aerodynamite
4x Platinum Member
Joined: October 2016
Posts: 4,040
|
Post by aerodynamite on Apr 29, 2021 19:29:43 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Leo ✔
Diamond Member
Julia Michaels Stan
Happy happy happy ♪
Joined: June 2016
Posts: 75,261
My Charts
Pronouns: He/him/his
|
Post by Leo ✔ on Apr 29, 2021 20:32:01 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) I like "Typhoons" a lot but "Hunter" is a great discovery.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) "positions" is horrible.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) "Questions" is solid. This match up is unfair.
|
|
wheatsquares33
6x Platinum Member
Joined: April 2015
Posts: 6,988
Pronouns: they/them
|
Post by wheatsquares33 on Apr 29, 2021 21:37:16 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) (decent to strong 6) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) (light to decent 7) Backhand was cool, Edge of the Dark was cooler
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) (decent to strong 5) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) (decent to strong 5) These are songs
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) (strong 6 to light 7) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) (strong 6 to light 7) I don't know if it's me or Royal Blood, but I'm just not liking RB as much as I was back in college. I mean, Typhoons is probably my favorite single from this new project, but it's just been bubbling under on my personal chart for months at this point. Hunter was cool, I like the tone of the guitars especially. These are both decent, could go either way. I think Hunter may be the underdog though so I'll give it to that.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) (decent to strong 7) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) (strong 5 to light 6) Bad Dream is cool. It's a less good version of Fire for You, but still good. I swear 2021 has felt like its flown by, and yet it feels so weird to me that Positions is eligible for this rankdown. I have no feelings towards this song.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) (decent to strong 5) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) (light to decent 6) These are songs, pt. 2. Sorry guys it's late
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) (strong 6 to light 7) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) (light to decent 8) Champagne Problems is a 2020 Taylor Swift song. Thought we had it in a Madness before? But idek if Willow was out for WTM so I'm probably just misremembering. Love Creatures though, that was on my shortlist of songs to submit but I figured someone else would so I left it off my final list.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) (decent to strong 6) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) (decent to strong 7) Idk, I always expect myself to like Middle Kids more than I actually do. They're a competent power pop group, but I've just never really cared for their stuff for some reason. This song is ok. Fight for You is like, really good though? I'm usually just ok with HER but this is great.
Best discoveries: Fight for You, Edge of the Dark
|
|
.indulgecountry
Diamond Member
Best Country Poster 2011, 2017, & 2018
"You left a mark on my face // And brought a dozen red flags in a vase"
|
Post by .indulgecountry on Apr 29, 2021 21:43:15 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
That moment when one of my country songs is facing off against another country song, thus giving it a possible chance, lol
|
|
|
Post by BlurryKyle on Apr 29, 2021 21:45:52 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) (3.5) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) (3.5)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) (3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) (2.5)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) (4) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) (3.5)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) (3.5) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) (3)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) (2.5) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) (3)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) (3.5) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) (4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) (3.5) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) (3.5)
My rating scale:
5 - Masterpiece 4.5 - Excellent 4 - Great 3.5 - Good 3 - Decent 2.5 - Average 2 - Mediocre 1.5 - Bad 1 - Terrible 0.5 - Abysmal
|
|
|
Post by DadJokes on Apr 29, 2021 21:48:57 GMT -5
typhoons: any recommendations as to where to start with these guys album-wise? "Typhoons" is from their upcoming third album, Typhoons (out tomorrow). Both of their first two albums are very good, but I think the second album ( How Did We Get So Dark?) has a sound more similar to the singles we've heard so far from the new album.
|
|
SHOOTER
Diamond Member
3x Poster Of The Year!!!
Phony ponies on full display. #FreePalestine
Joined: April 2006
Posts: 76,246
|
Post by SHOOTER on Apr 29, 2021 21:52:08 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
wrip
7x Platinum Member
Joined: August 2019
Posts: 7,667
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him/his
|
Post by wrip on Apr 29, 2021 21:56:42 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) - “Backhand” is really cool, the rapping works really well especially with the production here. I can’t quite figure out what “Edge Of The Dark” reminds me of, but definitely sounds like a specific artist. It’s a nice song, I just think I’m more interested in “Backhand”.
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) - I think Jamie and Sara complement each other really well in “Atlantis”, definitely has a fun sound to it. “Where I Find God” is also pretty nice, I especially love the pickup in the chorus.
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) - “Typhoons” feels like it’s so close to clicking with me, there’s just something holding me back from fully liking it (it’s a cool song tbf). There is a really cool vibe in “Hunter”, definitely a really cool discovery! I see myself returning to it.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) - “Bad Dream” is genuinely so good, both this and “Fire For You” have me wanting to check out more from Cannons. I actually really enjoy “Positions” and I see myself ranking it pretty high in the 2021 rankdown, though it just doesn’t quite compete with “Dream” for me. Still a great song imo.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) - “Cocktail” feels a bit like “standard” if the makes sense. It’s a fine song, not exactly something that I haven’t heard before. “Jealous” has been one of my go to jams of 2021. Really just love everything about this collaboration, Mahalia and Rico sound really good together on it.
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) - “champagne problems” is really pretty. “Creatures” slaps though, solid discovery.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) - “Questions” is a really nice discovery, though it’s *really* hard for me to vote against H.E.R, especially with a song as amazing as “Fight For You”.
|
|
MoD
3x Platinum Member
t!wiki bopis
the sun will blind my eyes, I love you anyways
Joined: October 2017
Posts: 3,589
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him
|
Post by MoD on Apr 29, 2021 22:27:02 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Juan Carlos
Administrator
One of Pulse's great and savage hidden gems
🔐🌕💛
Joined: February 2011
Posts: 38,680
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Juan Carlos on Apr 29, 2021 22:29:59 GMT -5
Preliminary Round #1: #3 Seeds vs. #4 Seeds – Set 4
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - "Backhand" (Lordeftones, #3) [7.3] vs. Emmit Fenn - "Edge Of The Dark" (Au$tin, #4) [8.9]
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - "Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0" (indulge, #3) [7.8] vs. Larry Fleet - "Where I Find God" (Tay, #4) [7.6]
Royal Blood - "Typhoons" (Macattack, #3) [9.0] vs. Becca Mancari - "Hunter" (peacebone, #4) [8.5]
Cannons - "Bad Dream" (pheebs, #3) [8.8] vs. Ariana Grande - "Positions" (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) [8.2]
Roman Alexander - "Cocktail Conversations" (Bigfan101, #3) [8.2] vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - "Jealous" (Shooter, #4) [7.9]
Taylor Swift - "champagne problems" (Fire, #3) [7.8] vs. Viagra Boys - "Creatures" (MoD, #4) [7.9]
Middle Kids - "Questions" (American Idiot, #3) [7.9] vs. H.E.R. - "Fight For You" (Leo, #4) [8.4]
|
|
Juan Carlos
Administrator
One of Pulse's great and savage hidden gems
🔐🌕💛
Joined: February 2011
Posts: 38,680
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him
Staff
|
Post by Juan Carlos on Apr 29, 2021 22:44:52 GMT -5
Didn't expect Liberty Bell to sound like this though. The guitars are really good! Great discovery in a long time. Wait...this is Nicholas Jaar's project? That explains! Yes. DARKSIDE is a collaborative project between Nicolas Jaar and Dave Harrington. Their sophomore album Spiral is out July 23.
|
|
wavey.
Moderator
Look...
Positive Vibes🙏🏾❤
Joined: August 2006
Posts: 43,631
Pronouns: He/Him
Staff
|
Post by wavey. on Apr 29, 2021 23:23:23 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
fearlessarrow
Moderator
Now a 7x PMA winner!
Joined: June 2015
Posts: 26,061
My Charts
Pronouns: he/him/his
Staff
|
Post by fearlessarrow on Apr 30, 2021 0:22:43 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) The rapping flows nicely with the beat in "Backhand". "Edge of the Dark" has a cool production and after the song takes off around the 3 minute mark it was great, but ultimately I found "Backhand" to be the more engaging of the two. I wish "Edge of the Dark" took off a little earlier, I think I would've voted for it had that been the case.
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) "Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0" is a pleasant country tune with two great vocalists. I'm actually not really familiar with Jamie O'Neal's material so I should change that soon (Sara Evans I am way more familiar than Jamie because I am a Pulse tractor after all). "Where I Find God" is good too and I liked the instrumentation.
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) "Typhoons" is a solid rock jam, love the guitars in the song. Ugh "Hunter" is a great discovery too... I want to vote for both ideally.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) I mean I sent "Fire For You" and "Bad Dream" is also great, but "positions" is a BOP. Sorry for being a pop hoe, lol.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) "Cocktail Conversations" is nice! A nice country instrumentation and it kind of has a nostalgic vibe to it, if that makes any sense. "Jealous" is a bop and this is actually pretty close for me but when I thought about which one I'd rather listen to, it's probably "Jealous".
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) My favorite song on evermore, so sorry MoD you pretty much had no shot at getting my vote here. The synthpop vibes in "Creatures" was nice though.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) "Questions" was a nice discovery. I liked the horn section in the middle and there was good instrumentation throughout. Ugh "Fight For You" is great too. Again I want to vote for both here.
|
|
d3vin44
Platinum Member
Joined: February 2016
Posts: 1,657
|
Post by d3vin44 on Apr 30, 2021 0:24:43 GMT -5
Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3)
Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3)
Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3)
H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Sambalada
8x Platinum Member
Founder of Rankdown ca. 2016
Mmmmmmmm....
Joined: June 2016
Posts: 8,721
|
Post by Sambalada on Apr 30, 2021 1:25:46 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
𝕡𝕙𝕖𝕖𝕓𝕤
9x Platinum Member
Justice for Georgia Leah Moses: https://www.georgialeahmoses.com
Joined: January 2019
Posts: 9,267
My Charts
Pronouns: she/they
|
Post by 𝕡𝕙𝕖𝕖𝕓𝕤 on Apr 30, 2021 3:18:03 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) (this was v hard, just sayin)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) (I loooove champagne problems, but viagra boys deserves a shit, this is good)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) (this was the toughest mach-up of them all)
|
|
dremolus - solarpunk
Diamond Member
𝙁𝙧𝙤𝙢 𝙋𝙖𝙡𝙚𝙨𝙩𝙞𝙣𝙚 𝙩𝙤 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙋𝙝𝙞𝙡𝙞𝙥𝙥𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙨, 𝙎𝙩𝙤𝙥 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙐.𝙎. 𝙒𝙖𝙧 𝙈𝙖𝙘
Joined: August 2019
Posts: 13,312
My Reviews
Pronouns: (he/him/they)
|
Post by dremolus - solarpunk on Apr 30, 2021 6:51:17 GMT -5
ob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) Neither excited me but I feel like I've Backhand a dozen times in different forms and fast rap over basic trap instrumentals don't do it for me anymore. I didn't really like vocals nor the vocal production on Edge of the Dark but I can respect the darker atmosphere.
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) These sure were country songs.
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) Hey, when Royal Blood stops being diet Muse, they can make some good and interesting rock.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) This is the first Cannons songs that I really like and made me finally see why they've been getting a following lately. Cool synthpop with a dreamy atmosphere and vibe to it but the lyrics are also a bit more creative and imaginative than Fire for You. Pollutions is bad for environment.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) It's a B-tier effort from Mahalia, she's had better, catchier singles but I'll take this over that Kane Brown impersonator.
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) I know I should be voting for the "underdog" but Viagra Boys just rub me the wrong way. They're IDLES but without the humor or real depth in their social commentary and lacking the balance to make it all fun (plus a lack of any good vocal production on their album). To be fair, Creatures is one of their better songs but sorry guys, I'll go with the white woman singing about her boy problems any day.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) This is actually an interesting match-up but while I really do love the sentiment and more subdued sound of Fight for You, the horn breakdown for Questions stood out in a really good way and really elevated the song for me.
|
|
walt91
5x Platinum Member
Joined: March 2018
Posts: 5,965
Pronouns: he/they
|
Post by walt91 on Apr 30, 2021 7:19:50 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
austin
9x Platinum Member
Pulse Survivor Sri Lanka Sole Survivor
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 9,357
|
Post by austin on Apr 30, 2021 7:40:25 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
|
Post by tim on Apr 30, 2021 8:21:46 GMT -5
Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3)
H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
keatonzab
Platinum Member
Loves Music, Has Autism and Taylor Swift fanatic
Joined: September 2020
Posts: 1,047
|
Post by keatonzab on Apr 30, 2021 9:49:24 GMT -5
Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3)
Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3)
H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Deleted
Joined: January 1970
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 30, 2021 10:00:04 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) {5} vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) {6} - going further and further into edge of the dark i was like "is this song even going on anymore", then it picked up a bit at the end. still ok
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) {5} vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) {5} - not easy
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) {7.5} vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) {5} - i guess i wasn't listening to the same song as you guys
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) {7.5} vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) {6} - [REDACTED]
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) {4} vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) {5.5} - maybe i ranked jealous too low in new releases
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) {7} vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) {7} - i'm an npc when it comes to taytay releases but why does everyone love champagne problems so much
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) {7.5} vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) {6} - i wish i had h.e.r.'s talent and connections 🥲
|
|
Ky
4x Platinum Member
Joined: December 2004
Posts: 4,482
|
Post by Ky on Apr 30, 2021 10:06:00 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Zach
7x Platinum Member
And at once I knew I was not magnificent...
Joined: September 2015
Posts: 7,544
|
Post by Zach on Apr 30, 2021 10:56:34 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
kimberly
Diamond Member
act i RENAISSANCE
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 11,930
My Charts
Pronouns: they/them
|
Post by kimberly on Apr 30, 2021 10:58:38 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Darkest Hour
Diamond Member
album listener
Joined: January 2017
Posts: 15,807
|
Post by Darkest Hour on Apr 30, 2021 11:04:53 GMT -5
You will see the comments later. They are here.
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) Backhand is decent, but this stylr is overdone. Edge of The Dark picked up in second half.
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) Had low expectation regarding Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0 as I remembered both artists have production issues in the part, but this rework is surprisingly solid. I like the idea. Also 2.0 may become more than the version number lol. Where I Find God is decent. Content not relatable and sounds a bit like a vocal imitator.
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) Typhoons is Royal Blood's stronger track in a while. Good infectious dance rock. Hunter is grungy at points but it doesn't have the great groove that Typhoons has.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) Bad Dream is as good as the previous Cannons song. Maybe finally good synthpop-that-is-played-on-alt group? Positions is lazy Ariana Grande.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) The lyrics of Cocktail Conversations are...something. Haven't listened to his solo song before but he sounds like Chris Young and Kane Brown hybrid lol. Either way between some picks by bigfan, he might be the curator of Spotify's (lame) Hot Country playlist. Didn't really like the tune of Jealous either. The bass is decent I guess.
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) Champagne Problems is overrated, but I am not sure whether I need the idea of synthpop IDLES. Creatures isn't bad but the vocals are hard to get into after so few listens. Taylor Swift's song is more palatable.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) Questions feel like rock drum & baas if it makes sense. I like H.E.R. but she is not strong enough to win an Oscar for this or win this matchup.
|
|
nickd
4x Platinum Member
Joined: November 2017
Posts: 4,416
|
Post by nickd on Apr 30, 2021 11:33:02 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|
Adrian C. 🍓
3x Platinum Member
2019 Best New Poster
Joined: January 2019
Posts: 3,736
My Charts
Pronouns: He/Him/His
|
Post by Adrian C. 🍓 on Apr 30, 2021 12:02:46 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4) - "Edge Of The Dark" has a nice vibe that I was able to get into. The production is kind of cool. I'm personally not a fan of "Backhand" though. Not my cup of tea.
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4) - This one is kind of tough because I like both songs. But as nice as "Where I Find God" is, I feel like I have to give it to "Trying To Find Atlantis". The vocals are the main standout, but the instrumental is nice too.
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4) - I can't say I cared all that much about "Hunter". It's okay. Apparently Typhoons was just released today. I'll probably give that album a spin once my schedule frees up. The title track is my least favorite of the pre-released singles, and that says a lot because I still like it quite a bit. Catchy chorus and great instrumental.
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4) - "Bad Dream" is probably my favorite discovery of this set so far. I love the groove and the song is very catchy. I've never been a fan of "Positions" and I think Ariana Grande is beyond overrated. Fortunately it doesn't look like this mediocre song will be getting a free pass.
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4) - Both of these songs were alright. I don't have very strong opinions on them, but I think I slightly preferred "Jealous".
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4) - "champagne problems" is pretty and pleasant like most of Taylor Swift's output within the last year. "Creatures" is kind of cool though, so I'll go for the underdog here.
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4) - Gah why does this have to be so hard??? Both are such good discoveries! :(
Favorite Discovery: Cannons - "Bad Dream"
Top 5: 1. Royal Blood - "Typhoons" 2. Cannons - "Bad Dream" 3. H.E.R. - "Fight For You" 4. Middle Kids - "Questions" 5. Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - "Trying To Find Atlantis 2.0"
|
|
𝕡𝕙𝕖𝕖𝕓𝕤
9x Platinum Member
Justice for Georgia Leah Moses: https://www.georgialeahmoses.com
Joined: January 2019
Posts: 9,267
My Charts
Pronouns: she/they
|
Post by 𝕡𝕙𝕖𝕖𝕓𝕤 on Apr 30, 2021 12:21:01 GMT -5
Sorry pheebs, Bad Dream is really good but I've been infatuated with Positions ever since it came out and if you need proof excuse me are you hamed????? have you returned from the dead?!? 😭
|
|
zaclord 🌈
Diamond Member
Jesus Jamz POTY
It'll all be alright...
Joined: July 2009
Posts: 10,888
|
Post by zaclord 🌈 on Apr 30, 2021 13:02:57 GMT -5
Rob: Earth-One f/ Malcolm Chester - “Backhand” (Lordeftones, #3) vs. Emmit Fenn - “Edge Of The Dark” (Au$tin, #4)
Jamie O'Neal & Sara Evans - “Trying to Find Atlantis 2.0” (indulge, #3) vs. Larry Fleet - “Where I Find God” (Tay, #4)
Royal Blood - “Typhoons” (Macattack, #3) vs. Becca Mancari - “Hunter” (peacebone, #4)
Cannons - “Bad Dream” (pheebs, #3) vs. Ariana Grande - “Positions” (GrinningLikeADevil, #4)
Roman Alexander - “Cocktail Conversations” (Bigfan101, #3) vs. Mahalia f/ Rico Nasty - “Jealous” (Shooter, #4)
Taylor Swift - “champagne problems” (Fire, #3) vs. Viagra Boys - “Creatures” (MoD, #4)
Middle Kids - “Questions” (American Idiot, #3) vs. H.E.R. - “Fight For You” (Leo, #4)
|
|