Peak: 2

Miss Independent, Kelly Clarkson
3-2-2-2-3-3-3-3-7-7-10-10-13-15-16-16-17-18-17-19-19-18-20
Debut: 3 / Peak: 2

[WhySoSerious?]

Looks like it's going to be Michelle Branch who debuted at #17 with "Breathe". It's currently #9 and I don't see it going to #1.

[iceman]

Way back in '97 the Backstreet Boys debuted at #14 and peaked at #2 with "Quit Playing Games With My Heart".

[Joe1240]

The Ones that I know of-

Outkast-The Whole World
Peak-2 Debut-2 Weeks-4

Korn-Here To Stay
Peak-2 Debut-3 Weeks-8

Kelly Rowland-Stole
Peak-2 Debut-3 Weeks-8

Kylie Minogue-Love At First Sight
Peak-2 Debut-4 Weeks-7


All are from when the chart was just a top 10

[Night Senses]

Take Me Away, FeFe Dobson
Debut: #12 | Peak: #2

Volcano, Damien Rice
Debut: #12 | Peak: #3

It Only Hurts When I'm Breathing, Shania Twain
Debut: #12 | Peak: #5

Chocolate, Kylie Minogue
Debut: #12 | Peak: #5

Nothing Fails, Madonna
Debut: #12 | Peak: #10

Numb, Linkin Park
Debut: #13 | Peak: #3

Harder To Breathe, Maroon 5
Debut: #13 | Peak: #5

Perfect Time Of Day, Howie Day
Debut: #13 | Peak: #8


#12 is definitely THAT number. lol.

[eric]

In 2005, my technical highest debut is:

09 -- DJ Z-Trip feat. Chester Bennington "Walking Dead"

[Libra]

Y'know, I was sifting through this forum's archives and I looked in this thread, but decided not to dig it up. But seeing as how someone else has done it for me ;)...

It's a tie:

Britney Spears Featuring Pharrell, "Boys (Co-Ed Remix)". That debuted at #10 on 7/27/02, but only peaked at #6.

Daniel Bedingfield, "If You're Not the One". That debuted at #10 on 4/27/03, but only peaked at #5.

[gbaby]

Funny how all of these high debuts didn't even hit #1.

Anyway, for me it's #2.

TLC's "Damaged" debued at #2, but never quite got the top spot. It spent most of it's chart run fighting it's way inside the top 5.

Alicia Keys' "If I Ain't Got You" also debued at #2 on my chart. It managed to spend a week at the top, but then began it's slow descend down that chart.

There were one or two other songs which debued at #2, but I can't think of them. :)

[Topay]

In 2004, Shania Twain's "Party For Two" debuted at 3 and fell from there.

[Joe1240]

Joe1240 said:

The Ones that I know of-

Outkast-The Whole World
Peak-2  Debut-2 Weeks-4

Korn-Here To Stay
Peak-2  Debut-3  Weeks-8

Kelly Rowland-Stole
Peak-2  Debut-3  Weeks-8

Kylie Minogue-Love At First Sight
Peak-2  Debut-4  Weeks-7


All are from when the chart was just a top 10

In the Top 20 Era,
It is a tie,

Evanescence-My Immortal
Debut-#3 Peak-#3

Janet Jackson-Just A Little While
Debut-#3-Peak#2

D12 F/Eminem-My Band
Debut-#3-Peak#2

Janet Jackson-I Want You
Debut-#3-Peak#3

[The Rebirth Of ffej]

Lindsay Lohan- Over Debut:3 Peak: 3
But that was on my ver first chart so I don't know if it counts

[Night Senses]

ffej said:

Lindsay Lohan- Over Debut:3 Peak: 3
But that was on my ver first chart so I don't know if it counts

Yeah, I don't really count my first chart for any records or anything like that. But some people do. :)

[allow that]

Dave Matthews "Stay Or Leave" which debuted at #14 and peaked at #3. This wasn't an actual single though, it's the only album track I ever allowed to chart because we played it so many times over the summer that most of my friends assumed it was a single anyway, so I let it chart for accuracy of what I was hearing the most at that time, if that makes sense.

[BadRomance]

Gwen Stefani - Hollaback Girl
Destiny's Child - Girl
50 Cent - Just a Lil Bit

[B-Boy]

Here's my Top 3 (2006 - Now). Other non #1's debuted b/w #7 - #10

"So Lonely"- Twista & Mariah Carey
Debut: March 18, 2006 - #2
Peak: #2 (3 weeks)

"Buddy" - Musiq Soulchild
Debut: January 20, 2007 -#3
Peak: #3 (2 weeks)

"Chop Me Up" - Justin Timberlake
Debut: March 1, 2008 - #4
Peak: #4

[jrnleblanc]

Fergie - Big Girls Dont Cry

Debut: #2
Peak: #2

Umbrella was #1 at the time

[Au$tin]

I've had two songs debut at #10.

The first was Nicki Minaj's "Starships." The other was Florence + the Machine's "Shake It Out." However, it must be pointed out that "Shake It Out"'s debut was on the chart's tenth week when I changed the formula for the point system, making it easier for songs to make it onto the chart. There's no doubt in my mind "Shake It Out" would have debuted at a lower position a week or two sooner. Also, "Starships"'s debut was during the first formula. If I was using the new method, it also would have debuted the week prior at a lower number.

[Kurt]

I've had two songs debut and peak at #2:

Adele - "Set Fire To The Rain"
2-2-2-2-2-2-2-3-3-3-3-5-8-10-15-17-22-20-20-21-27-31-35-38-39-41-47-47-42-20-16-11-10-7-7-7-7-4-4-4-4-5-9-10-11-14-17-18-24

Kelly Clarkson - "Dark Side"
2-2-2-2-4-6-12-17-17-23-25-26-28-32-39-49-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-34-18-22-25-21-29