singingrulebritannia
Diamond Member
source: https://twitter.com/spookyfoxinc/status/1832168743704596972
Joined: January 2010
Posts: 25,640
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by singingrulebritannia on Jul 15, 2019 6:22:23 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) {6.4} vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) {6.9}
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) {7.9} vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) {5.8}
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) {6.3} vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) {6.4}
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) {7.1} vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) {7}
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) {8.4} vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) {6.1}
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) {7.3} vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) {8.2}
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) {8.8} vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) {7.2}
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) {6.6} vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) {7.3}
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) {6.2} vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7) {6.4}
|
|
Beno
2x Platinum Member
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 2,216
|
Post by Beno on Jul 15, 2019 8:42:41 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) (strong 7) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) (light 7) "Borderline" is much better than Patience imo
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) (light 8) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) (decent 6)
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) (decent 7) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) (decent 7)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) (decent 8) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) (light 8) Expect me to put "Longshot" super high come the end of the year
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) (strong 7) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) (strong 6)
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) (strong 7) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) (decent 7) "Silver Needle" would've been so much better with different vocals imo
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) (light 7) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) (decent 7)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) (light 7) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) (strong 7) This Foals era hasn't wowed me all that much tbh but "In Degrees" is probably the best song I've heard from it thus far.
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) (light 7) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7) (light 7)
|
|
|
Post by American Idiot on Jul 15, 2019 8:53:30 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7)
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7)
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7)
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7)
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7)
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
Lordef†ones
6x Platinum Member
Let's drown underneath the stars
Joined: April 2013
Posts: 6,271
|
Post by Lordef†ones on Jul 15, 2019 10:48:01 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
janinho
2x Platinum Member
Joined: March 2017
Posts: 2,995
|
Post by janinho on Jul 15, 2019 16:49:05 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7)FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7)Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7)Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) (Very close)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7)Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7)The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
Red
Moderator
Hey, it's that old guy!
...that's bad
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 19,007
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Red on Jul 15, 2019 19:08:53 GMT -5
A reminder that the deadline to vote or edit your posts is tomorrow, July 16th, at 8pm US Eastern. As always, if you're not tagged, you are still more than welcome to participate!
|
|
Butterflies & Hurricanes
9x Platinum Member
"youve got 2B the best, youve got to change the world & use this chance 2B heard, your time is now"
Joined: January 2015
Posts: 9,813
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him/his
|
Post by Butterflies & Hurricanes on Jul 15, 2019 21:17:03 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7)
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7)
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7)
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7)
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7)
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) [/b]vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
peacebone
6x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2015
Posts: 6,441
Pronouns: he/him/they/them
|
Post by peacebone on Jul 16, 2019 12:04:53 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) This is kind of an underdog vote, I like both of these fine enough but they're about equal in quality. At any rate, Patience would have definitely gotten my vote here, wish it hadn't gotten such a rough matchup.
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) I was going to pick this myself, took it off my list expecting someone else would take it though.
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7)
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) Early post-punk is my s**t, so ACR + Barry Adamson should theoretically be something I should love...but this ain't doing it for me.
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7)
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
Red
Moderator
Hey, it's that old guy!
...that's bad
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 19,007
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Red on Jul 16, 2019 12:35:38 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) ("Abschied" was interesting, to be sure, and I was half-tempted to vote for it...but I can't vote against Tame Impala yet)
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) ("My Cheating Heart" reminds me of a couple of songs in particular, all of which that I really like (particularly "Lemon to a Knife Fight" in spots)...and yet, this didn't really stand out to me in the same way those songs did when I listened to them for the first time...maybe it'll grow on me?)
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) (okay, you know what I'm going to vote for, but I cannot say I was prepared for this change in direction from Meat Puppets *at all*...I don't think it completely succeeds, but the novelty of it all is engaging)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) ("Warm" is my personal least favorite of the songs on the Skyward Pines EP, but I like all three of the songs, and "Longshot", while fine, isn't quite good enough for me to vote against "Warm")
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) (I feel like I would need 5-10 listens to fully digest everyting going on in "Europa 22", and songs like those are ones that I always enjoy listening to, even when they're bad...and "Europa" isn't bad...crazy to think that ACR are still releasing new material after over 40 years, they fit in pretty well in the modern climate, too)
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) (well, "Silver Needle" definitely sounds like a song I imagine AI would submit, lol...not that there's anything wrong with that, or the song, for that matter...but holy hell, I LOVE the Ningen Isu song, this hits me in a sweet spot that I was unaware that I needed to fill)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) (I love "Shoulderblades", and I'm going to vote for it, but maaaaaan, "Toys" is so interesting, I can't wait to hear it again)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) ("In Degrees" almost sounds like "Adventure of a Lifetime" but on a massive amount of steroids, and I, honestly, wouldn't say that it's a bad thing..."Moon", meanwhile, reminds me a decent bit of older Paramore, which, also, isn't a bad thing...tough vote, this)
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7) ("I Dare You" has a bit of a "Strokes/Julian Casablancas but female" vibe, and I can't say I'm against it (and I see that wheat beat me to the comparison)...I think that I preferred "Tokyo" to "Believe It", but "Believe It" was solid, too...sure, let's just close the set out with another tough matchup)
|
|
Butterflies & Hurricanes
9x Platinum Member
"youve got 2B the best, youve got to change the world & use this chance 2B heard, your time is now"
Joined: January 2015
Posts: 9,813
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him/his
|
Post by Butterflies & Hurricanes on Jul 16, 2019 13:43:00 GMT -5
I wonder if I had submitted this Talking Heads cover instead I could’ve possibly gotten more votes
|
|
lyhom
Diamond Member
CAPSLOCK-PHOBE
Joined: January 2014
Posts: 11,376
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by lyhom on Jul 16, 2019 15:46:51 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
|
Post by Doc Indie Party Rock on Jul 16, 2019 23:34:21 GMT -5
I wonder if I had submitted this Talking Heads cover instead I could’ve possibly gotten more votes The music is definitely cool, but the vocals seem very uninteresting. I would have preferred Confidence Man doing the vocals. BTW, I'm glad you submitted "Dirty Boy"
|
|
willapted33
9x Platinum Member
blonded
Joined: February 2017
Posts: 9,525
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by willapted33 on Jul 17, 2019 5:49:25 GMT -5
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) both of these were decent, not better and not worse
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7)
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7)
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7)
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7)
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7)
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7)
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7)
|
|
Red
Moderator
Hey, it's that old guy!
...that's bad
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 19,007
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Red on Jul 17, 2019 8:29:12 GMT -5
ROCK TOURNAMENT: SUMMERTIME MADNESS 2019
Sorry about the lateness of this post, but I just got sidetracked yesterday and didn't really have the time to post this. My apologies.
ROUND 1, SET 3: #2s VS. #7s, PART ONE (RESULTS)
Tame Impala - Borderline (Daryl, #2) (9) vs. Die Ärzte - Abschied (janinho, #7) (5) -- I do not agree that "Borderline" is better than "Patience", but one way it has proven itself to be superior is by advancing into the next round of RoTo.
FKA twigs - Cellophane (willapted33, #2) (8) vs. Love Fame Tragedy - My Cheating Heart (BlurryFaceKyle, #7) (6) -- It looked like "My Cheating Heart" would win for a while, but a spirited comeback by "Cellophane" shoots it straight into the next round.
Rammstein - Deutschland (Red, #2) (5) vs. Meat Puppets - Vampyr's Winged Fantasy (Lordeftones, #7) (9) -- Daryl, you have to stop calling songs facing Rammstein "underdogs". Rammstein are the "underdogs" purely because of who they are. (It doesn't help that, both times you referred to their opponents as "underdogs", they lost.)
Skyward Pines - Warm (Beno, #2) (7) vs. Catfish & The Bottlemen - Longshot (MoD, #7) (7) -- The second Skyward Pines song pulls off what I have to consider an upset...by the skin of its teeth.
Bilderbuch - Europa 22 (disassociative, #2) (10) vs. A Certain Ratio - Dirty Boy (bangwave, #7) (4) -- I can't say that I was expecting "Europa 22" to win convincingly, let alone dominate like this...but here we are!
Idiot Pilot - Silver Needle (American Idiot, #2) (10) vs. Ningen Isu - 無情のスキャット (disassociative, #7) (4) -- On the other hand, I expected this domination. *sigh* My favorite discovery so far falls to the wayside.
Girl Band - Shoulderblades (shazam, #2) (4) vs. Sloth & Turtle - Toys (lyhom, #7) (10) -- Another of my favorite songs this set falls, albeit to another one of my favorite discoveries in this set.
Foals - In Degrees (Local Native, #2) (7) vs. The Y Axes – Moon (wheatsquares33, #7) (7) -- Arguably the closest matchup in this set is handed to the higher seed, but man, I was not expecting this matchup to be so close.
The Regrettes - I Dare You (BlurryFaceKyle, #2) (10) vs. White Lies - Believe It (dr.indie, #7) (4) -- And here's a matchup that I expected to be closer than it actually was. At any rate, The Regrettes...do not regret this matchup.
...
I'll see myself out.
A reminder that the first round will have three day deadlines (though two of the sets have already went past the three day mark...whoops), while every subsequent round will have two day deadlines. Because of the early post time for this set, the deadline day for voting is Saturday, July 20th. The deadline time will be the same in every round: 8pm US Eastern, which should be around the time that I post every new set. This is likely not going to be the norm.
If you did not submit, you are still allowed to vote! The voting process is not exclusive to those who submitted songs, hence why posters who didn't submit this time are still being tagged. If you wish to be removed from the tag list, though, I will do so without further questions.
ROUND 1, SET #4: #2s vs #7s, PART TWO KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
|
Post by American Idiot on Jul 17, 2019 8:50:32 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7)
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7)
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7)
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7)
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7)
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7)
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7)
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
peacebone
6x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2015
Posts: 6,441
Pronouns: he/him/they/them
|
Post by peacebone on Jul 17, 2019 9:58:58 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7)
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) This Life might be the most baffled I've been by any acclaimed song this year, this is pretty much a Jason Mraz song repackaged as Vampire Weekend. And I'm not just saying this because of what it's up against.
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7)
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7)
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) I love a good extremely out-of-left-field pick
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) This is...actually a surprisingly tough matchup, may or may not flip my vote later.
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7)
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
singingrulebritannia
Diamond Member
source: https://twitter.com/spookyfoxinc/status/1832168743704596972
Joined: January 2010
Posts: 25,640
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by singingrulebritannia on Jul 18, 2019 0:53:01 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) {6.3} vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) {5.5}
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) {8.3} vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) {5.5}
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) {5.8} vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) {7}
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) {5} vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) {6.4}
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) {6.5} vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) {8}
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) {7.3} vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) {6.4}
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) {7.1} vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) {6.2}
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) {5.8} vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) {7}
|
|
|
Post by BlurryKyle on Jul 18, 2019 1:04:17 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
maine
Moderator
Joined: February 2014
Posts: 27,379
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by maine on Jul 18, 2019 7:05:35 GMT -5
Hopefully I can get my votes in for this set. I've been insanely busy since this started up.
|
|
|
Post by Daryl the Beryl on Jul 18, 2019 8:26:18 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Both of these are good, but I prefer the funk vibe in Dysfunctional.
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Finally heard Superbike yesterday, and it's pretty damn great. Voting against my pick once again.
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Good is a song that has been done better other times before. Punk for the win.
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Both are solid but Bracket's song has better vocals so it gets my vote.
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) That World was pretty interesting, I dig it. White Onions was good, too.
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Both are two solid discoveries
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) Waste is the shortest of the three SP songs, but it's still damn great.
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) The Crows song is another great discovery, and Choke has cooled off me a little.
|
|
MoD
3x Platinum Member
t!wiki bopis
the sun will blind my eyes, I love you anyways
Joined: October 2017
Posts: 3,589
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by MoD on Jul 18, 2019 14:44:22 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) tough one, so yeah let's go with the underdog Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7)Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7)
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
|
Post by Doc Indie Party Rock on Jul 19, 2019 0:13:51 GMT -5
ROUND 1, SET #4: #2s vs #7s, PART TWO KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) DYSFUNCTIONAL sounds like dysfunctional rock which sounds more like Pop :kii: , but I like the groovy Bruno Mars vibe. I'm still Gotta go full throttle for Kaiser Chiefs. More groovy vibes but with my type of guitar vibes. Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) I like the idea of riding a superbike. I like the guitar hooks and female vocals even more. "This Life" is a decent little "diddy", but not one I can take seriously. Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) I already gave a good review to "Good". It's pumpy, jumpy and fun. "Free At Last" is not bad musically, but vocally he sounds like he is being eaten by a shark. Just like the album sleeve suggests. Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Bracket offered a surprisingly good song here, but no way I go against the guitar fire of "When I'm Gone". Also I kinda forget I had submitted it, but it also makes perfect sense I did.. Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) These guys are releasing a bunch of songs at one time. This one is also great. Love the synth hook throughout the song that becomes more amplified by the backing of the guitars. "That World" was pretty much what I expected. A Science fiction movie theme song. Not bad for Star Trek part 15. Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Got some cool Cranberries vibes here. Good song. "Incapable" was like Jazz Disco. It wasn't bad, I just prefer to rank Disco Jams with Disco James Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) Did you each submit one song from this album? Anyway, out of the ones I previewed here, this one is surely my favorite so far. "When I Dream" has elements I like, but I'm going with "Waste" ,so I can say I voted at least one time for them. Support your local PULSE musicians. IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) man some of these match ups are tuff as nails. Make is harder to be fair, especially when a song like "Choke" is already etched as being one of my favorite Alt rock songs of 2019. I'm choosing "Chain Of Being" because those fast bass lines pull me in like magnets.
|
|
Beno
2x Platinum Member
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 2,216
|
Post by Beno on Jul 19, 2019 8:21:18 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) (decent 7) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) (light 8) "Record Collection" is one of my favourite discoveries of the tournament so far, great pick James!
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) (strong 7) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) (light 7)
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) (strong 5) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) (decent 7)
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) (light 6) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) (decent 6)
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) (decent 7) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) (decent 7) Close matchup, voting for the underdog here
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) (strong 7) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) (strong 7) Toughest matchup of the set, this could've really gone either way
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) (decent 7) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) (light 8)
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) (decent 7) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) (light 7) Choke has such a good chorus but I don't love the rest of the song as much
|
|
wheatsquares33
6x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2015
Posts: 6,975
Pronouns: they/them
|
Post by wheatsquares33 on Jul 19, 2019 15:22:43 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) (strong 6 to light 7) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) (light to decent 7) Dysfunctional was kinda cool, sounded equal parts Nevermind, new Tame Impala, and Persona with an added layer of smooth soul. I question how much of a rock song it is, but it was enjoyable. I liked the Kaiser Chiefs song more than I had expected, never been a huge fan of theirs. Sounds like its straight from 2008, but not in a bad way I don't guess.
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) (decent to strong 7) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) (light to decent 4) Superbike was nice, I liked the guitar riff, but I've already forgotten everything about it. I have never cared much for Vampire Weekend as it is, but this is easily their most obnoxious single.
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) (light to decent 5) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) (light to decent 7) Never cared much for Good, sounds like discount Feel It Still with an annoying baby voice in the chorus. Pup is another band my bf likes a lot but I just can't get into. They seem up my alley, I just don't like the way the guy sings. This is one of their better songs though.
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) (decent to strong 7) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) (decent to strong 6) I like When I'm Gone like way more than I expect myself to. Normally this brand of Active rock which has been out of style for 25 years doesn't do much for me, but this one just works? Maybe it's just a more novel sound in the current Active landscape, idk. Bracket song was okay, sounds like a leftover from the alt 1993 rankdown.
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) (decent to strong 7) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) (light to decent 7) I could've sworn we've had this Foals song in a rock tournament before, but maybe I'm thinking of Wintertime Madness/any number of Foals songs that have been here already. I like it though. Tim Hecker song was nice, sounds like something from the Journey soundtrack which I do love. Again, kinda questioning the rock cred, but I guess there isn't an ambient tournament to submit Tim Hecker in, so whatever!
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) (strong 8 to light 9) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) (decent to strong 6) Incapable was fine and catchy enough, but did not need to be 8 minutes long, especially since there's just not that much variety in the groove to warrant that length.
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) (decent to strong 7) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) (decent to strong 6) This is the best Skyward Pines song so far, good guitar performance towards the end and I like the energy. San Cisco song was listenable.
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) (strong 8 to light 9) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) (light to decent 6) I really like Choke! Crows song did not do much for me.
|
|
lyhom
Diamond Member
CAPSLOCK-PHOBE
Joined: January 2014
Posts: 11,376
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by lyhom on Jul 19, 2019 17:14:30 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7)
I can't fucking believe I'm voting against "white onions" this early either but I am
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
Red
Moderator
Hey, it's that old guy!
...that's bad
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 19,007
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Red on Jul 19, 2019 17:51:18 GMT -5
A reminder that the deadline to vote or edit your posts is tomorrow, July 20th, at 8pm US Eastern. As always, if you're not tagged, you are still more than welcome to participate!
|
|
janinho
2x Platinum Member
Joined: March 2017
Posts: 2,995
|
Post by janinho on Jul 20, 2019 13:27:23 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|
maine
Moderator
Joined: February 2014
Posts: 27,379
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by maine on Jul 20, 2019 13:28:34 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) - KAYTRANADA is a solid producer. "DYSFUNCTIONAL" was pretty good. Cool production as usual coming from KAYTRANADA. Kaiser Chiefs have completely altered their sound over the years, and I think this was a good change this go round. Their last album felt forced, but this feels more organic. "Record Collection" is super catchy and addictive.
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) - "Superbike" was chill. It reminds me of another artist / song, but I can't seem to put my finger on it. "This Life" is super Hawaiian sounding. It feels weird to say that I've liked two Vampire Weekend songs this year, but here we are. TIL that "This Life" interpolates an ILoveMakonnen song. I think I like "This Life" more, but I'll go with the underdog vote.
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) - "Good" is fun. I don't like his voice that much, but the production is nice and it's pretty catchy. Though, I've always thought there was something kinda missing in the song. The song itself just doesn't really have that oomph to it. "Free at Last" was kinda generic punk sounding, but I will admit I enjoyed it a decent bit.
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) - If we're gonna go with AC/DC ripoffs, I'll gladly go with Goodbye June. John Dirty Honey's vocals are super annoying and whiny. He's okay on some of the chorus, but that's about it. The instrumentation is nice, but it's been done time and time again. "Canned from the Food Drive" was generic, but his vocals weren't annoying so that's a plus. I didn't really care for either song here.
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) - "White Onions" is dope. One of my favorites off of their new album. "That World" is really good background music. It's got a haunting vibe to it. This one is insanely hard, but f**k it, let's go with the left field pick.
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) - "Man Who Wasn't There" was really good. Great vocals and a nice, chill production on it. I accidentally had the playlist on shuffle when I started this, and "Man Who Wasn't There" came on after "DYSFUNCTIONAL", and I was real excited to get to this song when it came time. It delivered. "Incapable" kinda reminded me of Robyn actually. It was nice, but it didn't do all that much for me.
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) - "Waste" is good. I want to say this is the last of the three songs I've heard from Skyward Pines? I have heard the other two in my playlist randomly (not through RoTo), but I was missing the third – which I think is this. This is solid. Not as great as "A Poem" but still good. I love "Hey Did I Do You Wrong?" from San Cisco – I sing it to myself all the time still. "When I Dream" was nice. They kinda remind me of The Mowgli's if you took out all the gang vocals. Kind of similar vibes. This one was hard, but I'll lean towards "Waste" here.
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) - "Choke" is bleh. I haven't really been high on it the entire time its been charting. "Chain of Being" was solid. It had a nice driving production to it.
|
|
Red
Moderator
Hey, it's that old guy!
...that's bad
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 19,007
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Red on Jul 20, 2019 14:31:17 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) (I mean, I think I've established with my own submission this time that I'm not entirely against the idea of submitting songs that aren't "rock" by definition, and I dug the tight beat in "DYSFUNCTIONAL"; "Record Collection" kind of both sounds like Kaiser Chiefs and something much more of its time, like it's their take on the modern sound...it's fine, but I expected more)
Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) ("Superbike" might be one of my favorite songs in the entire tournament...and I prefer "Harmony Hall" to "This Life" anyway)
Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) ("Good" sounds a bit like a mix of Portugal. The Man and "HandClap"-era Fitz and the Tantrums...which isn't exactly the best comparison, but I suppose that "Good" has its charms; "Free at Last" really makes me want to check out the PUP album more, and I was already interested in listening to it before)
Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) (well..."When I'm Gone" is definitely a Doc pick, alright; "Canned from the Food Drive", in comparison, isn't great, but it's good enough)
Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) (every song I've heard from this Foals album suggests an album that isn't mind-blowing, but completely and totally solid, and "White Onions" is no exception; I appreciate that we are increasingly less likely to shy away from long songs in RoTos these days, it definitely gives us a little more variety...and "That World" feels like the kind of song that I can just put on in the background and immerse myself in...tough matchup, this)
Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) (oh, "Man Who Wasn't There" is nice...very, very nice...I don't want to vote against it, but, I mean, I can't vote FOR it in this matchup)
Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) (I love "Waste", so it's going to take a lot for me to vote against it...and though I thought that "When I Dream" was nice, it wasn't quite enough)
IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7) (I feel like I should like "Choke" more than I do, especially given the chorus...but the rest of the song isn't on the level of the chorus; "Chain of Being" is really nice, nothing groundbreaking, but just a solid, solid piece of music)
|
|
Lordef†ones
6x Platinum Member
Let's drown underneath the stars
Joined: April 2013
Posts: 6,271
|
Post by Lordef†ones on Jul 20, 2019 17:02:45 GMT -5
KAYTRANADA & VanJess - DYSFUNCTIONAL (lyhom, #2) vs. Kaiser Chiefs - Record Collection (Local Native, #7) Jay Som - Superbike (peacebone, #2) vs. Vampire Weekend - This Life (Daryl, #7) Twin XL - Good (bangwave, #2) vs. PUP - Free at Last (willapted33, #7) Dirty Honey - When I'm Gone (dr.indie, #2) vs. Bracket - Canned from the Food Drive (American Idiot, #7) Foals - White Onions (MoD, #2) vs. Tim Hecker - That World (shazam, #7) Boston Marriage – Man Who Wasn’t There (wheatsquares33, #2) vs. Róisín Murphy - Incapable (Red, #7) Skyward Pines - Waste (Lordeftones, #2) vs. San Cisco - When I Dream (Beno, #7) IDKHOW - Choke (janinho, #2) vs. Crows - Chain of Being (peacebone, #7)
|
|