mluv
Gold Member
Joined: September 2013
Posts: 540 
|
Post by mluv on Jan 13, 2014 16:25:05 GMT -5
The Idina version is outselling the Demi Lovato version right now so if Radio wanted this to be a pop hit then it probably could be one. They had no problem playing Cups which also had a Broadway sound and was a song that originated in the 1920's and 1930's. What it comes down to is probably just some agism bias that Radio has especially when it comes to female singers. Otherwise this could be a thing. Itune rankings for Idina: 19 and 35 Itune rankings for Demi: 47 and 99 With 4 versions of the same song charting on itunes, it's kind of silly if radio ignores it. Well, the clear reason why the Idina version is outselling the Demi version is because it's the version in the actual film. Additionally, buying and listening audiences are quite different. The pop version would probably be more likely to garner airplay tbh. It was made specifically for that purpose. I don't think this has a shot at significant airplay. And the reason is not because she's in her 40s. Or maybe people just like Idina's version better? It's not like they don't have a choice in the matter. Most comments I've read said Idina killed it and Demi didn't as much. I see on Spotify, which is all about listening, the Idina Version has more listening views than Demi. |
|
|
|
Post by Fat Ass Kelly Price on Jan 13, 2014 17:02:08 GMT -5
Well, the clear reason why the Idina version is outselling the Demi version is because it's the version in the actual film. Additionally, buying and listening audiences are quite different. The pop version would probably be more likely to garner airplay tbh. It was made specifically for that purpose. I don't think this has a shot at significant airplay. And the reason is not because she's in her 40s. Or maybe people just like Idina's version better? It's not like they don't have a choice in the matter. Most comments I've read said Idina killed it and Demi didn't as much. I see on Spotify, which is all about listening, the Idina Version has more listening views than Demi. That is a plausible reason, but it's not the most logical reasoning. It is a reason. But not the most logical reason imo. Logically, the version that is showcased in the popular movie and commercials would be more likely to be popular. Regardless of people feel about both versions, it's just logical. It also helps that it is better received. |
|
|
|
Post by Love Plastic Love on Jan 13, 2014 17:52:28 GMT -5
They are sort of in a pickle with this song. The Idina version is clearly not meant for radio play. However, it is so much better than Demi's version. I know that is very subjective, but Demi's version, though created for radio, seems poorly produced to me and it loses the epic/magical quality that makes the original so special. So you have a song not suited for radio that is amazing and a lackluster other version that is made for radio though. I think the ultimate result is that it will do nothing significant on radio, but the song in total will sell decently and become a new Disney classic through the strength of the film.
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 13, 2014 17:54:17 GMT -5
They are sort of in a pickle with this song. The Idina version is clearly not meant for radio play. However, it is so much better than Demi's version. I know that is very subjective, but Demi's version, though created for radio, seems poorly produced to me and it loses the epic/magical quality that makes the original so special. So you have a song not suited for radio that is amazing and a lackluster other version that is made for radio though. I think the ultimate result is that it will do nothing significant on radio, but the song in total will sell decently and become a new Disney classic through the strength of the film. If they're going to send it to radio, I think they should send both versions simultaneously. It's unlikely either version will become a major hit, but they'll both help to promote the soundtrack. Stations willing to take more of a risk can add the Idina version (which is selling better), and those less willing to take a risk can add the Demi version (not selling as much, but it will be less polarizing on their playlists). |
|
Choco
Diamond Member
james dean daydream
Joined: February 2009
Posts: 27,985 
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
|
Post by Choco on Jan 13, 2014 21:42:09 GMT -5
I think both versions are good. Idina's better of course but I wouldn't mind radio playing Demi's if that helps the movie version get more recognition.
|
|
nick64
Diamond Member
Joined: November 2011
Posts: 14,441
|
Post by nick64 on Jan 13, 2014 21:47:55 GMT -5
As much as I love Demi's version, I think releasing Idina's is smarter. Demi has "Neon Lights" out right now, and even with hype around "Let It Go", they would clash with each other. I don't think Idina's is too polarizing for pop at all. If stations are willing to give it a chance, I'm sure listeners will have no problem with it being played. The sales show that it's clearly connecting with people. I know that buyers and listeners aren't always the same people, but their tastes really can't be that different. There's no harm if it flops, so I'd definitely go for it.
Oh and personally I prefer Demi's slightly, but that's mostly due to the flawless bridge and the fact that I heard that one first, so it made some of the differences in Idina's version seem a little weird to me. I absolutely love both though.
|
|
Gray.
9x Platinum Member
formerly known as say selena.
Joined: December 2006
Posts: 9,954
|
Post by Gray. on Jan 15, 2014 16:21:37 GMT -5
They are sort of in a pickle with this song. The Idina version is clearly not meant for radio play. However, it is so much better than Demi's version. I know that is very subjective, but Demi's version, though created for radio, seems poorly produced to me and it loses the epic/magical quality that makes the original so special. So you have a song not suited for radio that is amazing and a lackluster other version that is made for radio though. I think the ultimate result is that it will do nothing significant on radio, but the song in total will sell decently and become a new Disney classic through the strength of the film. All of this. It's an amazing song, and Idina kills it, but this (sadly) probably won't get radio play. It will, however, live on in the Disney canon. |
|
pnobelysk
Diamond Member
Joined: November 2009
Posts: 10,240
|
Post by pnobelysk on Jan 15, 2014 23:12:07 GMT -5
New peak of 25 on the hot 100 this week and was 10 in digital sales this week
|
|
johnm1120
Diamond Member
JAM
Joined: September 2003
Posts: 24,921
|
Post by johnm1120 on Jan 16, 2014 15:39:17 GMT -5
The song has been nominated for an Academy Award.
|
|
secretchef
Platinum Member
Joined: March 2010
Posts: 1,179
|
Post by secretchef on Jan 16, 2014 16:00:50 GMT -5
An Oscars performance should push this nicely up on AC and peak the Hot 100.
|
|
Eqbk
3x Platinum Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 3,327
|
Post by Eqbk on Jan 16, 2014 19:58:18 GMT -5
Does anyone know how well other Disney songs did on CHR/Pop during the Disney Renaissance in the 90's (ie. Beauty and the Beast, A Whole New World)?
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2014 20:06:44 GMT -5
Does anyone know how well other Disney songs did on CHR/Pop during the Disney Renaissance in the 90's (ie. Beauty and the Beast, A Whole New World)?" "Beauty and the Beast" (#6; April '92) "A Whole New World" (#1; February '93) "Can You Feel The Love Tonight" (#3; July '94) "Circle of Life" (#16; October '94) "Colors of the Wind" (#16; August '95) "True To Your Heart" (#38; July '98) "You'll Be In My Heart" (#36; August '99) I think that's it for their animated films. If you throw in live action too, Jimmy Cliff's "I Can See Clearly Now" from Cool Runnings peaked at #8 in December '93. Any I'm forgetting? |
|
Au$tin
Diamond Member
Pop Culture Guru
Grrrrrrrrrr. Fuckity fuck why don't you watch my film before you judge it? FURY.
Joined: August 2008
Posts: 54,624
My Charts
Pronouns: He/his/him
|
Post by Au$tin on Jan 16, 2014 20:13:42 GMT -5
Does anyone know how well other Disney songs did on CHR/Pop during the Disney Renaissance in the 90's (ie. Beauty and the Beast, A Whole New World)? Beauty and a Beast (Pop Version - Celine Dion & Peabo Bryson) #6 A Whole New World (Pop Version - Peabo Bryson & Regina Belle) #1 Can You Feel the Love Tonight (Pop Version - Elton John) #3 Circle of Life (Pop Version - Elton John) #16 Colors of the Wind (Pop Version - Vanessa Williams) #16 You'll Be in My Heart (Non-movie version a.k.a. Phil Collins solo) #36 None of the songs from the actual films charted, but rather reworked versions (though, the differences in "You'll Be in My Heart" are much less prominent for obvious reasons). I'm kind of surprised to find that Christina Aguilera's "Reflection" and Michael Bolton's "Go the Distance" didn't chart. Edit: Oh, okay, Jazzy. |
|
HolidayGuy
Diamond Member
Joined: December 2003
Posts: 33,923
|
Post by HolidayGuy on Jan 16, 2014 20:15:09 GMT -5
The couple that didn't do as well at pop radio were All-4-One's "Someday," which peaked at No. 41 on R&R, and Michael Bolton's "Go the Distance," which didn't crack top 50.
"Let it Go" looks to be the first version of a song, sung by the character, that's charted on the Hot 100, unless there was something pre-90s.
|
|
icefire9
2x Platinum Member
Joined: November 2011
Posts: 2,071
|
Post by icefire9 on Jan 16, 2014 21:10:43 GMT -5
Yeah, I think Hakunah Matatah made it into the Bubbling Under chart, though.
|
|
johnm1120
Diamond Member
JAM
Joined: September 2003
Posts: 24,921
|
Post by johnm1120 on Jan 16, 2014 22:58:01 GMT -5
Does anyone know how well other Disney songs did on CHR/Pop during the Disney Renaissance in the 90's (ie. Beauty and the Beast, A Whole New World)? Beauty and a Beast (Pop Version - Celine Dion & Peabo Bryson) #6 A Whole New World (Pop Version - Peabo Bryson & Regina Belle) #1 Can You Feel the Love Tonight (Pop Version - Elton John) #3 Circle of Life (Pop Version - Elton John) #16 Colors of the Wind (Pop Version - Vanessa Williams) #16 You'll Be in My Heart (Non-movie version a.k.a. Phil Collins solo) #36 98 Degrees' "True to Your Heart" also made the pop chart peaking at #38. Other peaks for the top 40 misses: "Someday" reached #30 on the Hot 100 and #14 on AC. "Go the Distance" peaked at #24 on the Hot 100 and reached #1 on AC. It's Michael's last solo Hot 100 entry. "Reflection" only charted on AC, reaching #18. |
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 17, 2014 0:54:53 GMT -5
The label is testing Idina's version on RateTheMusic.
|
|
secretchef
Platinum Member
Joined: March 2010
Posts: 1,179
|
Post by secretchef on Jan 17, 2014 13:32:26 GMT -5
The couple that didn't do as well at pop radio were All-4-One's "Someday," which peaked at No. 41 on R&R, and Michael Bolton's "Go the Distance," which didn't crack top 50. "Let it Go" looks to be the first version of a song, sung by the character, that's charted on the Hot 100, unless there was something pre-90s. Very interesting, thank you! Awesome. I love this movie and song. |
|
Grün
Platinum Member
Come As You Are
Joined: August 2010
Posts: 1,257
|
Post by Grün on Jan 17, 2014 20:32:15 GMT -5
I thought the movie was excellent. I took my cousin to go and see it. The original version has the spark that could possibly make it big. Sure Demi's could maybe get it to the lower ends of the top 40, but Idina could make this huge and maybe into something incredible.
Honestly, I think Demi's version is lifeless.
The choice is theirs go for a short guaranteed charting or a risky possible smash.
|
|
Eqbk
3x Platinum Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 3,327
|
Post by Eqbk on Jan 17, 2014 21:40:32 GMT -5
Thank you to all the posters you gave radio info on other Disney songs. I guess making it onto the Top 40 mainstream would be an accomplishment in itself, especially when you look at how most other Disney songs fared during one of Disney's peak eras. I would love it if it were to somehow make the top 20.
|
|
Lozzy
Diamond Member
Joined: January 2010
Posts: 49,237
|
Post by Lozzy on Jan 18, 2014 1:08:33 GMT -5
Idina's version climbs #38 to #20 in Australia this week, while Demi's climbs #36 to #25.
As of last week it's Demi's highest charter here too (and Idina's).
|
|
#Joseph.T
Platinum Member
music fan
Joined: September 2012
Posts: 1,305
|
Post by #Joseph.T on Jan 22, 2014 22:44:48 GMT -5
I like this,included 25 different languages  |
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 22, 2014 22:56:29 GMT -5
Saw Frozen last night(wasn't my choice since I'm still bitter about it's soundtrack blocking Bey @ #1 twice)...
Anyways it was a great movie, and this song sounded so good on the loud speakers and big screen. Love love love Idina's version so much. It would be awesome if this could be a pop hit ala Cups, but I won't hold my breath.
|
|
Lahey's Lucky Star
Diamond Member
Banned
You must be my lucky star
Joined: January 2014
Posts: 15,666
|
Post by Lahey's Lucky Star on Jan 23, 2014 11:47:29 GMT -5
An Oscars performance should push this nicely up on AC and peak the Hot 100. It's top 40 on AC right now. |
|
Eqbk
3x Platinum Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 3,327
|
Post by Eqbk on Jan 24, 2014 22:15:27 GMT -5
Idina Menzel's version occupies the top 2 spots on South Korea's international singles chart.
|
|
pnobelysk
Diamond Member
Joined: November 2009
Posts: 10,240
|
Post by pnobelysk on Jan 29, 2014 21:31:27 GMT -5
new peak of 21 on the hot 100 this week
|
|
|
|
Post by ListenToItTwice on Jan 30, 2014 1:26:36 GMT -5
An Oscars performance should push this nicely up on AC and peak the Hot 100. It's top 40 on AC right now. A week later, and it's #25 on AC, and getting a handful (wish I could be more specific) of plays on Pop. |
|
icefire9
2x Platinum Member
Joined: November 2011
Posts: 2,071
|
Post by icefire9 on Feb 5, 2014 19:30:09 GMT -5
11 Idina Menzel - Let It Go 0.3560
32 Idina Menzel - Let It Go 0.1631
This is really increasing on iTunes! Any reason why?
|
|
nick64
Diamond Member
Joined: November 2011
Posts: 14,441
|
Post by nick64 on Feb 5, 2014 20:07:01 GMT -5
11 Idina Menzel - Let It Go 0.3560 32 Idina Menzel - Let It Go 0.1631 This is really increasing on iTunes! Any reason why? It's listed under New Singles on iTunes |
|
|
|
Post by josh on Feb 5, 2014 20:19:25 GMT -5
Also on sale for $0.69.
|
|
