Web
3x Platinum Member
Joined: January 2014
Posts: 3,985
|
Post by Web on Mar 31, 2020 14:31:57 GMT -5
idk if i'm going to be around for EOD and not sure if this has to be formalized with a vote or not so
Request: Extension
bc getting everyone's thoughts would be helpful
|
|
|
Post by Mayman on Mar 31, 2020 14:34:24 GMT -5
I agree, I would like more information from everyone before the day is over.
Request: Extension
|
|
|
Post by Devil Marlena Nylund on Mar 31, 2020 15:14:26 GMT -5
If people are willing to keep playing Iβm definitely in. If an extension is needed, Iβm fully on board.
Request: extension
Youβre all in my thoughts and Iβm sure we can all say the same. Sending well wishes where theyβre needed.
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Mar 31, 2020 16:00:09 GMT -5
Okay, the majority has spoken! You'll receive a 48-hour extension~
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Mar 31, 2020 16:04:26 GMT -5
D5 Vote Count #4:[2] Codex - Lordefβ ones , Exclusive * [2] @doinktheclown - Devil Marlena Nylund , Codex[1] Exclusive - Web [1] Ginger Spice - MaymanNot Voting: @antigonerising , @doinktheclown , gabe , Ginger Spice *Codex would be lynched as they received the most votes first. With 10 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.
There is 1 day, 23 hours, and 55 minutes on the clock
Sub Reminders: Ginger replaced Nick, Cynthia replaced Anna, CagedJuggalo replaced BB, Gabe replaced Tanooki.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 31, 2020 16:25:01 GMT -5
Vote: Juggalo
I'm sorry I've been useless. Between IRL and other games/RD, I'm just not here. Honestly I just joined as a favor because Mylo really cares about this game, but I can't fake interest if I keep forgetting this exists. Everyone's gonna be mad at me, but I'm just out of it
|
|
Lordefβ ones
6x Platinum Member
Let's drown underneath the stars
Joined: April 2013
Posts: 6,271
|
Post by Lordefβ ones on Mar 31, 2020 20:58:14 GMT -5
Matt and I have come to an agreement. Unfortunately, as we've exhausting a long list of possible subs, we won't do anymore unless someone comes to us who is able to sub into the game.
If you need to go out of the game, from now on you'll be 'killed' out of the game until further notice. For those who have already requested subs, you can consider if you want to continue playing or be 'killed' out of the game. We'd stay in the same phase as we are currently.Β Just kill me please
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Mar 31, 2020 20:59:16 GMT -5
Matt and I have come to an agreement. Unfortunately, as we've exhausting a long list of possible subs, we won't do anymore unless someone comes to us who is able to sub into the game.
If you need to go out of the game, from now on you'll be 'killed' out of the game until further notice. For those who have already requested subs, you can consider if you want to continue playing or be 'killed' out of the game. We'd stay in the same phase as we are currently. Just kill me please You're 100% sure you want to die?
|
|
Ginger Spice
5x Platinum Member
candy coated heart shapes
Joined: November 2013
Posts: 5,016
|
Post by Ginger Spice on Apr 2, 2020 2:05:16 GMT -5
Is Mylo actually banned? Does that mean this s**tshow is over??
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 2, 2020 5:23:13 GMT -5
Is Mylo actually banned? Does that mean this s**tshow is over?? Haha, nope! You guys get to enjoy another day phase~
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 2, 2020 5:25:28 GMT -5
April fools, suicides and even more death. This crew has gone through it all! One more self-declared death has occurred.
Lordefβ ones died. They were a Vanilla Townie.
Currently, there is 6 vanilla townies and 3 mafia. Townies can still win this, it's not over until it's over!
Day 6 begins!
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 2, 2020 5:30:21 GMT -5
D6 Vote Count #0:Not Voting: @antigonerising , @doinktheclown , gabe , Ginger Spice , Exclusive , Devil Marlena Nylund , Codex , Web , MaymanWith 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
There is 3 days, 10 hours, and 29 minutes on the clockSub Reminders: Ginger replaced Nick, Cynthia replaced Anna, CagedJuggalo replaced BB, Gabe replaced Tanooki. I know this game has been mess station, but now that all the chaos has cleared I'd like to get back to regular lol. Let's make this second half of the game super awesome guys! Try be active, talk, strategise, find those mafias! I've given you a little extra on the clock, use it wisely town~
|
|
Web
3x Platinum Member
Joined: January 2014
Posts: 3,985
|
Post by Web on Apr 2, 2020 7:10:08 GMT -5
so we're at 6 town vs 3 mafia which means this is basically our last shot to lynch a mafia before the game is over since if we mislynch it will be 4 town vs 3 mafia and town will have to be perfect from that point out (which considering our record isn't going to fucking happen lmao). and we still have basically nothing to work with. @antigonerising you wanted to lynch Lord earlier, what does his town flip now give you in terms of info about his wagon? i don't think Jug is mafia, bc mafia seems like they still want to win since they didn't decide to end this shitshow and bc of that they'd probably just ask jug to stay inactive like Mayman or gabe or exclusive have been doing rather than letting him lynch himself. All 3 of those inactives are more likely mafia than Jug to me. Codex (thoughts?) I'll give it my best shot to look through whatever actually remains to look through from this game after work today and place a vote down. Until then it would be really nice if the people who have contributed virtually nothing could come in and say something that isn't "i don't know what i'm doing" "i'm waiting for other people to post" etc.
|
|
|
Post by Devil Marlena Nylund on Apr 2, 2020 8:05:45 GMT -5
Watch there not actually be any fuxking mafia and this game is just Myloβs latest method of making everyone win while gunning for that damn Axis of Evil! π€¬
|
|
|
Post by Mayman on Apr 2, 2020 8:27:15 GMT -5
I'm not sure if Jugg is scum or not. I just don't know about him. Same goes for Gabe. Gabe girl get in here.
Exclusive I could see being mafia. Their strategy earlier on in the game was all over the place. They tried to stay under the radar but certain things were alarming. I'm not sure yet, but I'm keeping an eye out on you.
Ginger I'm not sure about either. He used to be somewhat active but he's disappeared so not sure what's going on there. Of course things may come up irl and I get that just pointing that out.
Codex might be mafia. They said a few sus things in the first half of the game but has gotten better as it's gone on. Not really sure here.
Cynthia I'm pretty sure is town. Nothing really strikes me as her being mafia.
Max I'm still uncertain about. He's very helpful and trying to get the game back, but sometimes maybe too helpful? idk. maybe i'm just overthinking it.
Web I used to think is Mafia but not anymore. I'm glad you're trying to get things back to be more enjoyable and everyone to be more active and I will do my best to help that.
For now,
Vote: Ginger Spice
|
|
gabe
3x Platinum Member
gay
Joined: July 2018
Posts: 3,237
|
Post by gabe on Apr 2, 2020 9:19:23 GMT -5
so i've been re-reading old posts on random pages for fun and i cant help but get a gut feeling that exclusive is mafia so...
vote: exclusive
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 13:36:12 GMT -5
This isn't super helpful because I've only gotten as far as Mayman and the Nick Perkins/Ginger Spice role, but I started working on ISO'ing posts yesterday. Here are most of Mayman's posts (I omitted obvious RVS posts and 'I'll be back later' quotes, but I did note when the latter type of quotes occurred) {Mayman} Albie I went with him to start with because he hadn't said much. I will possibly change it as we all learn more information. To answer Max's question, this is my first time playing. I have always heard how fun these are and wanted to try it out. Koochie , the reason I haven't changed my vote yet is for the exact reason you stated, he hasn't really said anything much to defend himself against any accusations or questions. It seems like he's starting to now, so I will go ahead and ask this - Charmander, how come you didn't say anything when I voted you? It seems like you didn't even attempt to change my mind. Ah yea, missed that sorry. Also wasnβt contributing as much in the beginning cuz Iβm on mobile a lot, but doing the best I can. Also wasnβt sure what to say in the beginning and was trying to wait out the lorde wagon. Iβll try to post my thoughts on everyone later tonight. Thanks, that's all I'm looking for. Which brings me to Albie 's question. I don't feel charmander is as sus anymore after he has explained himself a little more. Which brings me to my next topic: nvm im revoting now Vote: Maymansomething seems off about the way all of the discord newbies are visibly confused and unsure of what to do except him I'm not sure what Discord has to do with this. I haven't played before, I answered that already. I don't think I need to unnecessarily bring that up again unless there's an actual reason to. I honestly forgot that you were playing until you started posting just now. The fact that you only come discuss things when you are brought up is really sus for me. I'm not sure why you keep mentioning "mylo keeps throwing me into these"? What does that really have to do with it? For these reasons, Vote: TanookiI honestly was going to vote for you [Tanooki] before I saw that you voted for me. I just don't know enough about you yet. But for me, you are the most sus as of now. do you still think she's the most suspicious player in the game now that we've lynched Hamed and he flipped town? Who else are you looking at as potential scum targets now? I don't think at this point right now that Tanooki is the most suspicious player anymore. The whole BB/Codex situation is so odd to me, I thank you and a few others for helping state a few points about that whole thing because it's made me think a lot more about that whole thing. I think I am mainly the most suspicious of BB right now because IIRC, he hasn't said anything since the Hamed vote, correct? That's the only thing that's making me more sus of him rather than Codex right now. Vote: BBI would like to hear from BB about what he has to say about this situation. My reasoning for saying I was going to vote for Tanooki even if she didn't vote for me was because as I was catching up, multiple people started questioning her and that's when she started to talk. I just thought it was a little suspicious that she only came out to talk at almost the exact moment she was brought up. Another thing that was suspicious for me was her continuing to bring up "Mylo keeps throwing me into these games" which was stated in replies #132 and #135. I just didn't understand what that had anything to do with the current conversation happening in the game. I was informed and would like to apologize to Tanooki for using the wrong gender pronouns multiple times throughout this post. I went ahead and corrected it on this quote only and did not edit the original post. My thoughts on each player of the game so far, I might have missed a few things along the way but I just tried to skim through the last few pages. BB - I honestly feel really conflicted here. The whole Codex/BB thing is confusing to me, but the way he responded has me confused. I just know there's something off here. I know you've already answered a lot BB about that, but can you maybe explain to me what you think about Codex in general (not just that situation involving you both) Walt - I know you have voted for me, the reason I haven't said much of anything to you is because you haven't asked me much. I would like to talk to you, just want to hear from you as well. Tanooki - I stated everything I want about you in one of my recent posts responded to Web. Nothing has changed since then. Ginger - I don't know much of you yet but you're not giving me of mafia vibes. I like that you're asking questions and trying to know more info to formulate tour own opinion on everyone. Exclusive - I don't have much of an opinion on you yet. You don't scream mafia but aren't a sure town for me yet. Charmander - I like that you're really answering everything really well and are giving everyone a lot to work with. Before I thought you were mafia from not saying much but I don't think that's the case anymore. Codex - I think there's also something a little off here too. Like I said for BB, that whole situation was weird. I just don't get what telling BB that would have benefited you unless you were mafia. The thing that redeeming yourself for me is that you've been very open in answering questions and explaining your thoughts. Albie - You're very helpful, I'll give you that. Almost too helpful in a way? But I don't think that's a valid reason to suspect that you're a definite mafia. I will be keeping my eye out for you though. Rose - You haven't given us really much besides summaries of players. I'm not sure what to think of that because it certainly helps us. I would like to hear from you regarding Lorde and what you think of his style of play. Snarks - I don't think you're mafia tbh. You've said nothing that would make me think you are. Web - I would like to think you're town because you're the most active person here and are the best at getting people to talk. This could very be a strategy, but I don't think you're mafia. Cynthia - Can't walt to see the word walls The House - Same thing I said about Web. You're also pretty good at getting people to talk and it's definitely helpful for all of us. Lorde - I don't know what to think about you. You say hardly anything but for all the discussion around you, you seem to not care much. I feel like a mafia would be a lot more active and trying to really play the part but I'm not sure. Mayman walt's vote against you more sus than Tanooki come on let's see why this guy was targeting you since Mayman's had the spotlight on him a bit in the last few pages this could be pretty illuminating. Walt will bring more information to the table even on the off chance he's a townie (which he isn't) bb hasn't said anything substantial I've asked Walt to talk to but he didn't respond to me. Not sure how else to get him to talk without voting for him and pressuring him. Vote: WaltWeb, to answer you question - I don't think it was very sus of snarks rallying for a walt vote yesterday. Snarks posted some valid points, especially for me. I had asked Walt a question and he never responded. I put a vote on him to pressure him and he still didn't respond. Charmander - My vote was mainly due to trying to pressure Walt into talking. I was so confused as to why he wouldn't answer my question. When Snarks brought that up, it made me think about it which led to me switching my vote to Walt. [omitted: 3 consecutive posts of Mayman saying 'y'all tl;dr'ing in here, Imma come back later'] Looking through what has been said, Web as of now is the most sus to me. Vote: WebWeb is really playing that town game hard, maybe a little too hard. It's beneficial for us what he's doing I guess, but maybe that's why he wants us to think. Can we all just end this game why did I agree to this why is this actually hell Snarks idk you but I'll vote you because you want to leave. Vote: SnarksOkay so I'm glad we can kinda have a fresh start again with this. I'll do my best to consistently keep up with what's going on and be more active Vote: GabeGabe where are you? I don't think you've said anything yet lol I mainly asked for a summary due to there being like 4 or 5 new pages and with iirc not much time to vote. I want to unvote Gabe because although he might be a little inactive, he's done nothing to suggest he might be mafia. Unvote: GabeI would like to hear from Ginger as he hasn't said really anything recently and see what he's thinking for this vote. Vote: GingerI agree, I would like more information from everyone before the day is over. Request: ExtensionI'm not sure if Jugg is scum or not. I just don't know about him. Same goes for Gabe. Gabe girl get in here. Exclusive I could see being mafia. Their strategy earlier on in the game was all over the place. They tried to stay under the radar but certain things were alarming. I'm not sure yet, but I'm keeping an eye out on you. Ginger I'm not sure about either. He used to be somewhat active but he's disappeared so not sure what's going on there. Of course things may come up irl and I get that just pointing that out. Codex might be mafia. They said a few sus things in the first half of the game but has gotten better as it's gone on. Not really sure here. Cynthia I'm pretty sure is town. Nothing really strikes me as her being mafia. Max I'm still uncertain about. He's very helpful and trying to get the game back, but sometimes maybe too helpful? idk. maybe i'm just overthinking it. Web I used to think is Mafia but not anymore. I'm glad you're trying to get things back to be more enjoyable and everyone to be more active and I will do my best to help that. For now, Vote: Ginger Spice I'm about to work on Tanooki/gabe and .exclusive, simply because I know those two will be quick but if anyone else could/would take the time to ISO individual players (self/anna role included) and post them behind a spoiler cut so that they're all in one place that would be really great!
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 13:40:25 GMT -5
apologies to game mods for editing that post but I couldn't live with the fucked up spoiler code
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 13:43:19 GMT -5
Nick Perkins/Ginger Spice ISO. I don't think I omitted any posts for Nick bc by the time he showed up RVS was kind of over. Also not including his 'does that mean this shit show is over' comment a few posts up lol lettuce pray I get this spoiler cut right this time {Nick Perkins/Ginger Spice} wait I didn't realize this had started haha Vote: Lordeftonesalso if Lordeftones was actually mafia, you'd think the dude would go through the effort to post on here once or two. he's actually one of the people i feel most confident is a villager, i'd really prefer if we didn't waste our first lynch on him... thatβs actually a really good point. can we change our votes? ok Iβll be honest Iβm somewhat suspicious of BB just dropping a vote and then disappearing Vote: BB Iβm just gonna throw out that BB went with the flow until someone mentioned their name, after which they immediately went for that person. seems fairly mafia esque to me heyo Iβm also new to mafia Iβll be honest at first I voted for Lord because I had no idea what I was doing and didnβt want to anger anyone. However, I definitely donβt think Lord is mafia, as theyβve barely said anything in their defense, which gives my the vibe that theyβre not really mafia. Despite being new, the way BB played early on and their somewhat lacking defense later still has me suspicious. Love ya bud, but youβre acting super shady heyo Iβm also new to mafia Iβll be honest at first I voted for Lord because I had no idea what I was doing and didnβt want to anger anyone. However, I definitely donβt think Lord is mafia, as theyβve barely said anything in their defense, which gives my the vibe that theyβre not really mafia. Despite being new, the way BB played early on and their somewhat lacking defense later still has me suspicious. Love ya bud, but youβre acting super shady Why? For all of our references, and for those who have played with me before I'm going to become a broken record, but: this line of thinking should probably be avoided. In this game, we should be suspicious of everyone until we get evidence or are convinced they are town. If Lord hasn't said anything in their defense, we have no reason to think they aren't mafia. He could very well be mafia. How others acted toward him doesn't change that and it's each of our jobs to convince everyone else that we are town until we narrow down the options. thanks for the in depth explanation! I still donβt know a ton about the game, so at this point Iβm mostly going off of hunches, though Iβm super open to any and all suggestions anyone has Good analysis and I assume weβre focusing on the two most likely to be lynched. Charmander has still yet to commit to a vote even after his analysis. My vote stays where it is. I still lean town on Hamed because of how brazenly reckless his vote on Lord was. Iβd actually like anna to weigh in on things, as well as Walt and Perkins. I havenβt seen much original thought from the latter two yet. hiiii I havenβt had a ton of original thought yet as I just donβt have much of an idea of what to look for, hence why Iβve been echoing others. I think Hamed/BB is a fair bet for the first vote, though Iβm not totally sold on either. Iβm sticking with BB for now as they just give me the vibe that theyβre mafia. however I also donβt totally trust Char, seems like he could be playing the low key mafia game. thatβs what Iβve got so far Howdy, I've read through the thread once fully and skimmed again a couple times over. I wish I had more to go on with some of y'all. The player I'm replacing also didn't leave a lot to go on, so if anyone has any questions (in general or for me specifically), I'll be more than happy to answer. This might be the hindsight talking because I did read the first lynch result before going through the thread, but I didn't find Hamed remotely suspicious, so his lynch is puzzling to me. Looking at the posts voting for Hamed, a looot of them mention/seem to defend BB, with BB coming in with the final "hammer" (I guess it'd still be considered a hammer since it did the deed, even if it was based on time rather than majority.) Both charmander and anna based their votes on Hamed's suspicion of BB (Web kind of did too, but I thought his vote had more to do with getting Hamed to talk, if that makes since? 'Cause web actually questioned why Hamed wanted to vote for BB but didn't). BB coming in with the final vote for Hamed just kind of seals the sus for me, so for now Vote: BB and FOS charmander and anna. Albie, the house, and Max are the ones who are really digging into people and make sure questions get asked and points of view are challenged. Albie and the house almost kind of seem like good cop/bad cop team of Albie asking the questions, and the house being the contrarian one and really challenging people's thoughts. Not to say that means one or the other is townie or scum, but they've both contributed a huge amount of discussion so far, which is extremely helpful. I'm always suspicious of the house though, 'cause Town Kunt and Scum Kunt are scarily similar in their playing styles. I haven't found a reason to be suspicious of Max yet. Tanooki has offered very little in the way of words, initially just inactive and now kind of throwing in one or two sentences here and there. The suspicion of Mayman voting for her after Tanooki addressed suspicion is legitimate (I side-eyed the "I honestly was going to vote for you before I saw that you voted for me." just 'cause that sounds a little too convenient). But Tanooki is also now kind of tunnel-visioned on Mayman, which I find suspicious as well, but that could be a rookie mistake. I feel like I saw the name Lordeftones so much, but did he even post more than twice? "At least one mafia member likely jumped on the quick bandwagon to vote for me." is not very insightful. - On that note, snarks said in one post that we shouldn't lynch an inactive, yet said two sentences later "This actually makes Lordeftones seem like the most beneficial lynch imo" despite Lordeftones being one of the most inactive players? Everyone else, I don't feel like I have a lot to go along with. I'll keep skimming through, and see if anything new catches my eye. ^Codex also tagging BB right before the lynch while also voting for Hamed is... hmmmm. Voting for Maymansis what made you want to vote for me other than inactivity? It's my first time playing, what makes you think I have some grand strategy beyond what I've clearly stated? I'm very confused by everyone who thinks that I'm suspicious due to when I say things, not what I say or why. I wanna know what exactly makes me suspicious that isn't my clumsy posting lmao Just curious, and I'm sorry if I missed this from the Day One posts, but do you have any suspicions other than Mayman? Ginger Spice maybe it is the benefit of hindsight speaking here but you didnβt find it suspect how Hamed laid down something of a hammer vote on Lord? I only ask that because you mention you didnβt find him βremotely suspiciousβ, which isβ¦strong. Yeah, that must've been hindsight because I didn't even remember that by the time I was writing up my post. The Lord lynchwagon happened so fast within the first few pages, which I guess I didn't really get into in my post, but it was suspect on all counts. walt91, who I failed to mention in my post, voted for Lord right after Codex voted for Lord "for starting a lynchwagon," which, either incidentally or strategically, actually started the lynchwagon on Lord. I feel like a lot of the analysis so far (my own included) gives newer players the crutch of "that could just be inexperience," but I think it's important not to fall on that too much. Something scummy is still scummy even if it's a person's first time playing. We have to be careful how much benefit of the doubt we're giving here. Sorry if I missed this, Codex , did you address tagging BB before he was about to be lynched? I'm just curious what your thought process was. hey y'all! so i'm really sorry, but i think ima have to drop out. pulse survivor has been taking most of my free time, and i didn't have as much free time during the coronavirus as i thought i would (i also think i may be infected, but that's a different matter). i know this is lame to do this late and i should have done this a while back! either way, i'll still be casually following along, and i look forward to seeing the results I know this could legitimately be just you not realizing how much effort this game is and not wanting or being able to put in said effort, but the timing is . If someone were to replace you, they'd be in quite the pickle considering you currently have the most votes against you. Also where is Lordefβ ones? Has he made more than three posts in this thread? BBπ do you have any other thoughts?? Welcome @antigonerising, even if this whole situation regarding anna needing replacement is sus as hell! f**k these day phases go by so much quicker than I'm used to. People like BB, Lord, and Tanooki have offered us absolutely nothing, and while I hate leaning on inactives, there's really no reason to be that inactive this far in. Put that with BB's suspicious hammering at the end of the last day phase, I feel pretty good about my choice to vote for him. I feel like whoever mafia is, is either all new players or all experienced ones. If it's the later, we're probably f**ked, 'cause the newer players aren't offering much. But I feel like if it was a mix of the two, the more experienced players would be telling the new players to f**king step it up. I'm not opposed to a walt lynch, but snarks it's concering me how much you're gunning for him so quickly? What makes you so sure BB is town? Web To answer your direct question, yes I still find Charmander and BB/Coco suspicious for how the D1 lynch played out. I haven't been as focused on Charmander because he's stepped up his game and has been giving decent analysis during the second day phase. BB gave us absolutely nothing to work with, and I don't know what to make of that, but I also don't want to give BB/Coco a pass just because of that. Vote: Snarks for being so adamant about walt to actually tip the scales and cause us to lynch him. Some of y'all are already saying that it seems too obvious a move to make for scum to be so open about, but why should we ignore it when there's not a lot to go on? I would also like to look back on the players that the house voiced suspicions of. I mean if mafia already had one lynch go to a townie, the night phase right about to come up and give them their first kill, why would I go this hard against walt and albs? just because it's a stupid move and I'm hoping people think I wouldn't be stupid enough to do that? For a mafia is clearly playing a good game so far it seems like a huge risk to take and you'd think I'd be more strategic and careful in my posts like in picking apart every statement and keep giving new possibilities for how it could implicate them instead of trusting that being less cautious with my posts and actions will help me instead of hurt me. Obviously I can see how this would make ppl suspect me so I don't mean to use this as a way to clear my name lol but when/if I'm lynched hopefully it will give the remaining town enough info to go on. I'm actually pretty ok with me being the third lynch cause of this, it's not ideal to have 4 dead town before 1 mafia member but at least there's enough town players left and I think the info it would give could be enough for the rest of town a good chance to figure out the mafia quicker. I don't know why you would go so hard against Walt. That's what I'm trying to figure out but your posts today have not helped me see your point of view. I think we can all agree it was a stupid move, but it seemed like such a panic play, but you seemed to be the only one panicked before that lynch. Also, why are you so against the idea purposed that all the mafia players are new? I don't see why that would be such an unlikely suggestion. You said the mafia have played well so far which, while they've successfully not gotten lynched so far, that could easily be dumb luck as we haven't even had a majority lynch as town yet. In case it was unclear, @doinktheclown replaced BB not Coco. @pma2015 is not in this game, nor is Juggalo a Coco dupe to my knowledge haha. Why did I think that was Coco? I think it would be beneficial for us if we go back and analyze Koochie 's posts. No one was voting for him during the last day phase, I wonder if he voiced suspicions of some of the mafia players before. I'm trying to figure out why his death would be beneficial to the mafia other than him generally being one of the most active players asking questions and giving deeper analysis (which is probably enough for all the inactives we have lmfao.) FUUUUCK I was typing out a post that was several paragraphs and I f**king closed the tab. I'm way too sleepy to type everything back out (which will also explain any typos here) and tomorrow I'd really like to go back and look at BB & whoever is playing for them now and Lordeftones as there were major suspicions of both of them and those were just kind of dropped after the first two lynchs even though we never acutally learned anything from them. I went back through the house's posts and the main person he was extremely vocally suspicious about was Anna (now Cynthia) and that's where his vote was most of the D2 phase. The hard part about all the replacements is that they can't offer explanations of things that the person they're replacing did. Like I still want to know what Anna was thinking with her timing at the end of D1/beginning of D2. I'm taking my vote off of snarks because even though his insistence on lynching walt was obviously a really bad move, he's contributed a decent amount to D3, and idk, that's something. I'm gonna feel really stupid if he is mafia, but he's giving us a lot more than most players right now. Vote: CynthiaAnd so I'm asking Cynthia, are you able to m ake any sense of anna's gameplay before you replaced her? What do you make of the house's suspicions of you? I know I can't really be one to talk about contributing to this day phase specifically, but we have less than twenty four hours and half the players haven't even voted yet. @doinktheclown Mayman Lordefβ ones Devil Marlena Nylund gabe Codex get y'alls butts in here! I know it might not seem like there's a lot to go on, but it would be really appreciated if you would at least try to get a vote in. Not voting at all does nothing to help town win. I knew if Albie was town and got lynched we were absolutely f**ked. We're all just shooting in the dark now. Request: ExtensionDealing with s**t as well. Too hard to focus on this.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 14:29:52 GMT -5
Lord has been really active lately based on his overall pulse history, but he needs to do something or he'll get a strike soon. thatβs actually a really good point. can we change our votes? Yes. DEAD I didn't even realise there was a wiki So, there are 2 lynches today? That's interesting If I'm not mistaken were using a nine votes for a lynch and not a majority vote. Even if there are two persons I'm still waiting for the rest. I'm a newbie as well, the only experience I have was reading through one thread, getting a gist of what the is like. I voted for BB just to have a vote in. Exclusive β first time playing β voted BB to have a vote in. He pointed out that Lord has been active across the board but hasnβt been so in this game. How are you feeling about this now? Just rereading my post now, and that was not what I meant to say. At the time the post was made, based on his activity lord hasn't been active on the overall board. Based on that observation I was unsure of when he would be likely post again. Although he did give a response on who the potential mafias could be, I suspect some suspicion could be taken off of him, but I would need more responses from him.
6. .exclusive Actually the person I know the least about and hasn't really said much. No one's been talking about them either, so I can't really give any assessment. Would like your thoughts as well. My thoughts so far... Inexperienced as I am, I tend to make decisions based on the information provided and this is still day 1. While a lot has happened, I am wary of a few players, but my thoughts aren't that focused. With that said I'm cautious of the experienced players like the house, Albie, Max, and web. They are active and are providing some insightful commentary, yes, but even that could be a well-planned disguise to deceive the rest of us. The last part of Day 1 has me side eying Codex and BB but what's more alarming was Web's defense towards Codex.
Vote Web
My Thoughts the house: One of the players I've side-eyed from the game has begun. Mostly because of his experience. But after the end of Day 1, I think he's actually just a regular townie. Web: Has been really active in the game, providing a lot of insight from his perspective. As I mentioned in my previous post, the most helpful members could be scum in disguise. His response to the Codex/BB/Hamed situation gave rubbed me the wrong way. But then I asked myself, why would such an experienced player do this. Were tensions running high in the scum chat with him (BB and Codex)? I mean how are entirely sure that Codex isn't scum? He's also defended codex very strongly Albs: Doing the Lord's work, keeping us updated with his thoughts and even vote counts. I'm still not too sure about you though. I'm keeping my eye in you, sis! Anna/Cynthia: Not entirely sure what I think of her. Weird that she left when she had the most votes but oh well... Let's see what Cynthia does. Max: Undecided about you. You seem to be having 'middle ground' as anna said, but I guess the same could be said for me. Snarks: I think he is a townie. The post he makes isn't too suspicious from my perspective. Lordeftones: Not much to go on honestly. I'm undecided, would love if he posts more. Codex: I'm getting scum vibes ever since the BB/Hamed Incident. He and Web have defended each other. To my knowledge, this isn't his first time playing. the relationship between them both has me puzzled. Both of them telling us that they think each other re townie could very well be a risky attempt to draw attention, using the fact that both are experienced players to deceive us into thinking they would be that obvious for defending each other. His vote for Lord tells me that he's deflecting the attention from himself. BB: Scum vibes, In the same circle jerk with Web and Codex. He has been throwing around votes carelessly now. Nick/Ginger Spice: Hasn't stood out for me too much. They're pretty town leaning at the moment Walt: Eh, I'm not sure what to say about them. Their votes don't really give me much to go off. Although they may be new to forum mafia, they said that they loved the game, so some amount of experience is there, but current gameplay is confusing. It could very well be the dark horse among us. Mayman: Said this is hos first time playing, not much to go on, I'm guessing town for now. Tanooki: Gameplay is a bit confusing, I have a hunch that will be found later in this post Charmander: Has provided a lot of insight. I honestly think he is town.
I'm suspecting two mafia groups at the moment. Group 1: Codex, Web, and Bb Group 2: Walt, Tanooki and another player. Walt and Tanooki, Have hardly interacted with each other in the game. Both are gunning for Mayman at the moment which is alarming. As to who the other player is, not quite sure, but I just wanted to highlight this relationship between the two players. thanks for posting more detailed thoughts exclusive, both of these red pieces stood out to me, especially the second. There's hints of defending mayman in both, especially when players like Lordeftones have "nothing to go on" so he's undecided, but with "not much to go on" for mayman, there's a guess at town? also why is it so "alarming" that mayman just has two votes at the moment, especially when players like anna/cynthia and Codex are currently much bigger town targets? Oh really now. Well the phrase "not much going on" would be relative in this case. Lord hasn't done much so I don't know where to place him, hence the undecided status . From my perspective, mayman has nothing mu h going on that would make me believe that he is scum (but he has posted more than lord), so he is town for now in my eyes. As it relates to mayman having two votes by Walt and tanooki, I mean one could say that instead of going for the more poplular votes at the time like Anna or Codex (and being risk of regocgnized as scum due to a lynch wagon ), Walt voted for Mayman with reason being the tanooki affair.
I will post my thoughts later today. The house being killed isn't surprising, to be honest, his game play and experience with great. Him not voting at the end of day 2 didn't really help us. To answer Web 's question, with Walt flipping town, the Tanooki claims are now kinda null. But I'm still cautious of my group 1 scum suspects soo... vote: Web
{Spoiler} The house being killed isn't surprising, to be honest, his game play and experience with great. Him not voting at the end of day 2 didn't really help us. To answer Web 's question, with Walt flipping town, the Tanooki claims are now kinda null. But I'm still cautious of my group 1 scum suspects soo... vote: Web
Just broadening my previous points. I went through the house's previous posts in day 2 trying to place together a theory on possible reasons why he was killed off. Unsuccessful in putting together any other reasons except he was killed because of his experience. I think the mafia would love to take one of the most (if not the most) experienced player(s), especially in a double day system where there would longer periods of interaction in fear of getting sniffed out. With that said, who are the possible mafia. Walt being revealed as a townie due to his lynch definitely placed holes in my theory about him/tanooki and another player. So that leaves the other group that I specified (Web/Codex/BB). Nothing that has happened since I made my first claim about this group has altered my view. So I kept my vote on Web. Why I'm gonna keep pressing until proven wrong (I feel it in my gut lol). I hoped this clears up anything that was probably not seen or misinterpreted in my previous post. Well damn, should I get a replacement too? I'm just teasing, but all these replacements do have me thinking... :eyes: Looking through what has been said, Web as of now is the most sus to me. Vote: WebI guess I really see only one option here Vote: AlbsOh hell naw. Could can we get some more reasoning behind these votes. I know things are kinda hectic now but throwing down votes with little to no reason after all this time is really suspicious. i'm assuming one of Ginger/Max/cynthia/Codex is maf based on how the nightkills have panned out so far and since no one else is talking and we have pretty much nothing to go on town is most likely completely f**ked lmao so i'm done begging for everyone to come in and vote/voice suspicions and i feel like i could make a case to vote for anyone at this point so i'll start with this: Vote: exclusive
Exclusive how have your suspicions changed based on the insanity of the last day phase? Do you still think I'm your #1 suspect and regardless who else is on your scum radar? Max is another player who I could look back at if I have time later since he's played a pretty sqeaky clean game so far. Nope, but I'll vote for someone else in the group of suspects for a change this time around, even if it may appear scummy.
Vote: Codex
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 14:31:10 GMT -5
^above is .exclusive ISO. Spoiler title not working for some reason
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 14:31:21 GMT -5
{tanooki/gabe ISO} vote lord bc albie is angy at me but i was asleep while everyone was awake lmao Oh oop...y'all two wanna show up right when I'm typing my post lol. tanooki girl what? I'm gonna at least need you to type out a sentence or two like charmander just did. fixed i'm not angy lol. I just think you didn't read the thread. when you read the thread lmk what you think for real but also you're not supposed to edit your posts. and you gotta bold your votes. i didnt read the thread at all lmao just the newgrounds game mylo sent girl i been asleep no for some reason i just blindly join whatever mylo tells me to so here we are glad to see more people are voting and talking to each other Vote: Tanookiwhat do you think about the game so far? So far your posts other than saying hi were a vote on the Lord wagon and then another one saying you didn't read any of the thread yet. Who do you think is shady so far and why? the main line of thinking behind those strategy posts was looking way forward in the game to a D6 or something situation where a lot of the experienced town players have been killed off and town is down to less experienced/inactive town players vs a mafia who can perhaps guide them around easier. I was trying to think of ways to use the extra day phase that we have with the stronger town players as efficiently as possible. If we make determinations that players are more likely to be scum then obviously that overrides going after inactive, less certain players but activity in the game has increased a bit so I'm feeling a little more optimistic about avoiding dealing with inactives this game. Albie the main reason I unvoted Lord was because I didn't want the random lynchwagon from nowhere to somehow become an early lynch if I couldn't check the thread for a few hours. Additionally the fact that it sparked from basically nothing made me think there was a chance of a mafia player somewhere in there trying to get an easy shot on a townie and why I was backing off from wanting to lynch him first, but that isn't really a strong lean yet and I'd like to hear more from him specifically asap some people i want to actual opinions on other players from: tanooki , walt91 , Lordefβ ones I can throw some more leads together in a few hours. I'm just inactive while y'all are active, which appears to be the morning when I'm not awake lmao theres a few people im watching but i wont name names atm, im still tryna figure out what im looking for if that makes sense. i voted lord bc its a first vote and between him and hamed who was also in the lead, lord seemed infinitely more sus to me and it felt like voting for a random ass person would seem even more strange than just following the crowd bc mylo throws me into these games lmao but gimme like an hour imma change my vote nvm im revoting now Vote: Maymansomething seems off about the way all of the discord newbies are visibly confused and unsure of what to do except him Thanks, that's all I'm looking for. Which brings me to Albie 's question. I don't feel charmander is as sus anymore after he has explained himself a little more. Which brings me to my next topic: I'm not sure what Discord has to do with this. I haven't played before, I answered that already. I don't think I need to unnecessarily bring that up again unless there's an actual reason to. I honestly forgot that you were playing until you started posting just now. The fact that you only come discuss things when you are brought up is really sus for me. I'm not sure why you keep mentioning "mylo keeps throwing me into these"? What does that really have to do with it? For these reasons, Vote: Tanooki[/i][/quote] its pretty much a running joke now that mylo invites me to random s**t and i just do it without hesitation lmao, between this and PAR. mylo invited me to play mafia but only sent me a link to a newgrounds thing explaining how mafia works "The fact that you only come discuss things when you are brought up is really sus for me" so should I play the game or not lmao[/quote] also is it just me or does only voting for me when i point you out seem really suspicious Girl maymans reason to vote for me arent sound at all he just did it because i voted for him first who do i even trust anymore Im still very sketchy about mayman, just something seems off π€ Voting for Maymansis what made you want to vote for me other than inactivity? It's my first time playing, what makes you think I have some grand strategy beyond what I've clearly stated? I'm very confused by everyone who thinks that I'm suspicious due to when I say things, not what I say or why. I wanna know what exactly makes me suspicious that isn't my clumsy posting lmao Just curious, and I'm sorry if I missed this from the Day One posts, but do you have any suspicions other than Mayman? I'm still slightly suspicious on Lord but I don't have much to go off there i dont have very much to add to the list tbh, tbh i've tried to find s**t to say but everything i could say has already been said. im still very skeptical of mayman, the hypocrisy of calling me sus due to poor timing and then voting for me right after i say something about him still irks me. i have my eyes on lord since i still have a hunch but not much to say. regarding people like bb/hamed, i have no f**king idea lmao. im suspicious of the veterans like albie and matt just because even tho y'all are being super super helpful in understanding the game, if yall are mafia then that guidance isnt gonna be much help when yall convince us to lynch ourselves lmao. i wanna see more of charmander anna and exclusive. if anyone needs peaches in animal crossing hmu get that postcount up bbygirl the active posters list is all yours i forgot about this, lemme catch up on the happenings and ill get back to yall ~replaced~ hey i'm here and lowkey a litte confused but i'm trying to catch up today girl idfk whats going on can someone give me a summary Lordefβ ones , gabe , juggujug , Codex (i know you said you were working on analysis), all of you need to be voting for someone, there are only 10 hours left. If you're not voting for anyone you're sacrificing the only power that you have in this game and not giving us information to work with. so here's my thoughts so far: -First, I hope that everyone can realize that I've kind of just been thrown into this with nothing while everyone else has been building on their suspicions all game. I'm sure I'll get up to speed eventually, but just give me a little bit lol. I do understand the strategy of this game, as I was a huge town of salem fanatic. It'll just take a little time -Second, with what I've seen so far, I don't really feel comfortable with voting to lynch anyone yet. At my stage in the game, it would pretty much be a random vote, and random votes more often favor mafia than they do town im here i just still have no clue whats going on. i am town though [/spoiler]
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 14:33:02 GMT -5
WHY THE FUCK DO SPOILERS HATE ME I HATE PROBOARDS IS2GA FJEIOPFJEIOPQFJEIOFPJEQIOP
|
|
tanooki
Diamond Member
2019 Breakthrough
lucia gta 6
Joined: August 2017
Posts: 10,080
Pronouns: they/she/fae
|
Post by tanooki on Apr 2, 2020 14:35:52 GMT -5
hi again? lol
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2020 14:58:32 GMT -5
hey gurl
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 2, 2020 16:51:59 GMT -5
D6 Vote Count #1:[1] - @doinktheclown - Codex * [1] - Ginger Spice - Mayman[1] - Exclusive - gabeNot Voting: @antigonerising , @doinktheclown , Ginger Spice , Exclusive , Devil Marlena Nylund , Web * if deadline was now, Caged would be lynched. With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
There is 3 days, 1 hour, and 7 minutes on the clockSub Reminders: Ginger replaced Nick, Cynthia replaced Anna, CagedJuggalo replaced BB, Gabe replaced Tanooki.
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 3, 2020 5:19:00 GMT -5
D6 Vote Count #2:[1] - @doinktheclown - Codex * [1] - Ginger Spice - Mayman [1] - Exclusive - gabe Not Voting: @antigonerising , @doinktheclown , Ginger Spice , Exclusive , Devil Marlena Nylund , Web * if deadline was now, Caged would be lynched. With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
There is 2 days, 12 hours, and 40 minutes on the clockSub Reminders: Ginger replaced Nick, Cynthia replaced Anna, CagedJuggalo replaced BB, Gabe replaced Tanooki. Love your energy guys <3
|
|
Mylo13 π
Diamond Member
@grapefanatic
Wishing everyone an amazing day and life π
Joined: July 2017
Posts: 10,091
|
Post by Mylo13 π on Apr 3, 2020 19:02:07 GMT -5
D6 Vote Count #3:[1] - @doinktheclown - Codex * [1] - Ginger Spice - Mayman [1] - Exclusive - gabe Not Voting: @antigonerising , @doinktheclown , Ginger Spice , Exclusive , Devil Marlena Nylund , Web * if deadline was now, Caged would be lynched. With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
There is 1 day, 22 hours, and 57 minutes on the clockSub Reminders: Ginger replaced Nick, Cynthia replaced Anna, CagedJuggalo replaced BB, Gabe replaced Tanooki. You guys really need to slow down I can't keep up!
|
|
Ginger Spice
5x Platinum Member
candy coated heart shapes
Joined: November 2013
Posts: 5,016
|
Post by Ginger Spice on Apr 3, 2020 19:45:34 GMT -5
Okay I don't feel confident in anything and I also don't have the energy right now to go back and quote people but I still think Anna's game play was scummy as fuck. The past few days have given us nothing so
Vote: Cyntha
I'll try to stop in tonight and contribute more.
|
|
Ginger Spice
5x Platinum Member
candy coated heart shapes
Joined: November 2013
Posts: 5,016
|
Post by Ginger Spice on Apr 3, 2020 19:46:00 GMT -5
Tonight being *later* tonight, obviously.
|
|