Who was more successful? (Brandy or Aaliyah)

[strong4PMB!]

Mineable1004 said:

Wrong. I remember this Entertainment Weekly review.

LOL!

TCorey said:

Brandy killed Aaliyah.

[Gorminako]

on 09/08/2004 at 18:34:32, krazymack wrote:I'm actually quite surprised how much Brandy and Aaliyah are being compared as music industry rivals on this board. I remember Brandy and Monica to be the competitive ones back in the mid to late 90's.





That's because no one even put Aaliyah in their league until she died.

I always considered them rivals of each other. Aaliyah came first, then Brandy, then Monica, though I thought Aaliyah didn't get the credit due her in comparison to the other two. They're all great, but as far as the quality of music they put out, first is Brandy, then Aaliyah, then Monica. However, Monica probably has the best voice, though all are very good singers. Aaliyah's best songs were all released before her death. By the way, Brandy's latest CD is one of the best this year, and doesn't seem to be getting the success it deserves. It's much better than her previous one.

[will]

Definently Aaliyah! She's getting more recognition now, and she's dead. Is Brandy dead... NO! Go Aaliyah!