Carrie Underwood Album Tracks Rankdown (Finished)

[bboat11]

3. "Like I'll Never Love You Again"

Album: Storyteller



Total: 215
Average: 10.75
Std Dev: 7.90


Typo - 1
.indulgecountry - 1
SHOOTER - 2
taylor is terrified - 2
someguy - 4
tim - 4
lipe - 5
schnetzka - 5
ccarter1023 - 6
Troublemaker - 7
carriefan15 - 10
toomuchboy - 13
zaclord 🌈 - 16
castleoblivion26 - 16
bigd79 - 18
musicfan134 - 19
dgarcia3377 - 20
bboat11 - 21
fireflies - 22
ClevelandRox - 23

SPOILER: Click to show

{Songs Remaining}
That’s Where It Is
The Bullet

[bboat11]

"Like I'll Never Love You Again" was another strong competitor here, hanging onto the top 5 for nearly the entire submission process, although it was never on pace to be higher than "The More Boys I Meet" until it got both of its #1s from our final two submissions

Other than forgetting it exists in between listens, I do enjoy it when I am listening to it! It is a very relaxing listen.

[bboat11]

So here we go!!! It all comes down to her first album versus her last album

That's Where It Is vs. The Bullet!!!

Place your bets

[.indulgecountry]

There should be no universe where this ranked lower than fucking "The More Boys I Meet" so thank God for me and Typo.

[taylor is terrified]

Glad that LINLYA did so well here! Absolutely adore that song.

[bboat11]

2. "The Bullet"

Album: Cry Pretty



Total: 207
Average: 10.35
Std Dev: 7.28


SHOOTER - 1
schnetzka - 2
tim - 3
fireflies - 3
someguy - 5
.indulgecountry - 6
castleoblivion26 - 6
musicfan134 - 6
taylor is terrified - 7
dgarcia3377 - 7
toomuchboy - 9
bigd79 - 9
lipe - 12
ClevelandRox - 12
zaclord 🌈 - 14
ccarter1023 - 16
carriefan15 - 20
Troublemaker - 22
bboat11 - 22
Typo - 25

---

1. "That's Where It Is"

Album: Some Hearts



Total: 136
Average: 6.8
Std Dev: 5.70 (2nd smallest!!)


tim - 1
musicfan134 - 1
zaclord 🌈 - 1
ccarter1023 - 1
fireflies - 2
castleoblivion26 - 2
dgarcia3377 - 2
taylor is terrified - 3
bboat11 - 3
Typo - 3
carriefan15 - 5
bigd79 - 8
ClevelandRox - 8
toomuchboy - 11
lipe - 11
someguy - 13
.indulgecountry - 14
schnetzka - 15
Troublemaker - 15
SHOOTER - 17

[castleoblivion26]

"The More Boys I Meet" overstayed by a lot. That song has always been a bit of a meh song to me. Don't hate it or anything but other than hearing it when listening to the album I never seek it out.

I have my #6 and #2 left and while I think my #1 should have been higher I struggled between my Top 2 for my #1. Carrie sounds fantastic with "Whenever You Remember" and "That's Where It Is". I also think that "The Bullet" is a great song that has slowly grown on me since the first time I've listened to it!

[bboat11]

There you have it! "The Bullet" and "That's Where It Is" proved to be the songs to beat, although the victory was realistically never going to go to anything other than "That's Where It Is".

Honestly, it makes sense that this would be such a blowout victory for TWII, because the constant expressing of the sentiment that this song deserved to be in the last album tracks rankdown is one of the biggest reasons why we did this sequel to begin with!

Thank you to everyone who participated! And thank you for bearing with me when I disappeared right after getting started! I hope you all still had fun!

[bboat11]

Final Recap:

30. O Come All Ye Faithful (435)
29. Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee (418)
28. Home Sweet Home (395)
27. Softly And Tenderly (387)
26. Because He Lives (384)
25. Thank God For Hometowns (369)
24. We're Young And Beautiful (359)
23. Who Are You (359)
22. Leave Love Alone (357)
21. That Song That We Used To Make Love To (353)

20. Little Girl Don't Grow Up Too Fast (349)
19. Nobody Ever Told You (348)
18. Kingdom (332)
17. Clock Don't Stop (331)
16. The Champion (312)
15. The Girl You Think I Am (309)
14. Change (308)
13. Sometimes You Leave (307)
12. Cupid's Got A Shotgun (293)
11. Wheel Of The World (284)

10. Mexico (273)
09. Crazy Dreams (261)
08. This Time (253)
07. Whenever You Remember (245)
06. Play On (242)
05. Unapologize (240)
04. The More Boys I Meet (239)
03. Like I'll Never Love You Again (215)
02. The Bullet (207)
01. That's Where It Is (136)

[ccarter1023]

The correct winner!! As always, thank you bboat11 for a very entertaining rankdown!!

[carriefan15]

Sept 26, 2021 16:28:46 GMT -5 bboat11 said:

Here's the top 5!!!!

Like I’ll Never Love You Again
That’s Where It Is
The Bullet
The More Boys I Meet
Unapologize


How do we think this is going to play out?!?!?!

Ok little late here but I promise I haven't seen any posts after this one just yet. 
Here is what I'm thinking!

5. Unapologize
4. The More Boys I Meet
3. The Bullet
2. Like I'll Never Love You Again
1. That's Where It Is

Also yayyyyyy at This Time making it so far!!!

Edit: great rankdown!!! Thanks for hosting!!!
Carrie's music videos next??? 😆 

[zaclord 🌈]

Thank goodness "That's Where It Is" won. It's the only song in this list that doesn't belong in this rankdown. With that said, very surprised by where many songs placed. This was neat to see how Carrie songs rank amongst each other when you take out all the good ones haha.

[SHOOTER]

🚮🚮🚮

Thanks for hosting anyway Bussy

[lipe]

Couldn't be here for the top10 announcement.
I'm glad the #10 was my least favorite out of them.
Love "Crazy Dreams" & "Play On"
I was shocked to see "The More Boys I Meet" made it to #4, I didn't think it would even be on the top10 or maybe 15. I love the song though and ranked it on my top3.
"Like I'll Never Love You Again" is so beautiful. From my top5 songs this was the one I thought could be on the actual top 5. Super stoked it was #3. Funny how the two #1 rankings were the last two entries!

The top2 were my #11 & #12 rankings so I didn't really have a preference here, although if I had to bet I would have guessed The Bullet would win. Didn't expect such a blowout. Both songs are very good and this is a solid top5 for me.

Thanks bboat11 for hosting, this was very fun as always!