Rihanna vs Ariana's collaborations Hot 100 no.1s

[leoapp]

Both Rihana and Ariana each had 4 Hot 100 no.1s where they were just featured artists/only collaboration side projects/quick remix attempts.
Which group of no.1s do you prefer?

[🇯🇲 lucy88 🇯🇲]

Rihanna 

Live Your Life is the best one mentioned here and I like it way more than any Ariana collab song except Rain On Me, Bang Bang, and Side To Side.

Love The Way You Lie is decent. Don't remember how Monster goes.

Never liked S&M, remix or not.

[leoapp]

Love Ariana but her collab No.1s are weak as hell...
Bang Bang remains her strongest collab. I even prefer Don't Call Me Angel compared to these 4...
Love Me Harder are million better compared to her 2 quicky Weeknd no.1 remixes.

Rihanna wins although i hate The Monster and S&M is always just OK. Britney elevated the song for sure.
The other 2 are so strong.

[kimberly]

This goes to Ariana easily, with "Stuck with U" being the only dud (even then, I enjoyed it in 2020).
Save Your Tears and Die With You are both songs I only listen to the Ariana remixes for — she elevated them both very nicely (though SYT is the better song).
Rain on Me is a GAY hit and while not at the top of either artist's discography, it still gets played on occasion.

As for Rihanna:

S&M remix has nothing on the original, Britney dulls the song down.
The Monster is an incredibly mid tune that I think we as a society (rightfully) left in 2014.
Love The Way You Lie is fine I guess, but much like everything else Eminem has ever done, I do not care for it or ever revisit it.

Live Your Life is the only one worth putting on a playlist in this day and age.

[jdanton2]

Ariana for this easily . Rihanna has much better #1's than what is listed here while Ariana's songs listed here are all good.

[.indulgecountry]

"Rain on Me" is the best song from the options given by a LONG shot, but Rihanna takes the edge for me overall.

[irice22]

Anyone voting for Ariana is hard for me to imagine.

[SabrinaFan]

It was hard to choose, as I like two of each of the collabs (Live Your Life & The Monster, and Stuck With U & Rain on Me). I don't like "Love the Way You Lie" or the "S&M" remix, whereas "Save Your Tears" and "Die for You" are tolerable but meh, so I'll give my vote to Ariana.

[rnb]

close but rihanna

[beyoncelover]

Voted for Rihanna.

I do really love all of these Rihanna collabos. With the Ariana collabos, I really like some of them or love the others. Although my favorite Ariana collabo (Save Your Tears), I don't love as much as my favorite Rihanna collabo (Love the Way You Lie).

[Ernesto]

My favourite song of the bunch is "Rain on Me," but I'm givint it to Rihanna's collaborations which are quite massive and stronger.

[#brayden]

Eminem is hard on my ears and the other two Rihanna songs here aren't great. I like the original "S&M" but the Britney remix has always been a hard pass for me.

Ariana wins this easily.

[Positive Tension]

Ariana. I love "Rain On Me" and like most of the others.

I think Rihanna's collabs are among her weakest songs- I especially dislike "S&M." I'm also not a fan of Eminem, so their songs don't really do much for me.

[Fire]

Rihanna, stuck with u alone drags ari’s category down tbh

[Au$tin]

LOVE
1. Rain on Me
2. S&M (I only use the original solo version, tho)

Like
3. Love the Way You Lie
4. Stuck with U

Meh
5. Save Your Tears

Dislike
6. Die for You

Go Away
7. Live Your Life
8. The Monster

Ariana wins this for me, but honestly neither of them are an especially spectacular set of songs. Both of them have far better material.

[JukeboxJacob]

Ariana
-ok fine Rain On Me is SOLID. Otherwise -

-Stuck With Poo (I sincerely apologize)
-Save Your Half-baked vocals
-I can't think of a clever insult for the DFY remix it's just not that good

Rihanna
-ok fine the S&M remix is trash

-the rapping on Live Your Life is whatever to me, but we're focusing on HER contribution and well it's a banger chorus and a beautiful bridge so ✅
-basically same thing for Love TWY Lie but I like Eminem's rapping a bit more even as outdated as it is now
-The Monster was cool then & it's still cool now, stop pretending it's not

Rihanna wins

[avamaxstan]

LTWYL
ROM
SYT
S&M
The Monster
LYL
DFY
SWU

The slander in here against SYT, which is one of the best duets in recent memory… and the praise for the corny forgotten LYL